4 ms·
Seems generally harmless. As usual there's the natural tension in self-organizing groups between ensuring inclusiveness while not weaponizing the tools used to
by renewiltord 6y ago
Seems generally harmless. As usual there's the natural tension in self-organizing groups between ensuring inclusiveness while not weaponizing the tools used to protect inclusiveness. No doubt someone will succeed in the latter with the UCoC. No doubt in its absence someone would have abused their position unshackled by these explicit norms. It's just an optimization problem.
But that's just the nature of the thing. The network of WMF controlled sites is just far too big now for efficient auto-cooperation, which often happens. So now we have rules to mediate. The rules don't seem particularly onerous, though doubtless one day someone will find out that I advocated against organ donation on Twitter and drag me through the mud and request a rewrite of all my en-wiki contributions.
But until then, I've found en-wiki very easy to contribute to. I think the norms around picture copyright inclusion are super strict but everything else is easy. I've been a member for more than a decade and auto-confirmed for some long time so maybe that's it, but honestly I don't interact with other people at all, and the other day I looked back and I haven't been reverted once over that period.
- ars 6y agoIt doesn't really address the actual problems on Wikipedia - things like people "owning pages", or people contributing incorrect information, or people appointing themselves as the arbiter of what is and isn't useful (or correct) information. In my entire time contributing I've never even once, been aware of the other person's physical characteristics, or social standing. So it seems rather pointless to include those (although I guess harmless). What I would like for a COC is things like not demeaning other people's contributions by just removing them with barely even a comment, or just a dismissive one.
- chris_wot 6y agoI nearly died because of bullying. One of the worst moments of my life, obviously it exacerbated an existing condition but it was terrible. A CoC would definitely have helped.
- andrewxdiamond 6y agoNot to disparage your situation, whatever it may be, but that’s a pretty big jump in logic to make with no explanation as to how a CoC would have had meaningful impact.
- Thorrez 6y agoWow, sorry to hear that. I'm glad you're still around. Was this on Wikipedia?
- chris_wot 6y agoIt was, it was awful and had there been a code of conduct around respect then I’m pretty certain it would have been dealt with a lot better.
- raxxorrax 6y agoIn my experience COCs aren't used for inclusiveness ever, they are used to ban dissidents in any form. Some that misbehave, but also those that "aren't a good fit" or generally unpopular people. That said, it is still easy to contribute, but some politicized topics are a nuclear wasteland of orthodoxy and I don't think COC will be an improvement, on the contrary.