4 ms·
RISC-V still seems too ad-hoc to me, and really new. Hard to say where it'd go for now. I know momentum is currently towards ARM over POWER, but... OpenPOWER i
by dragontamer 6y ago
RISC-V still seems too ad-hoc to me, and really new. Hard to say where it'd go for now.
I know momentum is currently towards ARM over POWER, but... OpenPOWER is certainly a thing, and has IBM / Red Hat support. IBM may be expensive, but they already were proven "fair partners" in the OpenPOWER initiative and largely supportive of OSS / Free Software.
- ChuckMcM 6y agoI would love OpenPOWER to succeed. I just don't see the 48 pin QFP version that costs < $1 and powers billions of gizmos. For me the ARM ecosystem's biggest win is that it scales from really small (M0/M0+) to really usefully big (A78) and has many points between those two architectures. I don't see OpenPOWER going there, but I can easily see RISC-V going there. So, for the moment, that is the horse I'm betting on.
- dragontamer 6y agoNot quite 48-pin QFP chips, but 257-pin embedded is still smaller than Rasp. Pi. (Just searched what NXP's newest Power-chip is, and its a S32R274: 2MB 257-pin BGA. Definitely "embedded" size, but not as small as Cortex-M0) To be honest, I don't think that NVidia/ARM will screw over their Cortex-M0 or Cortex-M0+ customers over. I'm more worried about the higher-end, whether or not NVidia will "play nice" with its bigger rivals (Apple, Intel, AMD) in the datacenter.
- exikyut 6y agoThe FS32R274VCK2VMM appears to be the cheapest in this series; Digi-Key have it for $30, NXP has it for "$13 @ 10K". This is for a 200MHz part. https://www.nxp.com/part/FS32R274VCK2VMM https://www.nxp.com/part/FS32R274VCK2VMM https://www.digikey.com/product-detail/en/nxp-usa-inc/FS32R274VCK2VMM/FS32R274VCK2VMM-ND/7645581 https://www.digikey.com/product-detail/en/nxp-usa-inc/FS32R2... The two related devkits list for $529 and $4,123: https://www.digikey.com/products/en/development-boards-kits-programmers/evaluation-boards-embedded-mcu-dsp/786?k=S32R274 https://www.digikey.com/products/en/development-boards-kits-... -- Those processors make quite a few reference to an "e200", which I think is the CPU architecture. I discovered that Digi-Key lists quite a few variants of this under Core Processor; and checking the datasheets of some random results suggests that they are indeed Power architecture parts. https://www.digikey.com/products/en/integrated-circuits-ics/embedded-microcontrollers/685?FV=-8%7C685%2C506%7C342439%2C506%7C342440%2C506%7C342441%2C506%7C342442%2C506%7C342443%2C506%7C342444%2C506%7C342445%2C506%7C342446%2C506%7C342447%2C506%7C342448%2C506%7C342449%2C506%7C342450%2C506%7C342451%2C506%7C342452%2C506%7C342453%2C506%7C342454%2C506%7C342455%2C506%7C342472%2C506%7C431926%2C506%7C431928&quantity=0&ColumnSort=1000011&page=1&pageSize=25 https://www.digikey.com/products/en/integrated-circuits-ics/... The cheapest option appears to be the $2.67@1000, up-to-48MHz SPC560D40L1B3E0X with 256KB ECC RAM. Selecting everything >100MHz finds the $7.10@1000 SPC560D40L1B3E0X, an up-to-120MHz part that adds 1MB flash (128KB ECC RAM). Restricting to >=200MHz finds the $13.32@500 SPC5742PK1AMLQ9R has which has dual cores at 200MHz, 384KB ECC RAM and 2.5MB flash, and notes core lock-step. -- After discovering the purpose of the "view prices at" field, the landscape changes somewhat. https://www.digikey.com/products/en/integrated-circuits-ics/embedded-microcontrollers/685?FV=143%7C100399%2C143%7C105872%2C143%7C114552%2C143%7C114561%2C143%7C140510%2C143%7C147811%2C143%7C153451%2C143%7C160669%2C143%7C182367%2C143%7C213330%2C143%7C77976%2C143%7C79202%2C143%7C84100%2C143%7C85683%2C143%7C90674%2C143%7C94618%2C143%7C95635%2C506%7C342439%2C506%7C342440%2C506%7C342441%2C506%7C342442%2C506%7C342443%2C506%7C342444%2C506%7C342445%2C506%7C342446%2C506%7C342447%2C506%7C342448%2C506%7C342449%2C506%7C342450%2C506%7C342451%2C506%7C342452%2C506%7C342453%2C506%7C342454%2C506%7C342455%2C506%7C342472%2C506%7C431926%2C506%7C431928%2C-8%7C685&quantity=1&ColumnSort=1000011&page=1&pageSize=25 https://www.digikey.com/products/en/integrated-circuits-ics/... The SPC574S64E3CEFAR (https://www.st.com/resource/en/datasheet/spc574s64e3.pdf https://www.st.com/resource/en/datasheet/spc574s64e3.pdf) is 140MHz, has 1.5MB code + 64KB data flash and 96KB+32KB data RAM, and is available for $14.61 per 1ea. The SPC5744PFK1AMLQ9 (https://www.nxp.com/docs/en/data-sheet/MPC5744P.pdf https://www.nxp.com/docs/en/data-sheet/MPC5744P.pdf) is $20.55@1, 200MHz, 2.5MB ECC flash, 384KB ECC RAM, and has two cores that support lockstep. The MPC5125YVN400 (https://www.nxp.com/docs/en/product-brief/MPC5125PB.pdf https://www.nxp.com/docs/en/product-brief/MPC5125PB.pdf) is $29.72@1, 400MHz, supports DDR2@200MHz (only has 32KB onboard (S)RAM), and supports external flash. (I wonder if you could boot Linux on this thing?)
- rvense 6y agoThese are all basically ten-year-old parts, aren't they?
- dragontamer 6y agoThey're all low end embedded parts with highly integrated peripherals. Basically: a microcontroller. No different than say, Cortex-M0 or M0+ in many regards (although ARM scales down to lower spec'd pieces).
- ChuckMcM 6y agoYes but hey, the core ARM ISA is like 40 years old. The key is that they are in fact "low cost SoCs" which is not something I knew existed :-). Its really too bad the dev boards are so expensive but I get you need a lot of layers to route that sort of BGA.
- rvense 6y agoSure, the ARM ISA is old, but a few things have happened in microarchitecture since then. I wouldn't be rushing to use a 10-year-old ARM over a newer one. The Cortex cores are pretty great compared to ARM9 or whatever.
- dragontamer 6y agoThe ARM Cortex-M3 was released in 2006 and is still a popular microcontroller core. Microcontrollers have a multi-decade long lifespan. (I'm still seeing new 8051-based designs...) There are still new chips using the Cortex-M3 today. Microcontroller devs do NOT want to be changing their code that often. New chips move the core to lower-and-cheaper process nodes (and lower the power consumption), while otherwise retaining the same overall specifications and compatibility.
- na85 6y agoI miss DIP chips that would fit on breadboards. I don't have steady enough hands to solder QFP onto a PCB, and I'm too cheap to buy an oven :(
- Ecco 6y agoYou’re supposed to drag-solder those. Look it up on YouTube, it’s super easy. The hardest part is positioning the chip, but it’s actually easier than with an oven, because you can rework it if you only solder one or two pins :)
- na85 6y agoWow, just looked up a video and some guy did an 0.5mm pitch chip pretty darn quickly. Thank you!
- Ecco 6y agoYou’re welcome! Also, flux. Lots of it. Buy some good one, and use tons of it. Then clean the hell out of your PCB!
- IshKebab 6y agoThere's an even easier way than drag soldering - just solder it normally, without worrying about bridges. You can put tons of solder on it. The use some desoldering braid to soak up the excess solder. It will remove all the bridges and leave perfect joints.
- ChuckMcM 6y agohttps://www.digikey.com/catalog/en/partgroup/smt-breakout-pcb-for-48-qfn-or-48-tqfp/57383 https://www.digikey.com/catalog/en/partgroup/smt-breakout-pc... can help. I have hand soldered STM32s to this adapter (use flux, a small tip)
- foldr 6y agoA cheap toaster oven or hot air tool works fine for these. Or, as others have said, a regular soldering iron with lots of flux.
- awill 6y agothe war is over. Arm has won. That dominance will take a long time to fade. AWS and Apple's future is Arm.
- darksaints 6y agoOpenPOWER is pretty awesome but would be nowhere near as awesome as an OpenItanium. IMHO, Itanium was always mismarketed and misoptimized. It made a pretty good server processor, but not so good that enterprises were willing to migrate 40 year old software to run on it. In mobile form, it would have made a large leap in both performance and battery life. And it would have been a fairly easy market to break into: the average life of a mobile device is a few years, not a few decades. Recompilation and redistribution of software is the status quo.
- drivebycomment 6y agoItanuim deserved its fiery death and resurrection doesn't make any sense whatsoever. It's a dead end architecture, and humanity gained (by freeing up valuable engineering power to other more useful endeavors) when it died.
- darksaints 6y agoItanium was an excellent idea that needed investment in compilers. Nobody wanted to make that investment because speculative execution got them 80% of the way there without the investment in compilers. But as it turns out, speculative execution was a phenomenally bad idea, and patching its security vulnerabilities has set back processor performance to the point where VLIW seems like a good idea again. We should have made those compiler improvements decades ago.
- dragontamer 6y agoNVidia Volta: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1804.06826.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1804.06826.pdf Each machine instruction on NVidia Volta has the following information: * Reuse Flags * Wait Barrier Mask * Read/Write barrier index (6-bit bitmask) * Read Dependency barriers * Stall Cycles (4-bit) * Yield Flag (1-bit software hint: NVidia CU will select new warp, load-balancing the SMT resources of the compute unit) Itanium's idea of VLIW was commingled with other ideas; in particular, the idea of a compiler static-scheduler to minimize hardware work at runtime. To my eyes: the benefits of Itanium are implemented in NVidia's GPUs. The compiler for NVidia's compiler-scheduling flags has been made and is proven effective. Itanium itself: the crazy "bundling" of instructions and such, seems too complex. The explicit bitmasks / barriers of NVidia Volta seems more straightforward and clear in describing the dependency graph of code (and therefore: the potential parallelism). ---------- Clearly, static-compilers marking what is, and what isn't, parallelizable, is useful. NVidia Volta+ architectures have proven this. Furthermore, compilers that can emit such information already exist. I do await the day when other architectures wake up to this fact.