3 ms·
It's not a productive word really because it almost poisons every discussion based on whether someone's broadly sympathetic to 'capitalism' or not. Even when pe
by Barrin92 6y ago
It's not a productive word really because it almost poisons every discussion based on whether someone's broadly sympathetic to 'capitalism' or not. Even when people actually agree this can cause meaningless confusion.
What I think is very valuable within our system is markets as a tool. There's no functioning replacement yet for allocating resources through something like a market at large scale. Even socialism sympathetic economists like Oscar Lange recognised this a long time ago.
What's wrong with the status quo I think is markets as an ideology, confusing social ends or larger objectives with the outcomes markets or capital produce. There is too little coordination in society, too little forward thinking and planning at a high level. It shows in the covid pandemic into which we stumbled like fools despite knowing it would happen at some point, the way we're screwed every time a wildfire breaks out despite we know it'll happen. I think it's glorifying capitalism as a way of life rather than a tool that produces these failures.
- mathattack 6y agoIs such planning possible? Decentralized models work because centralized planning doesn’t. I concur with the aims. Solving pandemics, climate change and nuclear proliferation require a different toolset than what succeeded for reducing global poverty.
- socialdemocrat 6y agoIt is not like decentralized planning always work better. It depends on the task. What works in my opinion is iteration, feedback and experimentation. You don’t merely dogmatically state centralized or decentralized work better. Instead you experiment, iterate and refine. You learn from others.
- mathattack 6y agoCan centrally planned iteration and testing work better? I’m not trying to be dogmatic - I’m trying to look for a 3rd option beyond centralized and decentralized.
- Waterfall 6y agoSure, research and development in bell labs was pretty good. Doubt we'd get all that stuff from random people without exotic equipment and cash. Of course they made risks of their own money, not other people's money
- dqv 6y agoCentralized planning didn't work. And my assumption has always been that it was the result of a slow-to-respond system. Today we have a way to react to economic signals almost instantaneously. I think it's worth trying again in a smaller way i.e. centralized planning of the meat industry (someone smarter than me can figure out what industry is actually best to do a trial run of modern centralized planning).
- Waterfall 6y agoYou don't think meat packing is centralized? How you you think factories do their work? Where do you think subsidies come from? What does centralized mean? Why would I want a man in Washington to guide Montana in the form of government though?
- sudosysgen 6y agoYou might be interested by what Cockshott has to say.
- nickff 6y agoI don't think anyone denies that omniscient, well intentioned planners would be very efficient, but subjectivism and the calculation problem mean that you will never have the former, and political economy explains why you will not acheve the latter. Spontaneously ordered systems are also better at dynamic adaptation to exogenous changes (such as technological ones).
- foldr 6y agoNo system is perfect. Perfect markets don't exist either.
- Barrin92 6y agoHow can political economy explain away something that's already succeeded? It's how Singapore moved from the third world to first, in the words of LKY, how Taiwan and South Korea got rich, how China has dragged people out of poverty, arguably also how the US navigated a huge portion of the cold war, by strategic thinking and determining clear goals, and then leaving the how to less centralised systems to figure out. The 40s to 70s broadly were an era in which there appeared to be a pragmatic balance between strategic planning and decentralized execution, in which markets where tools, serving national interest. It's also probably the era in which we saw more technological progress than at any other point. Bringing up 'political economy' in this context is what produced the old saying 'Economists are the sort of people that see something work in practise and ask if it works in theory', it's exactly a symptom of the dogmatism that I think is plaguing us.
- sudosysgen 6y ago>subjectivism and the calculation problem Every planned economy that has existed has used price signals by the end user in order to fix these issues. Planned economies are made to run an economy without markets, not without prices. As long as you have an end-user price signal, subjectivism is not an issue and the calculation problem becomes a computational issue that can be solved.
- socialdemocrat 6y agoBut in many cases the calculation problem is smaller than the problems in a specific market. It seems clear that a whole economy cannot be centrally controlled but that does not mean that parts of it isn’t better controlled by planned economics than be market economics. It would be wrong to assume one size fits all. One can also have hybrid systems. Where the value of market decisions is understood but where a central planner has some important insights which he can use to tweak a market to work better.
- cyphar 6y agoThe term "capitalism" is not (as you appear to be implying) synonymous with "market economies". In fact they are two separate economic concepts. There have been economic systems that had free markets (feudal lords bought and sold goods in market economies) and there were also examples of capitalist enterprises that existed without free markets (some people would argue the Soviet Union fits this description, but if you prefer a less contentious example, most capitalist countries when they are functioning under a war economy have some form of central planning). Capitalism refers to an economic system where the way in which production is organised is through an employer-employee relationship.
- socialdemocrat 6y agoI think it is also important to add that it is a system where capital plays a significant role in the economy unlike say a feudal economy where land was the most important factor in the economy.
- panarky 6y agoWhile I realize that land is a distinct factor of production in the land-labor-capital-entrepreneurship model, in common usage I'd say land is the ultimate capital. Capitalists exploit ownership to generate profit for themselves. Sometimes that's ownership of something they produced, like a machine or a building or a work of the mind. More often, it's something produced by labor that they exploit for profit. And sometimes it's something they didn't produce, but manage to own and profit from nonetheless, like land and natural resources.
- sudosysgen 6y agoCapital must be producible. Land cannot be any form of capital because it cannot be produced.
- SAI_Peregrinus 6y agoLand can certainly be produced. It's very expensive, and quite limited, but things like the Dutch polders or Dubai's Palm Islands. Or for that matter much of San Francisco, Shenzen, and several other major cities.
- sudosysgen 6y agoWell, using capitalism to explain other issues is just a consequence of being a Materialist. If you adhere to a materialist understanding of the world, you come to the the conclusion that most of the features of our environment (which is validated by analysis) find their roots in the material organization of our world. And the material organization we are operating in is "capitalism". Which is why it applies so much. I think part of the confusion comes with the understanding of what capitalism is. Capitalism isn't markets, we had markets before capitalism. Capitalism is the economic organization where: * Production is organized under private ownership * Social relations are dominantly monetary relationships * Labour is dominantly done for wages * Production is done for profit * A market system is used to structure productive relationships * A de-facto class system which divides workers and owners That's what capitalism is, and when people, especially academics say that something is caused by capitalism, they refer to capitalism as defined, loosely, by those elements. Capitalism is not a tool, it is a state of being. Markets are a tool, that have wonderful advantages. Markets aren't an ideology, capitalism is a group of ideologies that promote markets as much as possible. For an extreme example, in the USSR, food production was overwhelmingly mediated by markets. Was that capitalism? No, because it was not done for profits, and because production was not based on wages. Everyone agrees that markets is an amazingly useful tool and is fit for many applications, except some which lack a good grasp of economics, or others which are deluded into abstracting economics from society and which therefore miss when they are not fit for the task. What people don't agree with is that capitalism is a system which should be perpetuated, and the two are perfectly consistent positions to hold.
- SpicyLemonZest 6y agoI agree with your assessment of what "capitalism" means, but it's still not a productive term to use if people are constantly confused and misunderstand it. In my experience, many people understand "capitalism" to mean nothing more than "rich people wielding power", so I try to avoid using it in contexts where confusion is possible.
- sudosysgen 6y agoI understand, but the way to fix that issue isn't to avoid talking about capitalism but to actually address what it is.
- simonpure 6y agoThis is also known as the Socialist calculation debate [0]. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialist_calculation_debate https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Socialist_calculation_debate