6 ms·
> This is what Nvidia was looking for since out of the big 3 US semiconductor manufacturers, it doesn't have its own IP on CPUs. Now it will soon be able to con
by ethbr0 6y ago
> This is what Nvidia was looking for since out of the big 3 US semiconductor manufacturers, it doesn't have its own IP on CPUs. Now it will soon be able to control ARM to its advantage against the competition.
In all fairness, consider the market from Nvidia's perspective: they've spent a few decades being a stone's throw from Intel eating them. They started as one of many add-on card manufacturers and have turned into a dominant player by innovating, iterating, and being ruthless.
Some here might not remember how cutthroat the early-GPU days were. Nvidia survived.
Now, an opportunity to become a technical peer to Intel at the CPU level? To control their own destiny?
They'd be insane not to take this opportunity.
- cptskippy 6y agoI don't remember it being all that cutthroat tbh. 3dfx was arguably the only game in down and ATi was it's whipping boy. Matrox was over in the corner saying "look nah two monitors at once!" 3dfx stumbled right as nVidia dropped the GeForce and blew everything away. ATi became nVidia's whipping boy and Matrox just added the ability to drive more monitors. I mean aside from not knowing if Matrox is still around, not much has changed from what I can see.
- landryraccoon 6y agoYou just described a space with 4 competitors fighting for the same market. How could it be anything other than cutthroat? GPUs are not the kind of space where it’s easy for new companies to enter. It very much was a winner takes all market.
- AmericanChopper 6y ago> It very much was a winner takes all market. Of course. The multi billion dollar market is just too small for more than one company. Nvidia is just biding it’s time on ~20% market share until it can put the finishing moves on the other 9 major vendors.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- cptskippy 6y agoCutthroat usually means something like unprincipled or ruthless competition. When 3DFX and now Nvidia were on top, there was no assailing them. You exist in a position they allow you to exist. Perhaps the competition between 3DFX and ATi or Nvidia and AMD could be described as cutthroat but the other "competitiors" in the space couldn't even compete and eventually they all just pivoted into other things without anyone noticing or caring. It's not unlike the x86 processor market. Companies like Via and Transmeta existed but they never were any serious competition to Intel or AMD.
- wyldfire 6y agoATI/AMD remains nearly the only competitor nvidia has in the discrete GPU space. But we started out with 3dfx, S3, nvidia, ati.
- phonon 6y agoPowerVR, Matrox, Trident, Bitboys Oy, 3Dlabs, Rendition, Intel740...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- danieldk 6y agoSiS also had 3D graphics chips. Tseng Labs was probably one of the earliest victims of the 3D GPUs wars, having developed but never completed the ET6300. PowerVR still exists and is seems successful in the mobile market (having provided Apple's GPUs until A10).
- nl 6y agoOh wow I had a Tseng Labs T4000(?) on my second Linux computer! I forgot about them!
- opencl 6y agoImgtech/PowerVR was successful in the mobile market until Apple stopped buying their GPUs. Now they have practically no mobile customers though they're still reasonably successful in the automotive market.
- nl 6y agoYeah there's a lot more fights NVidia has had. They spent a lot of time and money first building motherboard chipsets[1] with on-board GPUs for AMD CPUs only to have CMD buy ATI. Then they started a program to build their own x86 CPU[2] which Intel sued them over[3]. There was a counter suite, and the EU settlement around the same time and Intel ended up paying NVidia $1.5B3[3] which was often read a win for NVidia. Of course in retrospect it gave Intel another 10 years of CPU domination. So then NVidia announced they were building a desktop ARM processor[5]. That went pretty much nowhere. So then there was their mobile play (the Tegra)[6]. That was supposed to let them dominate mobile phones, and went just about as well as their launch partner phone (the Microsoft Kin). It has found use in robotics (the NVidia Jetson series) and cars (the Telsa model 3) though. So they've lost a bunch of fights, and outside GPUs it really has been cut throat. [1] https://www.anandtech.com/show/828 https://www.anandtech.com/show/828 [2] https://www.tweaktown.com/news/11570/nvidia_announces_x86_cpu_plans_to_investors/index.html https://www.tweaktown.com/news/11570/nvidia_announces_x86_cp... [3] https://www.reuters.com/article/us-intel-nvidia/intel-pays-nvidia-1-5-billion-in-chip-dispute-idUSTRE7095U120110111 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-intel-nvidia/intel-pays-n... [4] https://www.anandtech.com/show/4122/intel-settles-with-nvidia-more-money-fewer-problems-no-x86/2 https://www.anandtech.com/show/4122/intel-settles-with-nvidi... [5] https://www.engadget.com/2011-01-05-nvidia-announces-project-denver- https://www.engadget.com/2011-01-05-nvidia-announces-project... arm-cpu-for-the-desktop.html [6] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tegra https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tegra
- antpls 6y agoNote that Tesla does not use NVIDIA anymore. https://www.zdnet.com/article/nvidia-takes-aim-at-teslas-custom-gpu-claims/ https://www.zdnet.com/article/nvidia-takes-aim-at-teslas-cus...
- Impossible 6y agoFYI, Nintendo Switch is Tegra based as well. 61 million units isn't bad, and there are significantly more Tegras in use in Switch consoles than in Jetson boards or even Telsas (~1 million).
- 6y ago
- gwd 6y ago> Now, an opportunity to become a technical peer to Intel at the CPU level? To control their own destiny? > They'd be insane not to take this opportunity. It made financial sense for ARM's board to sell to SoftBank; it makes financial sense for SoftBank to sell to NVIDIA; it makes financial and strategic sense for NVIDIA to buy ARM; it makes financial and strategic sense for NVIDIA to radically change the way the ARM ecosystem works to benefit themselves. And yet, the world will lose out massively by having the ARM ecosystem radically changed to benefit NVIDIA. Capitalism certainly does a lot to create value for society as a whole, but this is just one of many examples of where capitalism also destroys value for society as a whole.
- bsaul 6y agoWhy stop there ? It'll make financial sense for previous users of ARM license to start looking for alternatives ( such as riscV) and create more competition in the field. Which ultimately benefits to the people as a whole. At least that's the theory of capitalism..
- chii 6y ago> the world will lose out massively by having the ARM ecosystem radically changed to benefit NVIDIA. if that's the case, then the people who stand to lose from this _should_ be pushing the gov't to standardize and prevent fracturing of ecosystems from happening.
- gridlockd 6y agoThis is a premature judgement. If NVIDIA treats ARM poorly, that benefits alternative ISAs and may ultimately undermine NVIDIAs investment. If NVIDIA treats ARM well, then that benefits the platform as a whole. The reality is going to be somewhere in the middle. Market equilibrium does not imply maximum benefit for any one interest group. "Consumers" or "end-users" are often conflated with "society".
- dippersauce 6y agoLooking through the doomsayers in this thread, this is the result I believe to be most likely. If ARM goes belly up through gross mismanagement, then the laurels will be taken up by someone else. I think another aspect to consider is the perpetual license agreements ARM holds with several other businesses. I think this may muzzle Nvidia to some extent.
- switch11 6y agoVery well put The biggest thing if you have been in prolonged vicious competition, is to Control Your Own Destiny and leave the basket of crabs behind For Nvidia this is a MASSIVE win Softbank are @#$@#$ idiots for selling ARM Right when ARM is finally taking over the world For what? So they can fund the next bunch of charlatans - add more disasters like WeWork and Uber?
- ZitchDog 6y agoSoftbank probably has a bunch of NVIDIA options that it needs to be worth money