3 ms·
What is unfair here exactly? There hasn’t been anything close to a ruling. These hypotheticals in this thread are getting way ahead of reality here. It sounds
by dmix 6y ago
What is unfair here exactly? There hasn’t been anything close to a ruling. These hypotheticals in this thread are getting way ahead of reality here.
It sounds like the courts are preempting the defense strategy by forcing a gov psych review instead of one paid for by the defendant.
In criminal law cases it’s not an instant get out of jail free card if you’re found to have some mental issues. Nearly every lawyer brings up mental states in serious crimes. These judges aren’t stupid.
- staticman2 6y agoJudges don't decide cases, juries do. There are some people with medical degrees in this world who will say anything for money. Wealthy people pay these individuals to try to get them out of jail. Normal people can't afford that.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> Judges don't decide cases, juries do. Even with jury trials, that's not really true, except that alignment with the jury verdict is required for criminal conviction (but not acquittal, or any civil judgement.) Because summary judgement/judgement as a matter of law/judgement non obstante veredicto is a thing, and even if one isn't issued in a particular case, it's because either no one petitioned the judge for it (unlikely) or the judge decided against it.