6 ms·
>> use beamforming to finish your download at Gbps speeds and get you off the network faster Ya, "Faster speeds mean people will spend less time clogging the c
by sandworm101 6y ago
>> use beamforming to finish your download at Gbps speeds and get you off the network faster
Ya, "Faster speeds mean people will spend less time clogging the connection" ... it never happens that way. Increased speeds mean people use more internet, not less. Consumers start doing new things with the faster speeds (streaming video etc) increasing demand and overall usage. The only real answer is massive and constantly increasing speeds and bandwidth capacities. It is a race that cannot be won but must be run nevertheless.
- foota 6y agoThis really isn't the case since mobile networks have relatively low usage limits.
- abstractbarista 6y agoNo, it is definitely true that volume of data consumed over cellular data connections has vastly increased over the years.
- jakear 6y agoThe limits will rise. They always do.
- bleepblorp 6y agoThis certainly hasn't been the case in hardwired broadband, which has gone from no caps, to caps, to caps with malicious quality of service rules. Limits go down when providers have limited competition.
- rayiner 6y agoYeah, it's not like peoples' traffic profiles didn't completely change during that period. (Going from bursty web surfing and downloads to everyone pulling down 25 mbps 4K streams continuously at the same time.)
- eru 6y agoYour mileage may vary based on jurisdiction and market you are in.
- Reason077 6y ago> "mobile networks have relatively low usage limits." That depends on the country/network/plan. I have unlimited 5G data and get consistent speeds in the 200-300 Mbps range, sometimes higher. Some months I will use 1 TB of data or more. Streaming games on Stadia uses a lot of bandwidth!
- bleepblorp 6y agoHow much cellular data people use is dictated far more by data caps and usurious overage charges than by the speed of their connection. With overage charges of >$100 a GB in some parts of the world, usage per person isn't going to increase just because speeds go up. Unless the carriers have a sudden outbreak of generosity, data caps won't rise under 5G, so usage per person will stay the same but improved efficiency will allow the carriers to extract more profits from more people per cell simultaneously. 5G doesn't solve any problems for end-users. It solves the carriers' problem of 'how can we get more people to use up their data cap faster.'
- Reason077 6y agoData caps seem to have risen pretty fast recently under 4G, and the prices of unlimited data plans have come down. You can get unlimited 5G data plans, on a good network, for under £30 per month here in the UK. Even cheaper on a crappy network! Of course, how fast and aggressively the prices come down depends on the competitive environment in your country. But it will happen.
- DaiPlusPlus 6y agoMy T-Mobile USA plan is $85/mo :( I miss my old O2 and Orange £10 top-ups I’d buy as a sport with my weekly pocket-money.
- SahAssar 6y agoIn some parts of the world it's very normal to have unlimited data without slowdowns. Some months I have downloaded around 200-400GB on a normal 40$/month cellular plan with no extra charges.
- BeeOnRope 6y agoIn Chile I pay about 5,400 pesos, about $7, for unlimited LTE, unlimited calls, unlimited tethering. Speeds are OK, between 5 and 20 Mbps usually.
- rayiner 6y ago
- kayson 6y agoThat's not what I meant. With higher SNR you can achieve much better spectral efficiency, so it makes more sense for spectrum-time use to allocate the most bandwidth to high SNR users as they need it. It's not a constant or necessarily noticeable thing. My example was an extreme one for illustrative purposes. It could just as well be downloading 1MB of web content at 300Mb/s.
- hammock 6y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Induced_demand
- Reason077 6y agoTrue. If it weren't for 5G, I probably wouldn't be streaming games in 1080p from Google Stadia over a mobile connection.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- bob1029 6y agoI do think there are some reasonable limits to look forward to WRT average bandwidth consumption by a typical user. For instance, there is a maximum display resolution after which point it does not make any sense to continue adding pixels, color depth or redraws per second. Most would successfully argue that we have hit that point years ago. For such displays, there is a constant maximum amount of video information that could be presented per unit time. This is somewhere in the realm of 10~1000mbps. Audio is another good example where we've decided that ~1.5 mbps for uncompressed stereo audio is about as much as you'd ever really need. Beyond this, there isn't a whole lot else that consumes substantial bandwidth per device. Assuming all gaming would be streaming over such incredible networks and A/V technologies, there is no need to worry about archaic things such as application binary, texture or other asset sizes.
- wlesieutre 6y agoAnd don't forget that these assets are being downloaded from services that have to pay to store them and then pay for upload bandwidth to send them to you. If you browse to an imgur hosted image on a mobile device, you'll find that the quality is visibly bad. And it's not because the client didn't have enough bandwidth.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- Dylan16807 6y agoStreaming video is the most intense use you'd see these days. Once you hit several mbps more bandwidth doesn't improve it, so yes you would get each user off the radio faster. You'll get more users if the network is less congested, but that's a good thing.
- eru 6y ago> Increased speeds mean people use more internet, not less. Do keep in mind that mobile devices have bottlenecks other than Internet speed. Eg limited battery. Or just plain old limited monthly data volume. > The only real answer is massive and constantly increasing speeds and bandwidth capacities. It is a race that cannot be won but must be run nevertheless. The victory is in giving people more Internet. They like that.
- cm2187 6y agoAnd how many pixels are visible to the naked eye on a small screen.
- eru 6y agoQuite a few. Though to be honest, 4k is currently good enough for me, resolution wise. But: even the highest bitrates you get on eg YouTube ain't good enough to show certain scenes nicely. Especially when snow is involved. That's because the video compression algorithms we have don't cope well with that. See https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r6Rp-uo6HmI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r6Rp-uo6HmI So there's a clear and simple use case for more bandwidth, even if we don't increase resolution.
- deelowe 6y ago> Increased speeds mean people use more internet, not less. Do you have reports that show this? I've read a recent isp report that show as people moved to gigabit fiber, their usage didn't go up as had been feared. The report showed that beyond a certain number, something like 100mb/s, usage no longer went up as bandwidth increased. Additionally, infrastructure costs went significantly down for the ISP showing that moving to fiber everywhere makes good financial sense for them. This isn't surprising at all. We see this in computing as well. When designing clusters, other network specs such a latency and jitter become the bottleneck above certain speeds, depending on the application.