4 ms·
> We need to focus on the second R, reuse. That means you need to end both single-use containers and selling stuff in containers entirely. There’s only do muc
by masklinn 6y ago
> We need to focus on the second R, reuse.
That means you need to end both single-use containers and selling stuff in containers entirely.
There’s only do much of one type of reusable container you even can have a use for, and that’s assuming you do even have a use for them in the first place: I don’t make jam at home, I buy it, I don’t have a use for a new jam jar a month, and every jam-making friend has more jars than they could ever use (seriously, I used to stock jars for my parents until they stopped canning, then tried giving my stock away, about a third of which found I interest, the rest went to recycling).
- Ensorceled 6y agoWhy couldn't jam manufacturers just use returnable bottles? The beer companies in Ontario do, soda bottles are returnable and reusable in many places.
- srtjstjsj 6y agoThey could, but no one wants to pay extra effort and energy cost when it's easier to make new glass from dirt.
- paulryanrogers 6y agoNo one wants to breath polluted air or drink polluted after, yet here we are. Rich producers just keep moving further away from the problems they create. Or they maintain their ignorance through a delicately balanced series of mental gymnastics.
- shawnz 6y agoCorporations don't have feelings... negative externalities need to be priced or there's no reason to expect a corporation to pay attention to them.
- justinph 6y agoThen this is a perfect case for regulation, to make it cost more to make new glass than re-use existing containers. It worked in the past just fine. But the first world incentivized energy production so much that we drove down the need to be efficient.
- sp332 6y agoFor glass bottles, I don't see the point. There's no glass shortage, and glass debris doesn't kill anything or leech into the soil from landfills.
- 1123581321 6y agoThe environmental cost of collection, transport, inspection and cleaning, and transport to be filled would outweigh the cost of manufacture and transport to be filled. So that regulation would make jam more expensive and/or the environment worse.
- R0b0t1 6y agoGlass is actually the most recyclable material with the highest difference in energy put in between new and reclaimed. I think the issue is not many plants are set up for recycling, and it is extra work to make pretty glass from reclaim glass.
- masklinn 6y agoI expect most of them are large companies unconcerned with that in the first place (so it'd have to be mandated), but more importantly jam containers tend to have pretty thin walls and somewhat odd shapes. They're solid enough when full and sealed but I expect they're much weaker when empty, so I don't know that the cost/benefit would break even unless the cost of the alternative was way increased. > The beer companies in Ontario do, soda bottles are returnable and reusable in many places. Reusing beer bottles is much more traditional so I expect they're designed for this specifically, and there's usually either an incentive scheme to encourage or outright legislation to mandate container deposits (germany even has legislation for single-use container deposits).
- yourapostasy 6y ago> That means you need to end...selling stuff in containers entirely. If we energy-cost-accounted for all externalities, then I wonder how returning the containers to the factory to automatically sanitize and re-use compares to recycling. Land filling is not an option: say you're in a closed loop environment like on a generation ship trip to Proxima Centauri b, and the concept of a land fill as we know it is obscenely wasteful.
- cnity 6y agoWhat's most interesting to me about this comment is the use of an example of a closed loop environment, despite the fact that _we're already in a closed loop environment_. We just pretend otherwise with landfill and the convenience of throwing things into a bin.
- yourapostasy 6y agoGlad you saw that. I already treat us as living in a closed loop environment, but very few people share and act upon that sentiment with me, so I find it easier to illustrate by analogy. Generally speaking, our human organizational psychology is extremely vulnerable to the principal agent problem throughout the body of the organization when timelines and scales are larger than an individual can internalize. MEGO is the usual response I get when I speak with most people about timelines exceeding a human lifespan (their human lifespan to be specific), or resource quantities at industrial and global scales. Until we can solve the problem of shifting on the order of 3e8 metric tons of mass off-planet without ruinous side effects, we're really stuck on our cradle world, and should plan (including actively researching how to get off world at that scale) accordingly.
- masklinn 6y ago> If we energy-cost-accounted for all externalities, then I wonder how returning the containers to the factory to automatically sanitize and re-use compares to recycling. That would be interesting, but it's very difficult to price externalities, and the very same people who are against any form of recycling mandate are also against pricing externalities (just look at who killed Australia's carbon tax, and which party's blocking any sort of cap-and-trade or carbon tax in the US).
- Nasrudith 6y agoContainer waste needs to be considered with its inversely correlated counterpart, content waste and contamination damage. A single food poisoning case has far more impact than just tossing a non-biodegradable container in a landfill. Especially if they die - every investment in them from vaccinations to education becomes for naught in the future.