5 ms·
Personally I say abolish the electoral colleges to ensure that every vote actually matters. That alone will reduce voter apathy and get more people actually out
by dheera 6y ago
Personally I say abolish the electoral colleges to ensure that every vote actually matters. That alone will reduce voter apathy and get more people actually out there voting.
- nradov 6y agoSounds good. Now how do we make that happen? Complaints about the Electoral College are rather meaningless without a realistic proposal for a Constitutional amendment that could achieve the necessary level of political support.
- striking 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Popular_Vote_Interstate_Compact https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/National_Popular_Vote_Intersta... already exists and is 73% of the way to coming into effect. No need for amendments when you have clever legal hackery!
- GeneralMayhem 6y agoIt's the last 20% that's the hardest, though (apart from the first 1%). No state with Republican leadership will ever sign it, because they know that they depend on minority rule. That means that the Democrats effectively have to run enough states to control the Electoral College anyway, and winning enough branches of a state legislature to pass laws is generally more difficult than winning that state in a presidential election. The one thing that's working in favor of the NPVIC happening is that it doesn't have to happen all at once, but that's a double-edged sword - if we get a state or two in the purpleish zone to sign on one year, but it's not enough to get to 270, then they could repeal it the next year. In particular, it'll be really interesting to see what happens if/when we get to the point where any state joining the NPVIC would push it over the edge. Would that state waver knowing that they're going to be the ones to press the big red button? You also have the judiciary to worry about. It's not obvious that the NPVIC is constitutional, and I highly doubt that the current Supreme Court, packed as it is with activist right-wing judges, would let it happen.
- jackcosgrove 6y ago> You also have the judiciary to worry about. It's not obvious that the NPVIC is constitutional Interstate compacts without the blessing of the federal government are unconstitutional. This is because the federal government has sovereign power over interstate relations, and a bloc of states that coordinate action are effectively challenging that sovereign power. So if the NPVIC is passed, it would also need to be approved by federal legislation to be deemed constitutional.
- nradov 6y agoThere are already interstate compacts over water rights without the blessing of the Federal government. I don't think those have ever been found unconstitutional.
- jackcosgrove 6y agoThose don't encroach on federal power like the selection of the president would. The Compact Clause is pretty clear and the courts have ruled that congressional approval is required for any compact that encroaches on federal power. The selection of the president is a bright line issue of federal power.
- rrauenza 6y agoConsider that our current president is a populist and it could be argued that he only didn't win the popular vote because he didn't focus on that, but rather on the electoral college. I think the founding fathers would cite our current president as the reason they didn't trust direct democracy... It's food for thought whenever I think about pushing more towards direct democracy. I've been leaning towards proportional electoral votes, but there are so many unintended consequences.
- ultramundane8 6y agoI really can't grant that first paragraph in good faith without some evidence. How could you possibly divine the intent of the 2016 Trump campaign? We still can't agree on a vast number of its actions, let alone its strategy.
- kthejoker2 6y agoYou want evidence that Trump 1) didn't try to win the popular vote i.e. specifically did not court the votes of certain people 2) In order to run as a populist i.e. shore up votes from his base 3) because the Electoral College system supports just such a strategy, such that winning 51% of a few states while only getting 45% of the vote Well, other than his entire campaign, the clearest evidence I can give is this in the face of actual polling numbers indicating that #1 and #2 had come to pass in the summer of 2016, the campaign's advertising dollars focused almost exclusively on the Obama states he ended up flipping.
- rrauenza 6y agoA fairer statement might be its a red herring to criticize any campaign for not getting the popular vote when that's not the game they are playing to win. But you're right -- he might never have actually gotten a popular vote.
- joshuamorton 6y ago> it could be argued that he only didn't win the popular vote because he didn't focus on that, This is exceedingly unlikely. At least not without major platform changes. A trump that appeals to an additional 3-5 million people looks significantly different. > I think the founding fathers would cite our current president as the reason they didn't trust direct democracy This makes even less sense, a more direct democracy (proportional approtianmemt in the house and senate) would be a much stronger check on an unpopular president. What you're seeing now is what happens when the value of votes are distributed unevenly, such that a party can appeal to a minority while retaining political power. That said even if it were the case, a popular vote would have other useful far reaching consequences in terms of how federal funding is apportioned.