8 ms·
This is fascinating and clever. But the cynic inside me fears it would never make a difference. First of all, one common statistic is that 90% of trash in the
by crazygringo 6y ago
This is fascinating and clever.
But the cynic inside me fears it would never make a difference. First of all, one common statistic is that 90% of trash in the ocean that comes from people dumping it (in rivers) comes from just 10 rivers, all in China/Asia.
And if they cared about the problem, they'd already be doing something about it. But it seems like they don't. Because the real solution there is the same as what is done in the first world -- to implement actual municipal trash pickup and urban trashcans etc. If they can't even do that, I have a hard time believing they'll bother with "bubble barriers".
So this seems like something first-world countries would implement... but that's not where the problem is.
But second, it's also common to hear that a large majority of overall ocean plastic comes from discarded industrial fishing gear -- nets and the like. Which this obviously does nothing for.
So while still very clever, I sadly don't think this could ever make a difference. We need to actually solve the much messier human problems of installing trash collection around the world and figuring out ways to monitor and punish fishers who discard their equipment.
- FeepingCreature 6y agoI don't follow. Because China don't even implement a countrywide logistics-heavy service branch, they won't bother with a cheaper, localized solution?
- crazygringo 6y agoThe countrywide logistics-heavy solution provides actual benefits to residents with cleaner cities and rivers. The catch-it-at-the-mouth-of-the-river one doesn't. It would still be expensive, but benefit only the ocean, not residents. So sadly, yes -- I can't imagine why they'd bother.
- nobodyandproud 6y agoThe Chinese do eat seafood. They don’t sacrifice growth for the environment, but passing up something relatively simple (and extremely clever) like this? I can’t think of why they wouldn’t try it.
- quirkot 6y agoThis is the opposite of a localized solution. It attempts to do waste collection at an aggregated point. Where does all the waste go that doesn't end up in river with managed waste collection, is the issue
- Hitton 6y agoThe ten rivers dumping 90% of plastic are in Asia and Africa. But Chinese trash is indeed big factor in more than half of the rivers.
- kijin 6y agoAnother big problem is that rivers in the developing world aren't particularly well controlled. Just this summer, a massive flood in the Yangtze basin displaced over 60 million people and inundated a number of large cities. The flood carries anything that will float downstream, and eventually dumps them in the ocean. As it happens, plastics tend to float pretty well. So even if the Chinese government declared that they will shoot anyone who throws trash in the rivers effective immediately, the rivers themselves come into people's homes, snatch plastics, and carry them into the ocean every year.
- sveme 6y agoLast year I was swimming in Corsica and every evening when the tide rolled in, the plastic rolled in as well. This is an island in the mediterranean, so lots of the plastic will probably come from first world, European countries, not Asia. Though I obviously cannot rule out that a lot of the plastic actually comes from the Nile.
- Bayart 6y agoMost of the plastic that comes to French shores is from Spanish land fills. They severely under recycle.
- rasz 6y agoCase in point, India: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XeDY3I841q0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XeDY3I841q0
- apacheCamel 6y ago>First of all, one common statistic is that 90% of trash in the ocean that comes from people dumping it (in rivers) comes from just 10 rivers, all in China/Asia. >So while still very clever, I sadly don't think this could ever make a difference. I get what you mean by this, but why can't these solutions be used in places that are willing to make a difference? Anywhere this is deployed is making a difference locally. In the grand scheme of the world, yes we do need some big solutions to get some places up to speed but if a bubble wall cleans up some of the 10% other plastic in the water, then I am all for it. We can't keep our heads in the sand over the 90%, but we need to be happy about the small victories we can get. I remember hearing about the machine that picks up trash in Baltimore at the Inner Harbor. It would take the current and push the trash into the machines conveyor belt. It was probably pick up a percent of a percent of the total world trash, but it made the harbor area much cleaner.
- gruez 6y ago>I get what you mean by this, but why can't these solutions be used in places that are willing to make a difference? Our efforts (and resources) might be better allocated in an area that has a bigger impact. This is basically the idea behind cap and trade. Why spend $10 to pick up 1 ton of plastic waste in the first world (made up numbers), when you can spend $10 to pick up 5 tons of plastic waste in asia? A more concrete example would be the water conservation measures in calfiornia a few years ago. The vast majority of the water usage is by agriculture, but residents were asked to engage in water saving practices (not watering laws, short showers, opt-in water at restaurants) at great inconvenience to them, even though any savings would be a drop in the bucket overall.
- apacheCamel 6y agoI see what you mean, but at the same point, the $10 to pick up 5 tons of plastic in Asia doesn't seem to be happening for whatever reason. My reasoning is that $10 to pick up 1 ton of plastic is still a good option since the $10 to pick up 5 tons is not a guarantee.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- lm28469 6y ago> First of all, one common statistic is that 90% of trash in the ocean that comes from people dumping it (in rivers) comes from just 10 rivers, all in China/Asia. > but that's not where the problem is. Maybe we should stop using them as our factories for 80% of the gadgets, tech, clothes, &c. we consume.
- cocoggu 6y agoI think there is now a real will from the chinese government to limit plastic pollution. For example, waste sorting started in Shanghai a year ago and started in Beijing last June [0]. This is not the usual waste sorting we are experiencing in Europe, for example, since you need to decline your identity and not make any mistake while sorting or you may get charged. Probably a bit too invasive (this is China after all) but more thorough for what I consider a good cause. Besides, the first bans on plastic use will take effect on January [1]. This is only for small items now, but this is a first step, and it also includes production of these items, which is especially impressive considering China supremacy on the production lines. [0] https://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/3016801/shanghai-begins-new-waste-sorting-era-china-eyes-cleaner-image https://www.scmp.com/news/china/society/article/3016801/shan... [1] https://www.scmp.com/business/china-business/article/3101241/no-plastic-bags-straws-or-hotel-shampoo-bottles-2025-china https://www.scmp.com/business/china-business/article/3101241...
- KSteffensen 6y agoAlso: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China%27s_waste_import_ban https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/China%27s_waste_import_ban A not insignificant part of the plastic thrown in rivers in South East Asia is consumed in Europe and the USA
- ars 6y ago> A not insignificant part of the plastic thrown in rivers in South East Asia is consumed in Europe and the USA I've heard this repeated many times, but every time I go searching for details I always come back with the same results: This is not true. The garbage in rivers is local. No one is shipping waste from Europe or USA, but some countries do buy recycling. But of course since they paid for the recycling, they have no interest in then dumping it. If you have some source showing different I'd be interested in seeing it.
- Xylakant 6y agoScientists say otherwise: https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/environment/plastic-for-recycling-from-europe-ends-up-in-asian-waters/ https://www.europeanscientist.com/en/environment/plastic-for...
- hwillis 6y agoThis is ignorant; China has in recent years taken a hard line on pollution of various kinds. They already put a moratorium on importing foreign trash (which was a huge source of river pollution) and are banning single use bags and straws: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-51171491 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-asia-china-51171491 Packaging like plastic bags are by far the biggest source of river waste: https://ourworldindata.org/plastic-pollution#plastic-waste-by-sector https://ourworldindata.org/plastic-pollution#plastic-waste-b... China currently produces ~60% of global oceanic plastic waste: https://ourworldindata.org/plastic-pollution#share-of-global-total-mismanaged-plastic-waste https://ourworldindata.org/plastic-pollution#share-of-global...
- azinman2 6y agoSo if China currently produces a majority of oceanic plastic waste, how hard a line could it be?
- jbay808 6y ago"if I'm hitting the accelerator hard, how could it be that I'm not currently moving fast?" I guess we'll see when they adopt these bubble barriers, or something similar.
- Dylan16807 6y ago"I've been holding the accelerator down hard for multiple minutes, why am I not moving fast?" They didn't start just a month or two ago. I share the skepticism of it being a "hard line".
- yholio 6y agoThe GP said that China/Asia produces 90%. You say China is at 60%, so if we add India and the rest of Southeast Asia, you are saying essentially the same thing. And while China might be starting to cleanup its act, India is fast urbanizing and increasing its waste production, with less investment in infrastructure. In a few years, the proportions might be swapped but the problem is not going away soon.
- hammock 6y ago>90% of trash in the ocean that comes from people dumping it (in rivers) comes from just 10 rivers, all in China/Asia So you're saying with bubble barriers in just 10 places (as opposed to all around the world), we can clean up 90% of ocean trash from dumping? That's amazing. A lot easier than trying to get China et al. to implement more "actual municipal trash pickup and urban trashcans etc." The first world could crowdfund the barriers. I'll help.
- MichaelZuo 6y agoIf there was a way to setup a nonprofit actually competent enough to carry this out, and maintain it, and fend off any local politicking that is bound to happen then this might be the fastest solution. Of course the difficulty is getting enough buy in from the countries with those rivers since using force is probably not possible.
- crazygringo 6y agoFor all the reasons you've stated, that's why it's simply not going to happen. Can you think of any major environmental project funded by foreigners that just goes in and successfully helps out? They don't work because they're seen as an affront to the nation's autonomy. It's not seen as help. It's seen as invasion. I'm not even joking: in Brazil most of the population believes that any effort by US private citizens/charities to purchase land in the Amazon to protect it is just a front to make a future US military invasion of the Amazon easier. It's ludicrous to Americans, but it's just "common sense" to Brazilians.
- twic 6y agoThe point is that those 10 places don't even need bubble barriers, they just need normal first-world refuse handling.
- chrischen 6y agoIsn’t our first world refuse handling to send it to the second world?
- Softcadbury 6y agoIt comes mainly from Asia because developed countries send their trashes there (in big polluting ships) to be "recycled", so depressing.
- jimmaswell 6y agoThis is why feel-good nonsense in 1st world countries like plastic bag taxes and banning plastic straws is infuriating.
- arcticfox 6y agoIs there a source on that actually being nonsense? I recognize that it might have a trivial effect overall given the global situation, but it still seems like a good step to me. I know next to nothing about this though, so I'm interested to hear more.
- jacobush 6y agoI was mildly against it, but now that it’s implemented I feel a little different about it. I think the main impact is going to be cultural - people are going to start feeling weird about using disposable plastic in everything. It’s going to nudge everyone just a little bit away from plastic. The kids growing up now, hardly ever seeing a plastic bag, will grow up to be designers in the future. Predisposed against plastic. I’m now mildly for banning plastic bags. Where paper is not yet optimal, we will eventually iron out the kinks with engineering and science.
- unethical_ban 6y agoYou deny the concept of collective impact. One person using a plastic straw isn't a big deal. Three hundred million people using a few dozen straws per year is additive. Same with all disposables. Furthermore, ocean pollution isn't the only kind. Look at any urban creek/bayou bank after a hard rain and look at the trash that is washed up in the grass. The right-wing pejorative is "virtue-signalling" but is that always bad? Is it bad to set an example, a cultural marker, that we want to encourage re-use and biodegradable materials? This is not an either-or.
- blacksmith_tb 6y agoI agree, but I would say the danger is that people will feel like they have now done their part - "My straw is waxed paper! I'm not destroying the planet!" when in fact plenty of other things in their day-to-day lives have a much larger impact - insulating your home would do more for the world by orders of magnitude (admittedly that doesn't keep straws out of sealife, but choose your battles?)
- itronitron 6y agoWhat's nice about this solution is that it's not trying to change people's behaviors. Instead, by angling (no pun intended) the bubble barrier across the current the rivers and canals can be used to sort the plastics into recycling bins.
- lozenge 6y agoInstalling a bubble barrier could be a lot easier than solving plastic pollution all the way along the river in a country with endemic corruption.
- rdiddly 6y agoI wouldn't call that cynical, just a recognition that the "missing ingredients" in any plan usually turn out to be leadership, courage, compassion etc., not technology.
- RandallBrown 6y agoSo if those countries don't care about their rivers spewing plastic into the oceans, could a billionaire simply pay to build one of these things and then pay boats to clean up the waste it collects? I wonder what it would cost to just put one of these in somewhere and run it. (Including all the bribes/lobbying to allow it to be built in the first place)
- bobloblaw45 6y agoIt gives me a strong "solar freaking roadway" vibe. I feel like there has to be some details missing that makes a huge difference.
- wenc 6y ago> First of all, one common statistic is that 90% of trash in the ocean that comes from people dumping it (in rivers) comes from just 10 rivers, all in China/Asia. Just thought I'd factcheck this: turns out this statement is not accurate. The original paper [1] lists the countries, and two of them are in Africa, 4 are in China, 1 is on the China-Russia border. Jurisdictionally, there seems to be a few parties involved and the insinuation that "they" don't care about the problem seems like an oversimplification and a projection. Secondly, that snapshot was a while ago and assuming that nothing hasn't been done since then is also incorrect [2]. I have to admit I felt uncomfortable with the cultural assumption expressed in the sentiment about "having a hard time believe they'll bother with bubble barriers". It felt a little presumptuous because it assumes a culture is immutable. The sentiment that these types of solutions are something "only first world countries would implement" also seems a little bit dismissive. I work with people in non-first-world countries every day (I work in a global company) and have often been surprised how ahead of the curve they can be in certain areas, and I've learned not to make assumptions without first informing myself of the true situation on the ground (which is often more complex and nuanced than the tropes we have in our heads). [1] https://pubs.acs.org/doi/suppl/10.1021/acs.est.7b02368/suppl_file/es7b02368_si_001.pdf https://pubs.acs.org/doi/suppl/10.1021/acs.est.7b02368/suppl... [2] https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/06/90-of-plastic-polluting-our-oceans-comes-from-just-10-rivers/ https://www.weforum.org/agenda/2018/06/90-of-plastic-polluti...