14 ms·
Advocates want to name heatwaves like hurricanes to raise awareness of dangers
- johnday 6y agoSounds like a good idea. It might be harder to delineate when a heatwave is worthy of being named, but I'm sure the Met office (or the equivalent across the Atlantic) can manage it. That said, I'm not convinced that giving it a name is enough to make people consider it dangerous.
- dylan604 6y agoDon't we anthropomorphize things to make them more friendly? Here comes Heatwave Henry III. Everybody wave back! Hopefully, he won't be nearly as bad as that evil Henry II.
- leetrout 6y agoI am not a fan. We’re heading to naming all the major weather which happens often and is just going to desensitize people. The NOAA already doesn’t recognize winter storm names and I would expect them to use the same rationale for not naming heat waves, cold waves or any other extreme weather events that don’t bring destruction. (Not arguing against the danger of heatwaves).
- Cthulhu_ 6y agoThat's exactly it, it's the "boy crying wolf" issue and everyone will just shrug. I found them starting to give "regular" storms already overly dramatic, or that they have started to hand out "yellow", "orange" weather alerts. Those are just not actionable for me as an average regular citizen. Mind you they probably mean that measures are being put in place for others though.
- elmo2you 6y agoI fully agree with that, but I think it's a manifestation of a far wider trend that might be far more worrying. In this age of information overload, where the struggle for people's attention has become nothing short of warfare, I see both advocacy groups and commercial entities ever so further seek to dramatise their message, just to "maximize their reach" and not get drowned out in the sea of other sensationalized/polarized information. While this motivation or a even sense of need is understandable, with everyone "competing" only for their own interests in relationship to everything else, it essentially is a race to the bottom. The (psychological) effects of it do (already) go a bit further than people just shrugging. On the population as a whole, it (significantly) increases stress levels, general distrust (certainly warranted), and maybe even cause a constant sense of danger or a believe that this world has gone mad. The effects of which should not be underestimated. All of which can cause both individuals and groups of people to make really poor decisions.
- luckylion 6y agoIt's essentially the tragedy of the commons, with the commons being the audience's attention and stress level.
- finnthehuman 6y agoPeople have a bad relationship with the uncertainty of forecasts, I think it's the most inescapable example of how the media's incompetence and desire for attention should be considered malice. The boy crying wolf effect is a result of a media that can't even inform viewers how to weigh a weather forecast. The NWS has been issuing forecasts for over 100 years, and their predictive accuracy moves at a glacial timescale compared to anything else in the news. If they can't competently communicate THAT, what the hell can they effectively inform us about?
- tosser0001 6y agoI think they're a bit to aggressive in naming tropical storms as it is. Currently any tropical storm that reaches 39mph/63kph gets a name, which to me is pretty low threshold. Maybe if every two-bit storm didn't get a name people would pay a bit more attention.
- shireboy 6y agoAgree. Maybe I'm too cynical, but I strongly suspect this is more motivated by weather news marketing and ad revenue strategy than an altruistic desire to "raise awareness".
- sandworm101 6y agoThere is a practical use for the names. It isn't all marketing. Internally, a hurricane starts as a little swirl on the other side of the ocean and is watched/tracked as an interesting object. Designators are used to track these structures. They are given formal names at a particular point once they hit certain milestones. This naming triggers certain processes (more attention, greater tracking fidelity, inclusion in daily briefs etc). These are no different than military operations, which have to be of a particular size before they are formally 'named'. The fact that the media promulgates these internal designators to the public is but an extension of a useful internal process.
- phkahler 6y ago>> This naming triggers certain processes (more attention, greater tracking fidelity, inclusion in daily briefs etc). Right, but you mention the key thing places like The Weather Channel want - increased attention via daily briefs. The public doesn't need that, TWC does.
- sandworm101 6y agoThey might appear to want it, but I think the weather channel simply takes whatever is available. With hours of time to fill each day, they will make hay with whatever data the government weather people put on the website.
- leetrout 6y agoNot quite true. > In November 2012, TWC began naming winter storms ... > The U.S. government-operated National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) ... and ... the National Weather Service (NWS)—did not acknowledge TWC's winter storm names and asked its forecast offices to refrain from using the TWC names > The National Weather Service has since stated that "no plans to consider naming winter storms" are in progress.[25] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winter_storm_naming_in_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Winter_storm_naming_in_the_Uni...
- HumblyTossed 6y ago> I am not a fan. We’re heading to naming all the major weather which happens often and is just going to desensitize people. I agree. This is just going to turn into a media nightmare and people will simply tune out.
- fatnoah 6y ago>I am not a fan. Also agree. I've stopped watching the Weather Channel because I can't stand all of the stupid storm names. Naming everything doesn't raise awareness, it just creates fatigue and reduces the impact of "named == you'd better pay attention".
- Zenst 6y ago> I am not a fan. We’re heading to naming all the major weather which happens often and is just going to desensitize people. I have to concur and the prospect of some small town having a welcome Heatwave Karen parade is one that will sadly only go to normalise attitudes towards climate change and may even become counter productive. More so as the demographic they are going for that would warm to naming such weather events are equally more inclined to be less believing of climate change.
- tejado 6y agoIn germany, the high pressure areas are named after male names and low pressure after female names: https://www.bavariannews.com/blog/2018/10/03/how-storms-in-germany-get-their-names/ https://www.bavariannews.com/blog/2018/10/03/how-storms-in-g...
- svara 6y agoAs the article you cited points out, this has been changed in 1998. Low pressure areas get male names in odd years and female names in even years; vice versa for high pressure areas.
- dylan604 6y agogreat, that's not confusing at all. hmm, i'm seeing a warning. i should know what to do. wait, what year is it? damn, if only i could remember even/odd male/female cycles. oh well, best if i just ignore it and carry on with my day. at least it's not a tuesday. i never got the hang of tuesday.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- arnvald 6y agoHalf-jokingly: let's give them some scary sounding, hellish names. Hurricane Benedict sounds like a friendly neighbour. Heatwave Astaroth - that's some serious stuff right here.
- bryanrasmussen 6y agoAs long as we're half-joking: future headline prompting mass-murder if your suggestion taken up - Local Church announces NOAA aligned with Satan, heatwave caused by federal government trying to hasten onset of the antichrist!
- throwanem 6y agoThat's practically slander. Honestly, I don't think Christians even deserve to complain about climate disasters, not with all the effort they put into worshiping an incredibly priggish and unbelievably prudish deity for which weather-powered slaughterfests have always been such a go-to. And I mean say what you like about Ishtar, at least she gets that people are gonna fuck.
- Waterfall 6y agoAre you suggesting that in Christianity they don't have sex? Sex is important in all religions, or their populations would die.
- throwanem 6y agoOf course they do. They'd just rather they didn't and no one else did either, thanks to their god's hangups as codified by a Roman with some pretty fierce hangups of his own. Hence all the interest in cloning and brain uploading and so forth.
- zez61 6y agoWhat is the purpose of this comment? Keying off a random deity figure you’re replying to, you decided 9am on a Monday morning on Hacker News seems like a pretty good time to spout off hateful and discriminatory feelings about “they” the religious group? They don’t deserve to talk about climate change because they’re prudish in your interpretation of things? Seriously, what the shit are you talking about? Christians live on this planet too and have a stake in its future. I’m completely nonreligious and have my own gripes with religion in the broad, by the way, so if I’m checking you, you’re way off the deep end. I can see why HN is resistant to humour, because there are a remarkable number of people who can operate Vim but can’t for the life of them figure out a joke without punching down people who aren’t them (or making light of mass shooting events and conspiratorial delusions right upthread). Suggested HN guideline: Humour is best avoided and left to those with enough empathy to understand when their “sense of humour” is really a catastrophic case of toxic, unpleasant person who thinks their take is hilarious and has enough people around them enabling them to not know any better.
- adenner 6y agoIn the US the weather channel tried to do the same thing for winter storms. No one else pays any attention to their names at all.
- downshun 6y agoGive natural disasters a CVE code
- DudeInBasement 6y agoSmart man, smart solution
- Sebb767 6y agoAnd the bigger ones get a punny name, a logo, an information website with a half description screaming doomsday - and Merch, of course ;)
- gjvnq 6y agoEven better, let's give them descriptive systematic names just like IUPAC does to molecules!
- whymauri 6y agoI'm from Florida, and I think this is a good idea. Giving our hurricanes names helps cement them in the collective conscious of the region, and it definitely helps with awareness during early schooling. I don't think having names for hurricanes ever desensitized me to them. The main driver for desensitization is time. It's either been so long since the last catastrophic hurricane that you're underestimating how bad they can get, or you've seen so many Cat <=3 hurricanes that you literally don't consider them a threat (a classic mistake, since they can gain strength so quickly).
- Spooky23 6y agoI agree with you — one thing that is different with hurricanes is that every one is a different distinct event and when talking about a hurricane it’s important to distinguish between specific storms. Even snowstorms are pretty much cut and dry. If it snows a lot, it sucks for a couple of days. The biggest variable is the competence of whomever is plowing. With heat, forget it. “Heatwave Harry” vs “Coldsnap Sally” are exactly the same — there is no variance in hazard. Bad things happen at specific known extreme temperatures.
- Jiocus 6y agoHas there been any research into general population behaviour when faced with unnamed vs named events? My first thought is that anthropomorphizing dangerous weather phenomena to neutral-sounding beings could downplay their dreadful potential. People seem rational enough to dehumanize mostly anything (or anyone) else they perceive as a threat. In fiction, writers use sinister names of characters, as a warning to the reader to prepare for the protagonists inevitable trial later on.
- Waterfall 6y agoThey sure do! (Only if the names are female.)
- LanceH 6y agoThe evidence of climate change isn't about some place being warm. That would make some place being cool counter-evidence. I've already seen this play out with multiple years of seeing one side screech, "look how hot it is" and the other, "this winter is cold."
- krapp 6y agoHow about not naming weather events at all? We shouldn't have to anthropomorphize something before people consider it a threat, like telling children to go to bed or the boogeyman will get them. Asian countries tend to assign typhoons a sequential id but they're still somehow cognizant of the danger.
- _ph_ 6y agoNaming large weather events makes a lot of sense. Hurricanes are very good example of that. They are actual entities which behavior gets tracked. It is much easier for the public to keep up to date, when there is an easy to remember name.
- krapp 6y agoBut does it matter to the public whether they roads are closed due to Irene or Jacques? Admittedly, the names are catchier but I'm not certain they're necessary to convey information. It's not as if they have to keep track of a dozen hurricanes at a time.
- _ph_ 6y agoGiving a hurricane a name raises awareness. When a named hurricane is coming, people have a very clear sign, that they should spend attention. Having the name, also makes following the events easier. So it would be quite logical to name other similar dangers.
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoWhile we are at it, can we change some vocabulary used for sensitising climate change from 'For the planet' to 'Your children will die soon, your grandchildren sooner'?
- bzb5 6y agoHow certain is that, given that according to previous predictions the Earth should currently be uninhabitable?
- cochne 6y agoWhich predictions are you referring to?
- bakedbeanz 6y agoBy all means, provide us with reputable sources that claim "the Earth should currently be uninhabitable". We'll wait.
- xenspidey 6y agoNot OP but a quick google search. https://www.aei.org/carpe-diem/18-spectacularly-wrong-predictions-made-around-the-time-of-first-earth-day-in-1970-expect-more-this-year-3/ https://www.aei.org/carpe-diem/18-spectacularly-wrong-predic...
- Brakenshire 6y agoSo of the 18 predictions none are from climatologists, none are in published research but rather in comments to magazines and speeches, and half are from 2 people, Paul Erlich (a biologist) and Kenneth Watt (an ecologist). And some of them are not even wrong, for instance concerns about population growth or rainforest loss at the rate it was occurring at the time. The headline here is “some random scientists were wrong about something 50 years ago”. The fact the comparison is even made between these comments and the published evidence base for climate change, indicates more about the person making the criticism than the target of the criticism. These are the same kind of people who think that political commentators on rolling news are making a meaningful contribution to scientific debate.
- nemo44x 6y agoAre we going to officially name every tornado? Every earthquake? The article leads with “we need more drama...” - I think we have enough, thank you. We need to consider the psychological affects of these things. We already stir people into collective panics for so many things. Do we need to add another? People need less anxiety in their lives.
- TheRealSteel 6y agoWe ABSOLUTELY need to make people panic about heatwaves. We need to make people lose sleep about it. Get distracted by it. Feel sick about. Climate change is going to kill millions if we don't act hard, and fast. We need a global, coordinated, war-like effort immediately to prevent the displacement of billions and a new world war. Coronavirus lockdown is not even going to be a blip on the radar compared to life on this planet if we don't start removing carbon from the atmosphere on a global scale. The fact that it's inconvenient for your stress levels is irrelevant.
- chrisseaton 6y agoWe want effective solutions. Panic, sleep deprivation, making people feel sick and stressed is not the way to get those.
- take_a_breath 6y agoCouldn’t any form of bad news make people panic, sleep deprived, and stressed? I don’t think communicating the science or real world impacts is too hard for people to handle. If it is, we are going to have a lot more problems as the climate continues to warm. Edit: We told citizens about Pearl Harbor and 9/11 attacks and it caused panic, sleep depravation, and stress. Why is this risk different?
- chrisseaton 6y ago> Couldn’t any form of bad news make people panic, sleep deprived, and stressed? Yes... and that's unavoidable but the person I'm replying to is talking about deliberately inducing more panic, sleep deprivation and stress by increasing the dramatics of bad news. That seems bonkers to me. > I don’t think communicating the science or real world impacts is too hard for people to handle. I don't think giving dangerous heatwaves whimsical names is any kind of honest 'science communication.' > We told citizens about Pearl Harbor and 9/11 attacks and it caused panic, sleep depravation, and stress. Why is this risk different? I think you've imagined that I wrote 'don't tell people about the risks'. I wrote don't artificially ham it up to deliberately cause additional stress. What you want is people taking effective action. Panic, sleep deprivation, and stress isn't the way to get there.
- RegBarclay 6y agoThey lost me at "We need more drama..." No, I do not think we need more drama.
- thrownaway954 6y agoi'm sorry to say but all this will do is desensitize people further. it used to be that when they named a storm it was going to be bad and you paid attention. now they name every damn storm out there and it just makes you tune out.
- roamerz 6y agoWhile we are at it we should name some of these west coast fires after the politicians who have supported shutting down the forests to sensible resource management.
- umvi 6y agoYet west coast politicians want to stop calling them "wild fires" in favor of a new term "climate fires". So the question is, how much of these wildfires are due to climate change, and how much is due to bad forest "resource management" (not sure what this entails - preventing more frequent smaller fires with firefighting which causes bigger fires years later?) and how much to some other reason (water table depletion, etc)?
- liability 6y agoPremature attribution of cause to a fire also seems potentially harmful to arson investigations.
- simonsarris 6y agoPre-1800, about 1.8 million ha burned each year in CA: https://www.sierraforestlegacy.org/Resources/Conservation/FireForestEcology/FireScienceResearch/FireHistory/FireHistory-Stephens07.pdf https://www.sierraforestlegacy.org/Resources/Conservation/Fi... > Approximately 1.8 million ha burned annually in California prehistorically (pre 1800). Our estimate of prehistoric annual area burned in California is 88% of the total annual wildfire area in the entire US during a decade (1994–2004) characterized as ‘‘extreme’’ regarding wildfires. The idea that US wildfire area of approximately two million ha annually is extreme is certainly a 20th or 21st century perspective. Skies were likely smoky much of the summer and fall in California during the prehistoric period. See also: https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rstb.2015.0345 https://royalsocietypublishing.org/doi/full/10.1098/rstb.201... > Many consider wildfire as an accelerating problem [...] however, important exceptions aside, the quantitative evidence available does not support these perceived overall trends.
- wtvanhest 6y ago
- freddealmeida 6y agoI think this may be a misconception that names raise awareness. In Japan, typhoons and large storms (tsunami..) get scientific names. However awareness is quite well represented in the population. I think what you need to change is how information is distributed in a culture that is more focused on video/music than reading. As well, tying this back into the costs they may face if they ignore it (fear sells) However since we are now entering a solar minimum (entered?) I think this problem will disappear in the next few decades (or centuries). The question is does this problem need to be tackled with this new paradigm?
- ck2 6y agohow about a name for when the air quality on the entire westcoast becomes very dangerous for anyone with lung problems, asthma, COPD, post-covid, etc. https://www.purpleair.com/map?opt=1/mAQI/a10/cC0#2.56/28.39/-87.34 https://www.purpleair.com/map?opt=1/mAQI/a10/cC0#2.56/28.39/...
- Proven 6y agoOh, how innovative - psychops against the non compliant! It can only raise the level of annoyance (already very high) at this point.
- scythe 6y agoI think this is a better idea than naming winter storms, the comparison we seem to have settled on. The first criterion is coherence: a hurricane has a (somewhat) well-defined magnitude while frontal systems have different intensity in different places, highly subject to geography. A heat wave is more well-defined than a front but less than a hurricane. However, the more important thing to know is that extreme heat is already the deadliest form of weather event in the United States and will likely get worse in the coming years. Being able to put a name to the phenomenon that killed your grandmother has a powerful psychological effect. See: https://weather.com/safety/news/2019-09-17-top-cause-weather-fatalities-nws-cwa-united-states-map https://weather.com/safety/news/2019-09-17-top-cause-weather...
- cos2pi 6y agoIt's worth mentioning here that heatwaves are the leading cause of weather-related death in the US for the past 30 years. https://www.weather.gov/hazstat https://www.weather.gov/hazstat I'm not advocating for the personification of all extreme weather events, but the lethality of heatwaves is often overlooked.
- mrmuagi 6y agoIt doesn't kill you directly, but the vulnerable are easy prey (elderly, immobile, etc.). A story that was shared with me about the lethality of heat was basically an overweight individual fell off his mobility scooter and was knocked unconscious, and just cooked to death.
- DataGata 6y agoI am terrified of a hurricane knocking out power throughout Florida followed by even a mild heatwave. Nursing homes could barely handle keeping their staff from going to the bars and getting Covid- are we to believe they are prepared to deal with hundreds of cheaply built old-person dorms turned into sous vides?
- gravy 6y agoWhat if they just assigned "categories" like they do to Hurricanes?
- 11235813213455 6y agoWe should have extended lockdowns for each heatwave
- cmurf 6y agoIt's worked for malware, hasn't it?