3 ms·
For the people in this thread gleefully calculating the absurd energies required to achieve miniscule thrusts, please remember two things: 1) The version in th
by jiggawatts 6y ago
For the people in this thread gleefully calculating the absurd energies required to achieve miniscule thrusts, please remember two things:
1) The version in the lab and the device that would actually be used for satellite production are very different. The lab version is not designed for efficiency. It's designed to be easy to manufacture and test, using simple, well-characterised technologies. For one, a production design would use a superconducting cavity for much better efficiencies, easily 100 to 10,000x better.
2) Miniscule propellentless thrusts are still useful with solar power. Satellite stationkeeping is largely limited by the finite propellent capacity onboard. Even Xenon plasma thrusters, the most efficient currently available, run out of fuel eventually.
Now, I'm not saying the EmDrive works, I'm just pointing out that it's a distraction talking about the efficiency or utility of a "benchtop experiment".
- Dylan16807 6y agoI dunno about 1, it sounds like the extreme inefficiency makes it extremely hard to get numbers stable enough to do a test with.