11 ms·
I agree. Parents are making sacrifices which benefit society as a whole. Those children the parents are taking care of now will be the ones who will provide fo
by mc32 6y ago
I agree. Parents are making sacrifices which benefit society as a whole. Those children the parents are taking care of now will be the ones who will provide for the one complaining now via taxes as well as services rendered to them.
If anything, companies should be providing more childcare so that more women (as well as some men) will have less of a burden balancing career and caregiving.
I see these people as being petty complainers who wouldn’t raise their own children (own or adopted) but complain someone else is willing to be a productive member of society engaging in the workforce and raising the productive adults of tomorrow when these complainers will be asking for benefits and services that would be unavailable without future adults.
It's similar to "I don't take the bus, why should my taxes pay for public transit."
I would concede if there are people exploiting this privilege then that’s a problem and management should address it.
- ng12 6y agoWhat I've seen is the complaints are largely coming from couples that want to raise kids while both parents work full time jobs. Asking for fewer hours so you can continue that lifestyle is asking your employer and fellow employees to subsidize your second income, not your ability to have and raise children. My coworkers with SAH spouses aren't feeling the burn anywhere near as badly -- it's just an extended summer for them. I feel a lot of empathy for single parents but those seem to be relatively rare in the field.
- puszczyk 6y agoI think school and day care are a reasonable assumption. It’s a bit unfair to say — _keep your spouse at home because there maybe once-in-a-lifetime pandemic and the schools will be closed_.
- alisonkisk 6y agoIt's more fair to say "save some money for a rainy day" or "you will have to sacrifice some of your quality of life and savings due to the pandemic".
- christinamltn 6y agoBut right now you very often can’t apply money to fix these problems.
- mc32 6y agoI would definitely agree the ones hit hardest would be the single parents and would deserve the most flexibility. That would be tough. With regard to dual income parents. I’d give them some slack, but as always, abuse of good intentions is why we end up not having good things. I’d hope they’d be able to trade roles during their respective busy times. As I’ve said before... it’s very rare anyone performs above 50% of their time “working”. So it’s not like WFH (or office) is like hamsters in a hamster wheel all day long. If they can coördinate switching on and off they should be able to pull it off with exceptions.
- coffeemaniac 6y ago> I’d give them some slack, but as always, abuse of good intentions is why we end up not having good things Taking marital status into account of how much "slack" you grant an employee is forbidden by law.
- CydeWeys 6y agoIn modern society it's basically required that both parents work full-time jobs. It's not the 50s anymore; you can't support an entire household with children on one income. So you can't have the expectation that one of the parents give up a large chunk of their salary just to have kids. If you do structure society in this way then you get rapidly declining birth rates and very bad long-term population demographic problems (which many countries are already dealing with). Personally I think the best solution would be to have universal child care going down to age 0 (rather than just age 5 as it is now), which is common in many other countries. Because of efficiencies of scale, that's cheaper than subsidizing all the foregone salary required by parents all individually giving up one of their two household jobs to devote to child-rearing.
- rayiner 6y agoIt’s not just the cost of childcare. Since divorce became acceptable, it became a huge liability for women to exit the workforce and permanently give up earning power to raise children. I’ve seen this first hand in my family and it’s really difficult.
- bradlys 6y ago> Since divorce became acceptable, it became a huge liability for women to exit the workforce and permanently give up earning power to raise children. Where are these anecdotes from? Of the divorced men I know in California - they're on the hook for a lot of money. Their wives chose to not work (first few years to do childcare - remaining years because they didn't want to). The women didn't want to be in the relationship anymore and got a divorce. The men end up owing their spouses alimony for decades plus child support (regardless of where the kids spend the most time). As a straight man, I've decided to not marry based on their horror stories alone. I see marrying someone who wants to be a SAHM as a huge financial liability not in just temporary loss of earning potential but in near permanent levels of loss due to potential divorce.
- rayiner 6y agoMy mother in law gave up a job as an executive (where she was earning more than her surgeon husband) to be a stay at home mom. Coming back into the workforce 20 years later when the marriage deteriorated was nearly impossible. I don’t know what horror stories you’ve seen. But for most ordinary men, alimony and child support add up to very little. If you make $75,000, maintenance for a 15 year marriage in which the other spouse earned nothing adds up to $22,000 a year. And it ends in about 11 years. A significant hit, no doubt, but if the other spouse had similar earning potential (which is typical these days—people tend to match up with people of similar education) it won’t come close to covering the lifetime loss in post-divorce earnings. It can be different if a high earning person marries someone who has limited earning power, but that’s the exception these days.
- satyrnein 6y agoThis is a fair point that I had not considered. The more positive spin is that it's a sacrifice to move toward an egalitarian society where women have the same career options as men.
- sulam 6y agoJust keep in mind, those people working two full time jobs might be barely making ends meeting in Silicon Valley. Maybe one is a tech writer earning 5-figures and the other is a nurse with a schedule they don't control and that doesn't give them real benefits (this is all too common). They can't afford to quit and now they have to juggle kids, too. Everything worked fine when the kids were in school and they could pay for after school care, but now both of those options have been removed. On top of everything else they also have to figure out how to organize their 3 bedroom place into two classrooms and an office. Oh and for the cherry on top, now you can't even be outside safely without a high quality mask on. And yes, I'm thinking of a specific couple -- this is not a made up situation.
- umvi 6y agoI hate to say "move", but if dual income is super hard to make ends meet in SV, it's time to move out of SV. The US is huge, there are tons of places with decent tech scene, but affordable housing on a 5-figure salary without needing dual income (Texas, Utah, etc.).
- CydeWeys 6y agoIt's easy to say move, but much harder to actually do it. A lot of people flat out cannot afford to move half-way across the country, period, full stop, nor can they afford the added risk of getting new jobs. Plus, odds are good their salary where they're moving to is less, so it's not clear that they'll easily now be able to survive on a single salary anyway. Plus, this solution isn't highly scalable; only so many people can do it.
- ryanobjc 6y agoPlus when you land there, you won't be getting help or support. So toss all your support network for more space. For some that's reasonable, but for many it is not, and presuming that it's their own 'fault' for not moving is not charitable.
- 6y ago
- jtsiskin 6y agoI’m not sure I buy this argument due to the disruptions of COVID. Pre-COVID, both parents working full time may have made total sense. With daycare, nannies, and/or school it’s perfectly reasonable both parents can have full time jobs. One parent may have even delayed their career during the youngest years and only recently resumed work. The issue now is COVID makes these childcare options impossible, so it isn’t the parents fault for both working, and they have a momentary huge increase in childcare responsibility. This is not something they could have planned for and suggesting one parent quits their job and stays at home is unfair.
- alisonkisk 6y agoPrivatized the gains, socialize the losses?
- MaximumYComb 6y agoI'm a single parent working full time from home in addition to some university that's online too. My children are young, right at the beginning of their school experience (7 and 5). It's not too bad. I spent years working my arse off after I became a single parent so I could have a career that also lets me be an involved parent. This year was meant to be my first relaxing year. It hasn't worked out that way but it's still an easier year for me than 2019 and 2018. I would go two months straight with 100-110 hours per week of time commitments. Maybe I have an advantage because I'm used to not having free time. Home schooling is at most 30 hours per week but in reality far less unless your child has special needs. My 7 year old is mostly autonomous. Let's assume 40 hours per week of work. That's still only 70 hours per week. People might need to just manage their hours better each week. I do a lot of homeschooling on weekends, the work we missed during the week when my kids needed help but I was busy. I don't see any reason schooling on weekends would be an issue?
- zem 6y agoit's not "your" second income, it's your spouse's first income! one person, one income.
- gones00n 6y ago"Benefit society as a whole" sounds good in theory but rarely works in practice because people are inherently self-interested. A simple counterargument is that someone's kids may not turn out at all to be productive members of society. Fundamentally corporations are different to the government. So whereas government can tax and progressively tax to soften wealth inequalities, corporations ultimately need to be profitable and revenue-positive to survive. A corporation can create benefits for certain employee demographics but there are financial limits. A dystopic result would be the separation of employees based on their parental status: most non-parents work for Company A, and most parents work for Company B. I wonder which of the 2 companies will be more successful (at least financially) in the long run.
- gimmeThaBeet 6y agoEvery productive member of society is someone's kid, whether they're home grown or an immigrant. You don't see some bad apples, declare your orchard blighted, and raze the whole thing. Not every apple is going to be perfect.
- CydeWeys 6y agoThe benefit to society as a whole is that human society literally continues to exist. If no one has children then society ceases to exist because there isn't a next generation. It's hard to think of anything that benefits society more than having children to comprise the next generation of society. And you know what's really bad for corporate profitability? Not having any workers in a few decades because conditions were such that no one now can afford to have the next generation of workers. The more people there are the better as far as companies are concerned. That's more potential workers and more potential consumers.
- CydeWeys 6y ago> Parents are making sacrifices which benefit society as a whole. 100%. We need people to have kids (and for it to be financially possible to do so) because kids are literally the future generations of human society, and if no one is having kids then we'll see a very rapid collapse. This is, incidentally, why it pisses me off when people complain that their pets don't get the same kind of accommodations that children do e.g. on airplanes or in restaurants, or that tax breaks exist for children. Your pets are optional. Children are mandatory. Not everyone has to have children, but enough people do. Having children isn't just planting trees for future society to enjoy the shade of, it's literally creating that future society (to reference an old proverb).
- YarickR2 6y agoPets are optional ? I didn't expect myself to hate this statement so much
- mc32 6y agoOptional for the continuation of society. Like say Elon going to Mars, he could take a pet. Pets provide some good, but they are not essential. Notice in poorer societies pets don’t enjoy the same privileged position they do in wealthy societies.
- grillvogel 6y agopets are required? i think most people who have kids agree that once you have kids you care a lot less about your pets than you did before
- outworlder 6y ago> Pets are optional ? I didn't expect myself to hate this statement so much They are just as optional as kids. Some of the comments here make it sound like they come from an alternate post-apocalyptic reality where they are trying to re-populate the planet. Not from this reality. You know, the one were we have a planet struggling to support the current and ever increasing population.
- icebraining 6y ago
- Mirioron 6y ago>Those children the parents are taking care of now will be the ones who will provide for the one complaining now via taxes as well as services rendered to them. >when these complainers will be asking for benefits and services that would be unavailable without future adults. But that's not the deal society is giving you. Society is forcing you to pay taxes now so that when you become old society will take care of you. The promise is unrelated to those future children. Society doesn't even give you the option to opt out from that. People aren't committing a noble sacrifice when they have children. They want to have children, it's a pretty strong drive for virtually any living being.
- quadrifoliate 6y ago> If anything, companies should be providing more childcare so that more women (as well as some men) will have less of a burden balancing career and caregiving. I think this is the crux of the matter; some people think that companies should not be doing this, society as a whole should through the age-old custom of voting. My other comment [1] on this thread elaborates. > It's similar to "I don't take the bus, why should my taxes pay for public transit." The difference is that public transit is a public utility. Anyone can use it if they want to. This is more like your employer offering transit that only parents can use. Everyone else is excluded – people who need to be caregivers for a relative, people who are suffering from depression, people who can't drive, etc. Naturally some of the latter group will think “What's so special about the parents that my employer who is a private company is making special concessions for them even when society isn't?” My solution to this would be basically just that – to open up more flexible schedules in general, and ideally based on what society as a whole wants. Unfortunately, any kind of attempts to make corporations give employees more flexibility by law are a non-starter in the US, which means that US society as a whole doesn't buy into this “We're all in it together” paradigm. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24414141 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24414141
- Aunche 6y agoThe difference is that the burden of taxes are distributed fairly (for the most part at least). If you need to pick up slack because your coworker is taking care of their kids, the burden is 100% yours. It would be like forcing you to foot your neighbor's cancer treatment.
- jelliclesfarm 6y agoWhat about parents of children who are a burden to society? Should they pay back the subsides recd for their bad seed?
- Zenbit_UX 6y agoYou're on quite a high horse there, why don't you step down so we can discuss facts? > I agree. Parents are making sacrifices which benefit society as a whole. The exact opposite is true. Bringing a first world child into this world is the single worse thing you can do to our planet. I'm making to sacrifice to not have a child for the planet, parents are not. They're in fact making an incredibly selfish decision to clone themselves despite all evidence showing their children will live through terrible conditions and may deal with famine, water shortages, mass migrations, and overpopulation.