10 ms·
It has been a few years, and despite a few attempts, I still don't really understand bitcoin. Yes yes ledgers and proof of work and yada yada, but I still don't
by nicbou 6y ago
It has been a few years, and despite a few attempts, I still don't really understand bitcoin. Yes yes ledgers and proof of work and yada yada, but I still don't know what I would need to do to buy something with bitcoin right now.
As I understand I need to do something that's pretty much exactly like opening a bank account, but transactions take forever, they cost money, and the currency is not accepted by any business I use, unlike my free credit card.
I have 55€ in my wallet and everyone on this continent knows what to do with it.
- sanderjd 6y agoIt's simple: it is an abject failure as a currency. It is fairly successful as a security for the purpose of speculation. If you aren't a financial speculator, you really don't need to pay attention to it.
- int_19h 6y agoIt's also fairly successful as a way to transfer money.
- hkt 6y agoAnd until recently, a highly successful way to _launder_ it.
- meowface 6y agoSome other cryptocurrencies designed around anonymity are still very effective for that purpose. The only weaknesses are at the spots where the funds enter and exit the "laundry". (Converting to/from fiat or a less anonymous cryptocurrency.)
- buzzdenver 6y agoWhy did it stop being that?
- d3nj4l 6y agoBecause more secure cryptos, e.g. Monero, have picked up pace.
- perardi 6y agoI am pretty lucky that I only have to transfer money to between 2 countries that have heavily linked banking systems (US -> Canada), but I am not entirely sure what Bitcoin would get me in terms of transferring money. The fees are quite small on Transferwise, and also, I have…I don’t know what you want to call it…accountability? Reversibility? Reliability? Whatever fee I have to pay, the fact I get a known third-party with a papertrail is peace of mind.
- captainmuon 6y agoSome time ago I had a bunch of Chinese yuan on a Chinese account that I wanted to transfer to Europe. I couldn't do a wire transfer, and I couldn't bring them as cash since my German bank didn't want them. I could either pull 500 € a day via ATM (with large fees), or just send it via Bitcoin.
- riffraff 6y agoWhy couldn't you do a wire transfer?
- bmn__ 6y agoBefore 2009, export of RMB was completely prohibited. Afterwards, some restrictions were lifted, but AIUI they do not apply to J. Random Laowai.
- Bayart 6y agoNowadays, can people even have bank accounts in their names in China without Chinese ID ?
- GoblinSlayer 6y agoFiat financial systems are full of most arbitrary restrictions. My anecdote: I once wanted to deposit money, came to a bank, gave them a bank card, They: What is this? Me: Money. They: No, bring money.
- 6y ago
- abpavel 6y agoHowever "transfer money" is a market need, and there are a number of companies that are doing that. I had to switch after I ran the costs of the service vs transaction fees of bitcoin. It's not much, but it adds up.
- Shared404 6y ago> it is an abject failure as a currency. In the US perhaps. In at least one other country however... https://www.bbc.com/news/business-47553048 https://www.bbc.com/news/business-47553048 https://www.somagnews.com/bitcoin-becomes-the-dominant-currency-in-venezuela/ https://www.somagnews.com/bitcoin-becomes-the-dominant-curre...
- riffraff 6y agoThe second article makes a pretty strong claim but does not seem to have any proof other than "Venezuela uses crypto a lot", doesn't it?
- wsc981 6y agoI feel it's also a pretty decent store of value. Now some people will probably want to tell me that it's a bad store of value, since the value can fluctuate quite a bit on a day-to-day basis. Sure that true, but in the long run I am confident the value will only go up, whereas many fiat currencies will only go down, especially now due to QE (basically printing money) that's happening in Eurozone, the US, and many other regions [0][1] in the world as well. So in my view, it's pretty nice as an alternative to holding gold. Gold can be nice as well of course, but it's difficult to transport. If you keep gold in your home, at some point someone might break into your home and steal your gold. You could pay some company to store your gold, but perhaps in times of crises a government might step in and claim some of your gold. Crypto currencies can be easily held in a digital wallet or people can even just memorise the keys to their wallet in their brain. It's hard for governments to control crypto currencies and I'm sure some of the wealthiest people in the world now keep a certain small percentage of their wealth in cryptos as well as a hedge against fiat currencies, stock market crashes, etc... --- [0]: https://news.bitcoin.com/venezuela-bitcoin-use-hyperinflation-crypto-adoption/ https://news.bitcoin.com/venezuela-bitcoin-use-hyperinflatio... [1]: https://www.financemagnates.com/cryptocurrency/the-impact-of-inflation-on-crypto-adoption/ https://www.financemagnates.com/cryptocurrency/the-impact-of...
- gruez 6y ago>As I understand I need to do something that's pretty much exactly like opening a bank account Not really. If I want a bank account I need to fill out a page of paperwork requiring my name, address, social security number, citizenship information, income, occupation, date of birth, scans of various pieces of ID and/or other documents. Compare this to bitcoin where you only need to install an app, and new identities can be generated on-demand. It's true that trying to buy/sell bitcoins via an exchange will subject you to AML requirements, but in-person transactions won't. >transactions take forever, they cost money [...] unlike my free credit card. The cost and time it takes is mostly a function of how much demand is there for blockchain space. During periods of high transaction volume, you'll either have to pay high fees or wait a long time. You can see in this chart https://jochen-hoenicke.de/queue/#0,30d https://jochen-hoenicke.de/queue/#0,30d that there are periods of very high transaction fees (the yellow peaks correspond to a $3 fee for a typical transaction), but also periods with low transaction fees (the parts with blue troughs correspond to a $0.12 fee for a typical transaction). People in a hurry pay more and people who can wait pay less. It's a classic microeconomics. Credit cards aren't free either. The cost (around 2-3% in the US) is borne by the merchant. Cash has fees for handling, transportation, and storage. "Free" bank transfers (eg. vemo, SEPA) are typically restricted to consumers, are often part of a bigger banking package, which have fees or minimum balance requirements.
- TedDoesntTalk 6y ago> It's true that trying to buy/sell bitcoins via an exchange will subject you to AML requirements, but in-person transactions won't. Nobody does bitcoin transactions in person, at least not in America and not anyone I know. I have several bitcoins and the only way to use them is through an exchange like coinbase, who require the same identity documents that a bank does. You could argue “but you just have to find vendors who accept bitcoin!” But with 3 bitcoin I won’t find enough vendors to spend it on.
- gruez 6y ago>Nobody does bitcoin transactions in person, at least not in America and not anyone I know. https://localbitcoins.com/ https://localbitcoins.com/ >You could argue “but you just have to find vendors who accept bitcoin!” But with 3 bitcoin I won’t find enough vendors to spend it on. There are also bitcoin-for-gift-card stores, which vastly expands your vendor options.
- porknubbins 6y agoThe problem as I see it that it is nothing like opening a bank account... You don’t need to understand the banking system to use a bank account. Meanwhile normal people without a serious networking/distributed systems background will not really grasp what they are doing when using bitcoin and have to resort to googling steps and following them blindly. The fact that ETH gas prices are going through the roof because of Defi would be a huge leak in the abstraction for something like a bank.
- ric2b 6y ago> You don’t need to understand the banking system to use a bank account. Same for Bitcoin, you install a wallet app and use it. It's actually much easier than opening a bank account. > Meanwhile normal people without a serious networking/distributed systems background will not really grasp what they are doing They won't grasp what they're doing on their bank account without a serious economic/financial/law background either.
- companyhen 6y agoCommunities can create value. The Bitcoin community believes Bitcoin has value, so it does. It has unique tokenomics with a limited 21m supply and is backed by math and cryptography. That's all there is to understand. Look into the history of money. Crypto just allows communities to have value. Soon you will see many communities online creating governance tokens, something like "reddit coins" but better, and you will be able to sell them for another coin like DAI or USDC. You can already purchase Reddit MOONS from the r/cryptocurrency subreddit here: http://xmoon.exchange/ http://xmoon.exchange/
- tuatoru 6y ago> Crypto just allows communities to have value. So do stamps, coins, Star Wars figurines in original packaging, baseball cards, yada yada. At least you can look at those other things while you possess them.
- companyhen 6y agoYou can transact billions of dollars across the globe securely with a minimal transaction fee via Bitcoin. Don't see how that's possible with Star Wars cards. Guess some people prefer government fiat currency with unlimited supply. I'd rather store my wealth in something that was launched more fairly for all and deflationary, even if it is high risk. The future for blockchain tech is bright, a lot has happened during the past bear market and the DeFi giant is looming. https://defipulse.com https://defipulse.com
- Abishek_Muthian 6y agoOfftopic - I saw Bitcoin project on GitHub's artic code vault[1] and advertised heavily. But I couldn't find libbitorrent on it besides it being hosted on GitHub as well. Is this because the project owner hasn't enabled it or is there some other reason behind it? [1]https://archiveprogram.github.com/ https://archiveprogram.github.com/
- denkmoon 6y ago> I still don't know what I would need to do to buy something with bitcoin right now. but I think you do. You find a seller who is willing to accept the currency you're using, and you use whatever interface to the bitcoin network you've chosen to do "send x money to y identifier". No different to a regular EFT. You identified the exact problems. It's not that bitcoin transfers are some weird foreign concept, it's that they take forever, have high fees and aren't accepted universally. The major users of bitcoin as an actual currency rather than a speculative vehicle are places that can't use the more convenient forms of currency. Guaranteed they'd rather use USD if they could.
- nicbou 6y ago> You find a seller who is willing to accept the currency you're using Well that's a non-starter. If I wanted to buy a beer with bitcoin right now, I'd probably end up drinking tap water.
- denkmoon 6y agoSame deal if you tried to pay for a beer in the US using vietnamese dong. However if you wanted to purchase "illegal" drugs online you'd be hard pressed to find anyone who will accept your USD.
- xorcist 6y agoMost people have no use for most currencies. I, for example, have no use for the Argentine peso. That doesn't make it useless for someone else, who might for example live in Argentina. The day you want to hire someone who wants their payment in Bitcoin for some reason, that's when you'll have use for it.
- amelius 6y agoPGP suffered from a similar problem.
- centimeter 6y ago> pretty much exactly like opening a bank account You don't have to go anywhere, you don't have to provide any kind of ID or documentation, you don't have to wait around for a free salesperson. > but transactions take forever Bitcoin transactions are instantaneous. Look up "settlement cycle" if you want to make a direct comparison. Bitcoin final settlement usually takes about an hour, compared to anywhere from several days to several months for traditional payment. Credit card settlement is usually 60-90 days. > they cost money It costs less than a dollar to move ~any amount of money anywhere in the world with ~1hr settlement. A credit card usually costs something like $0.25 + 3%. > the currency is not accepted by any business I use... I have 55€ in my wallet and everyone on this continent knows what to do with it. I have AU$80 in my wallet and I'm pretty sure no one on your continent would take it. In fact, last time I traveled to SE Asia none of my debit cards worked for cash withdrawal and the only way I was able to get cash was with a Bitcoin ATM. So it worked very well for me!
- tracker1 6y agoYou don't REALLY need something like a bank account (exchange account) except to convert to/from the currency. You only need an electronic wallet. The transactions are where it gets really weird though. That said, unfortunately, short of a large nation state, or collection of banks also allowing exchange/transactions, I don't think it will ever take off. Even then, transaction times as you mention are not fast, and often are controlled by a limited number of organizations. What the technology does offer, is a means for multiple parties that don't trust each other to proceed with a transaction. This is often where "smart contracts" come into play, and also why banks are considering a cryptocurrency system(s) for inter-bank exchanges. In the end, those that win will largely be the incumbents imho. I setup bitcoin on a few machines really early on... and had a couple coins... but I had no way to "use" them and it was just costing electricity at the time... I deleted it all and didn't look back until they cleared $20k a coin. Kind of wish I at least saved a zip file of the wallets somewhere. Though if I'd kept mining, may have been worth something.