5 ms·
Ask HN: Glassdoor for Medical Bills?
I had an idea earlier after receiving an unreasonable medical bill.
As most here probably know, medical bills in the U.S. - in addition to being high - are almost never advertised, often erroneous, often inflated via agreements with insurers, and can often be talked down as soon as the recipient points out issues with them.
What if there were a website where people could report their invoices from different providers, tagging them by state, by insurance provider, by insurance plan, itemizing the charges for each piece of care, and including both the base charge and the amount covered by insurance, and then the site could a) aggregate this data to help people understand how their costs compare to others for similar treatments, and b) raise general awareness of the prices. If prices won't be transparent up-front, we can make them transparent after the fact for the next person. Beyond just helping individuals, if this got big enough it could conceivably push down prices as providers are forced to compete.
A journalist at Vox did something similar (for a one-off investigation) at one point: https://www.vox.com/2018/2/27/16936638/er-bills-emergency-room-hospital-fees-health-care-costs
But of course what I'm talking about would be an ongoing, ever-growing, self-reported dataset.
Does this exist? Could it exist? Anybody want to collaborate on it?
- greenyoda 6y agoWhat do you envision as the business model for this site? Pay to subscribe? Ad-supported? Free, supported by donations?
- brundolf 6y agoI was thinking open-source/nonprofit. Server costs should be trivial until it started to take off for real (and I'd personally be open to covering them out of pocket), at which point a proper nonprofit/donation model could be set up. Ideally the data itself would also be open, for use by others (analysts, journalists, etc).
- codegeek 6y agoFunny I have thought of doing exactly the same. Would love to brainstorm ideas. Sick and tired of medical billing crap.
- applecrazy 6y agoI've had this exact idea. I made it as a hackathon project but haven't worked on it ever since. One of the things I wanted to do was to use publicly-available treatment cost data (I think states like California require reporting of this) and aggregate it by type of treatment to allow users to comparison-shop between medical providers in their area. The issue I was facing (and the reason I stopped working on this project) was the lack of standard, openly-available medical codes, since most hospitals mark treatments with CPT codes, which are proprietary and require a license to use in software. If anyone has any solutions to translate these codes to human-readable names without licensing the entire set of codes from the American Medical Association, I'd be open to hearing those ideas.
- brundolf 6y agoMy (possibly naive) thinking was to have people just enter the human-friendly name for each item from their invoice as-is. A data-cleanup stage would then be necessary to reconcile these names across entries, but: - The same provider will presumably use the exact same name for the same item across invoices, reducing the subsets of values that will need to be matched up (similar to the way services like Mint make sense of transaction names) - Some automated "fuzzy matching" could be applied; keywords, off-by-one-letter checks, etc - Human curation, amplified by the above two factors, might be feasible - Maybe someone could even do something fancy with a neural-net, who knows ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ But yeah, data reconciliation is definitely one of the main challenges here. If you want to brainstorm/discuss more directly, you can email me at mail[at]brandonsmith[dot]ninja
- adventured 6y agoIt's a good idea overall. My suggestion is to absolutely under no circumstances attempt to cover all (or a large number) possible medical codes in the first few years. Do not spend any mental energy on that, it will bury you, it will rob your motivation, it will waste your time and make you wish you never considered the service. Do the opposite, start very stupid simple, knock down one bowling pin. Pick a small selection of the most common medical codes or those most in need of this service (the treatments that can benefit most from this). Roll the complexity gradually from there. You will be aided by resources as you scale, in many ways, which you will lack in the beginning. Your expanding userbase can also assist you immensely as you go along (in the beginning they won't exist); but you first need to have a very useful service to get those users, and to do that you have to be good at something; narrow, narrow, narrow; you'll expand outward later. And frankly if you can't make it work for a small group of medical codes, you are not going to make it work for a much larger & complex context. Again, whatever you do, do not attempt to run before you crawl with this. You don't need to do that. Just offering this for small selection of medical codes could be hugely valuable, then slowly expand it. Make it work super well for that small group first. Make it clear what your service focuses on, and keep that list short. Reject any attempts by users to expand the system to cover all medical codes in the beginning. It's no different than going from Harvard.edu, to Stanford.edu as in the Facebook bowling pin strategy, and then building up some demand from users to see you add more medical codes (the userbase will help inform you which to do next). Do not try to go wide in the beginning, it's a guaranteed path to failure. Plus, if you start with a small selection of medical codes, you can better focus on your outreach / marketing to just those people and their circumstances. It will drastically simplify your attempts to find the first 100 / 1000 / 10000 users, and those early users will all be able to coordinate on the same narrow medical code/s, which will build the initial community foundation you require. If you try to go wide initially, covering a lot of medical codes, you'll get stray users that won't be able to coordinate with the other users who all have different medical codes (ie it's better to have 1,000 users with the same single medical code, than 1,000 medical codes each with one user).
- giantg2 6y agoMany insurance providers actually have a portal where you can search for a procedure and they will list the providers and their prices.
- schemescape 6y agoMy employer used to provide access to a service (it might have been Castlight Health) that would show typical prices for providers/facilities, so you could at least attempt to shop around. I don’t think it is open to individuals, unfortunately.