3 ms·
> The developers have convinced themselves that they're right on this, having, I suppose, not learned from the hundreds of package managers that have come befor
by steveklabnik 6y ago
> The developers have convinced themselves that they're right on this, having, I suppose, not learned from the hundreds of package managers that have come before them. They're wrong; full stop, no qualifications, no asterisk, no footnote, they are totally wrong on this and it is inevitable that their opinion will change.
Comments like this are why this discussion has devolved over the years. It's "all heat and no light." It does not help convince anyone that you're right, and if you want this to change, I would suggest that you change your approach.
The team has stated that they are open to implementing namespaces, but that the people who advocate for them need to address the concerns. This hasn't been done successfully yet, and is part of what this post is trying to help out with, by cataloging some of the large amounts of previous discussion.
- voxl 6y agoWhat concerns? Most people don't care because they feel that the ship has sailed, the mistake is set in the concrete. Transitioning thus becomes the biggest conceivable concern for me. What are the other possible concerns? The only comments I've seen on this is "It's not any different, people will just squat namespaces" to which I reply: reserve namespaces up front for Rust nursery and bespoke crates. That has always been the biggest benefit of namespaces, when i type "std.rand" I never have to worry about an attacker squatting "std.rnd". But I could just mistype the namespace! Fine, I could, but all the obvious mistypings could _also_ be reserved!
- steveklabnik 6y agoThe article has some discussion on all of the various bits of the problems in this space, and has links to previous discussions. It seems from your comment (and I may be wrong!) that you're purely talking about the "use namespace to solve squatting" issue, which is only one dimension here. Some people want namespaces and don't care about squatting. Some people want to solve squatting through other means. Some people do see namespaces as a solution to squatting, while others disagree.
- Aeolun 6y agoI think the point of the post is that whatever the reason, every other package manager that has started out without namespaces has eventually implemented them. The reasons may be unclear, but it seems likely that eventually the crates.io team will receive the same reasons that the other package managers got and implement namespaces.
- steveklabnik 6y agoThat’s just not true though. Rubygems does not, and neither does CPAN, I believe. It doesn't look like PyPi does.
- dragonwriter 6y agoThere's been some discussion around it for PyPI, but it doesn't seem like there's a consensus that it is necessary, or even on what the set of problems that should be addressed by it is.
- steveklabnik 6y ago... sounds familiar...