10 ms·
I would be curious to see analysis for what home prices would be with 0 Fed intervention. It is an interesting thought experiment. From what I've gathered, an
by refurb 6y ago
I would be curious to see analysis for what home prices would be with 0 Fed intervention.
It is an interesting thought experiment. From what I've gathered, any intervention by the government to make housing more accessible, just gets priced in pretty quickly, removing the benefit.
For example, FHA offering 5% down payments instead of a standard 20%, just means every first time buyer can now pay 15% more (approximately) for a house. In hot markets, the prices rise quickly to reflect that and everyone is in the same position as before.
It obviously benefits buyers in non-hot markets. It's pretty nice to put $7500 down in the mid-west for a house.
I assume that without any federal intervention, the housing prices would be as accessible as they are today, prices would just be lower so that that the same number of people could afford 20% down and 5-year term mortgages with the resulting interest rate risk.
- postingawayonhn 6y ago> For example, FHA offering 5% down payments instead of a standard 20%, just means every first time buyer can now pay 15% more (approximately) for a house. Assuming they had the same deposit available they would theoretically be able to pay 300% more. Of course they probably wouldn't be able to demonstrate their ability to service a loan that large.
- sokoloff 6y agoOr, if they had the income to service a 4x loan, they could quickly save additional down payment towards an 80%LTV loan.
- CydeWeys 6y agoThey're not gonna pay 300% because they wouldn't be able to pay even the first monthly mortgage payment. Buyers aren't stupid -- they'll take advantage of low money down but they won't get themselves into a mortgage that they literally already can't afford the payment on from day one. No, the way mortgage problems typically happen is that the payments are initially affordable but then something changes (typically job loss).
- sethammons 6y agoWaves from 2005 where people literally could not afford the loan they just were given. I knew a couple of people who just planned on flipping so didn’t worry about the inability to service the loan.
- ryathal 6y agoPeople will absolutely try to take out mortgages they can't afford. Post 2008 rules make giving a mortgage to someone who can't afford the first month nearly impossible, but you can still get a mortgage that will crush you without a job loss.
- macca321 6y agoMortgage repayments are much cheaper than renting, at least where I am in London
- zalkota 6y agoAre you just disregarding the mortgage payment?
- harry8 6y ago>any intervention by the government to make housing more accessible, just gets priced in pretty quickly, removing the benefit. If a large number of mortgages forclosed without the fed this would put a hell of a lot of downward pressure on prices. Economic carnage style. That hot market. It's getting pretty cold. Does that make houses more affordable for those frozen out? Or are they now unemployed with the zero intevention and/or unable to get a loan in that cold market making the benefit from the carnage nothing? Whether it's the right thing to do for the overall economy and all in it, keeping house prices up is clearly something the boomers want so they can keep their very large gains from having got in early. Younger generations may look at this and see more than simple coincidence.
- danvasquez29 6y agowhen people are living (and budgeting) paycheck to paycheck, with low interest rates, the prices go up a bit more than 1:1. It becomes all about what monthly payment you can afford.
- johnchristopher 6y ago> In hot markets, the prices rise quickly to reflect that and everyone is in the same position as before. Except for the government's budget, right ?
- glenstein 6y ago>just means every first time buyer can now pay 15% more (approximately) for a house Wait, what? Wouldn't it mean that a pool of prospective buyers that couldn't afford 20% but can afford 5% are now able to buy a house? That's a shift in the structure of the market rather than just a change being "priced in" for the same set of buyers. >In hot markets, the prices rise quickly to reflect that and everyone is in the same position as before. I would think this is the kind of question where we need data. I like to think I respect the exercise of thought experimenting more than your average person, but in this case, it seems to illustrate how thought experiments serve to answer questions by restating their core assumptions rather than exposing them to challenges in the way data would.
- tialaramex 6y ago> Wait, what? Wouldn't it mean that a pool of prospective buyers that couldn't afford 20% but can afford 5% are now able to buy a house? No. Real property doesn't work that way at all. The effect of most of this kind of government intervention in the housing market is to subsidise developers. In fact it's so bad that in the UK shareholders of such a developer are outraged because the uncapped bonus structure for executives at the developer means they get enormous (many times annual salary) bonuses essentially directly funded by central government which the shareholders of course think instead ought to all be profits assignable as dividends, not "bonus payments" for executives whose "performance" amounts to just sitting back and collecting free money from central government. Like there's not even doubt there about what this government money does, it goes to the house builders, it can't and doesn't magically produce more homes, the argument is about who gets to keep the loot. Government can intervene to actually build homes, and that would actually work, but NIMBYs hate it, so if a government doesn't actually care about housing people then a policy that can be headlined as support for home buyers but actually just puts money in the pockets of the wealthy is a good choice.
- gbasin 6y agoDevelopers can't get FHA loans
- 6y ago
- ced 6y agoIt is an interesting thought experiment. From what I've gathered, any intervention by the government to make housing more accessible, just gets priced in pretty quickly, removing the benefit. It benefits home owners, which (at least in Canada) makes up the majority of the voting base. Like GP said, it's at the expense of the next generation of buyers.
- gwd 6y ago> From what I've gathered, any intervention by the government to make housing more accessible, just gets priced in pretty quickly, removing the benefit. You say "any intervention", but you've only mentioned interventions that give more money. Other interventions: 1. Encouraging developers to build new properties, particularly properties for low- and medium-income tenants 2. The government building low- to medium-income housing themselves. The problem with any policy, of course, which aims to bring down the prices of houses makes everyone who's already bought a house very unhappy.
- tfigment 6y agoAnd they get unhappy because they have been trained to think of housing as investment that should grow faster than inflation rather than a place to live.
- tnel77 6y agoYou don’t treat a couple hundred thousand dollars as an investment? Sounds privileged.
- oppenh3imer 6y agoIf the price of the house rises faster than inflation, it is a good investment. However, rising faster than inflation also means that they become proportionally less affordable over time. You cannot have both affordable housing and high returns from housing
- dragonwriter 6y ago> You cannot have both affordable housing and high returns from housing Sure, you can, but only if real estate in established neighborhoods is more expensive than housing in new neighborhoods, which isn't hyperlocally sustainable but might be sustainable over a broader region.
- thebean11 6y agoYou sort of can, but it requires increasing density (so per square foot stays similar but those with low incomes can still afford a small place) or older neighborhoods becoming more expensive than newer neighborhoods (happens all the time).
- _Anken 6y ago> It obviously benefits buyers in non-hot markets. It's pretty nice to put $7500 down in the mid-west for a house. Unfortunately banks won't loan what they see as small mortgages like that. This leaves the lower priced homes only available to landlords buying cash. I live in a home like this myself - all the banks would happily loan me $215,000 with $35k down, but no bank would loan me $15,000 to buy a $50k house. There's many people renting in my city that have decent credit that could easily afford one of these lower cost homes, but instead the houses stay empty or get turned in to rentals.
- pc86 6y ago> all the banks would happily loan me $215,000 with $35k down, but no bank would loan me $15,000 to buy a $50k house. This seems like a made up problem. Those same banks would also gladly loan you $40k with $10k down, and you could have the remainder to fix the house up or make huge payments every month. Furthermore, if you already have $35k it shouldn't be too difficult to save another $15k and buy the house cash. If it is, you probably can't qualify for the mortgage payment on either property based on your income.
- mtcoopee 6y agoThat's what FHA is for, allows you to put 5% down. When I bought my first home, I put down 2000 in 2015 using FHA + state grants.
- sjg007 6y agoHuh? This is nonsense. You can indeed buy a 50k house if the house appraises at that value. You can also get an improvement loan included to make it livable as well if necessary.
- johnrgrace 6y agoFHA offering 5% instead of 20% down payments means first time buyers can buy 4x the house.