7 ms·
A step in the wrong direction. Children should be riding bicycles. Adults should be too. But if you get them in cars at 14 it's never going to happen. Another e
by globular-toast 6y ago
A step in the wrong direction. Children should be riding bicycles. Adults should be too. But if you get them in cars at 14 it's never going to happen. Another enemy of other road users is born.
- ekianjo 6y ago> Children should be riding bicycles. Adults should be too. Not everyone is fit to ride a bicycle, and riding a bicycle where there's cars on the road is a lot more dangerous than being in a car. And let's stop using the word "should" for every problem out there, people are free to make their own choices.
- Uhhrrr 6y agoSure they're free to make their own choices, but most people are fit enough to ride bicycles, and exercise is good for you, so they should ride bicycles.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoSure, many people are fit enough to ride a bicycle for a bit on flat land when it is dry out. I'm not sure "most" people are, though, and I'm guessing this gets less the older folks get. I do not live on flat land and I live in a place with winters. I, in fact, live in a mountainous area. Riding a bike is not an easy feat here - I've been testing this summer. Short slight inclines aren't too bad: The occasional steep hill isn't so bad. 15-30 minutes uphill, however, is too much for me. All uphill one way isn't easy. I'm not the only person that struggles with this: Biking forums are full of folks that struggle with uphill, and it takes time to get fit enough for this.
- bserge 6y agoI'm not getting into the "fit or not" debate, just pointing out you don't have to ride on the bike uphill. I found it's easier to just walk (with the bike acting as support) :D
- yodsanklai 6y agoElectric bikes are the solution. I see more and more people commuting with electric bikes. I've been commuting by bicycle for years, not for ecological reasons, but because it's convenient and healthy. That being said, I wouldn't do it if the roads weren't safe enough. To me, this is the main limitation. Bad weather and hills can be overcome, but I don't want to compromise with safety.
- tom_mellior 6y ago> Not everyone is fit to ride a bicycle This is true. Nor is the climate suitable everywhere, etc. However: > riding a bicycle where there's cars on the road is a lot more dangerous than being in a car. This is a problem that absolutely can solved by more "should". The police should police more, and the courts should be strict about endangering others with deadly weapons, even if those deadly weapons are on wheels. > people are free to make their own choices. People are "free" to speed, or to drive drunk, or to otherwise endanger others "where there's cars on the road". Looks like these "own choices" aren't a terribly good fit to many of the problems posed by cars.
- ekianjo 6y ago> People are "free" to speed, or to drive drunk, or to otherwise endanger others "where there's cars on the road". Looks like these "own choices" aren't a terribly good fit to many of the problems posed by cars. Taking my quote out of context? It's pretty clear I meant that they are free to decide to have a car if that is best for them. Nowhere did I encourage speeding.
- tom_mellior 6y agoYou didn't encourage speeding, but you did suggest that cars were somehow inherently dangerous to bikers. As opposed to the behavior of the people inside the cars being dangerous to bikers. You also suggested that this is a problem that cannot, or need not, be solved by "should" rules to change that behavior. I agree that people are free to decide to have a car, but they absolutely should behave very responsibly with them. I also agree that creating a more welcoming environment like this will encourage more people to make the free choice to bike, we don't need to force them.
- asutekku 6y agoEurope does not have the same obesity rates as US.
- yodsanklai 6y ago> people are free to make their own choices. As long as it doesn't impact too much the rest of society. For instance, people aren't free to drive a tank on the highway. If we believe data on global warming, and if we consider it's an issue to be addressed (and most people believe both), some choices which are available now should be restricted in the future.
- ekianjo 6y ago> some choices which are available now should be restricted in the future. It will be easier to make people make these choices if they look attractive ways to go forward rather than blaming them about using what is available for them to live their lives.
- yodsanklai 6y agoI don't think blaming is a solution. I think some choices should be heavily discouraged or simply forbidden. I don't expect people to willingly lose comfort and convenience. Unfortunately, this is the only way to go if you want to reach the objective fixed by the Paris agreement [1]. CO2 emissions should be reduced by 5% every year. [1] https://unfccc.int/process-and-meetings/the-paris-agreement/what-is-the-paris-agreement https://unfccc.int/process-and-meetings/the-paris-agreement/...
- gambiting 6y agoI disagree that it's a move in the wrong direction. When I got a scooter at 15 it suddenly opened up my world - I could ride it to other cities and meet distant friends after school, and just get a lot more things done without having to involve my parents. It was an incredible mobility improvement for a young person, and I imagine this will serve the exact same purpose. And I rode a bicycle at the same time - me and my friends used to cycle 2-3 times per week, 100-120km per day, just for fun. But that's not a good option to go with friends to a cinema, when the nearest one is 45 minute bicycle ride away along major roads. A scooter improved that ability immensly, and I'm sure a small car will as well.
- donatj 6y agoI agree 100%. I didn’t get my license until I was 22, and looking back I strongly feel like it was a mistake. There was just so much missed opportunity in being stuck within the range human power can get you.
- wffurr 6y agoI don't doubt your story, but I still have doubts that scooters or minicars are the right fix. 45 minutes doesn't seem like a big deal, most people, especially in cities, probably live a lot closer to a cinema, and the main issue is dangerous main roads without sufficient cycle infrastructure. Taming car traffic in cities and providing easy to use cycle infrastructure would be enormously more beneficial across the board that a competition for "fast as legally possible" mini cars and scooters, even electric ones.
- qayxc 6y agoAnd it never occurred to you that maybe the whole concept of lack of public transportation was at fault? I didn't get my drivers licence until I was 23 and I didn't miss out on anything, because I could (and did) travel the whole country via train and bus - despite growing up in the countryside. The train station was just under 2km away and that helped immensely and had regular service (2 times an hour) to the nearest cities.
- read_if_gay_ 6y ago
- bzb5 6y ago>Children should be riding bicycles. Adults should be too. Don’t present your opinions as facts.
- CCstal 6y agoNot at all. Its a step in the right direction. Who wants to go to work full of sweat or go meet friends quite a few km away and show up sweating. People forget that bike riders, once its past a certain amount of distance will sweat + are exposed to the elements. Sure ebikes help with this. But nobody in my country is going to go to work in a full suit + on a bike.
- yodsanklai 6y ago> Not at all. Its a step in the right direction. Who wants to go to work full of sweat or go meet friends quite a few km away and show up sweating When considering what the right direction is, you should consider convenience, but also environmental impact. It's a trade-off to be made.
- Tade0 6y agoIt's not that clear cut. Humans are terrible at turning food into energy, and only the most efficient (vegan) foods have a footprint below 1g CO2/kcal. Your typical vegan on a bicycle has a footprint of 22g CO2/km and that's the best you can get with human-powered transport. The Ami has a driving footprint of 7g / km in France, a 5.5kWh battery, which has a one-time impact of ~450kg, and seats two. Long term it's the less impactful opttion really, especially if you take into account that only 2% of the population is vegan.
- yodsanklai 6y agoNot convinced by your conclusion > Humans are terrible at turning food into energy Electric bicycles come to mind. They would provide a more direct comparison with the Ami, but being 50 times lighter, I don't see how the Ami could compete. > a one-time impact of ~450kg This amounts to 20000km! That's a lot of cycling before the Ami becomes less impactful. Also a battery lifetime is about 5 years. > Your typical vegan on a bicycle has a footprint of 22g CO2/km I didn't find this number. "CO2 emissions from the average European diet, which is another 16g per kilometer cycled" [1] With this number, that would be 30000km of cycling before you even drive one meter with the Ami. > in France France electricity production generates very little CO2. In most other countries, the footprint would be much higher making the Ami an even worse option. It's hard to argue that a 500kg vehicle can be more efficient than a 10kg one (or even 20kg for an electric bicycle). That being said, it'd be great if Ami could replace more polluting cars for people who dislike cycles [1] https://ecf.com/news-and-events/news/how-much-co2-does-cycling-really-save https://ecf.com/news-and-events/news/how-much-co2-does-cycli...
- spodek 6y agoMoreover, they will become disposable and landfills will fill up with them, as I wrote in more depth in another post here.
- anigbrowl 6y agoBicycles are great but no amount of pro-bike policies will make them better in the rain or when you need to carry any sort of cargo larger than a single shopping bag.
- globular-toast 6y agoI used to carry about 3-4 shopping bags on my back while cycling back from the supermarket. That was before I discovered pannier bags which are far more effective. You can also get trailers. I also went to my job in the rain and snow. Why did I do this? Because I didn't have a car. It's amazing what is possible when there's no other option.