3 ms·
CRISPR isn't quite enough. That's just patching. Direct synthesis of a human sized genome will probably be available at some point. The human genome is about 3
by Animats 6y ago
CRISPR isn't quite enough. That's just patching. Direct synthesis of a human sized genome will probably be available at some point. The human genome is about 3 billion base pairs. Largest synthesis so far is 580,000 base pairs.
Then we'll need CAD tools. Really good CAD tools.
- vikramkr 6y agoJust synthesizing a genome isn't going to get us to designer humans - frankly its already well within the reach of modern technology to synthesize 3 billion bases. You cant just bootstrap from the nucleotide sequence - even in really simple bacteria we have to pop the genome into a pre-prepared genome free cell with the machinery to start working on doing life stuff, and adding the complexity of human epigenetics and a multicellular organism makes that a nonstarter currently. Especially when just editing the genome is so much easier.
- adrianN 6y agoI would be interested in reading some literature about the current problems of plopping a synthesized genome into a vertebrate ovum. Or a simpler multi-cellular species, say C. elegans.
- vikramkr 6y agoThis has more to do with the synthesis process itself, but here's a good read [0]. Youll notice most of the problems are around cost and logistics, but if we had the funding of the human genome project, that would be a non issue. I dont know if any articles discussing the epigenetics really exist since the organisms so far are ones where that's not really so much of a problem yet - I don't now of any de novo synthesized efforts in multicellular organisms but perhaps someone has a link (not counting cloning - the epigenetic information is carried along in the transfer). [0] https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-00511-9 https://www.nature.com/articles/d41586-020-00511-9
- dekhn 6y agoI can't even imagine why you would want to synthesize and inject a replacement human chromosome (let alone the entire genome). That sounds like a huge waste of time and money, unlikely to achieve any reasonable goal, and prone to far more unintended side effects than localized patching
- sbierwagen 6y agoGWASes have shown that many strongly heritable things that we care about (height, heart attack risk, IQ) are hugely polygenetic, the result of the interaction of thousands of genes: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genome-wide_association_study#Results https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genome-wide_association_study#... CRISPR is too unreliable and has too many off target effects to move the needle on height. By the time you've made a hundred CRISPR edits to a single genome, you've shot the other chromosomes full of holes. It's only useful for taking out one or two genes, for someone who knows they carry a fatal genetic disease, but still wants to have kids. True designer babies will be done with genome synthesis.
- dekhn 6y agoWhat you're describing is basically science fiction, far in the future. We have no technology to do what you're describing, nobody is planning on "repairing thousands of genes" to increase somebody's height. I understand it's fun to speculate about this.
- sbierwagen 6y agoFactual statement: "We have no technology to do what you're describing" Correct. We can only assemble synthetic bacteria right now. Synthetic sperm is years away. Synthetic eggs are too complicated, I wonder if they'll ever be made. Synthetic embryos would be true sci-fi stuff, requiring heavy engineering and many breakthroughs. Emotional statement: "nobody is planning on" Human germline engineering inspires strong feelings. I'm sure that the advent of motorized vehicles would have inspired the same strong feelings in horses, if they could have understood what was about to happen to them. Nevertheless.
- anticensor 6y agoWe will rather need an IDE and decompilers for genetic code.