4 ms·
While the points about Assad's treatment are essentially true I'm not sure the author does himself a favour by engaging in relativism concerning the dubious pra
by Barrin92 6y ago
While the points about Assad's treatment are essentially true I'm not sure the author does himself a favour by engaging in relativism concerning the dubious practises of Wikileaks, Assange, and the probable connections or at least sympathy with the Russian government.
For example, concerning leaked internal Democratic emails "An even more important point, however, is that a transparency organisation like Wikileaks had no choice, after it was handed those documents, but to expose abuses by the Democratic party – whoever was the source."
I'm pretty sure Wikileaks is the sole authority when it comes to what they publish so they have that choice, and I'll never consider it ethical to leak internal documents of a political organisation, likely by a foreign party, to influence domestic politics.
I lost virtually all respect for Assange after reading
Daniel Domscheit-Berg's book on Wikileaks and Assange's conduct. Domscheit-Berg was second-in-command at Wikileaks, so it's hard to pretend that all of this is conjured up by the US government.
- brudgers 6y agolikely by a foreign party, to influence domestic politics. Assange didn't influence domestic politics and every thing he does is by a foreign party. He's Australian, mate. He had a rather legitimate interest in Clinton's candidacy because she had implied support for his assassination while serving as Secretary of State.
- matthewdgreen 6y agoI agree. Assange made a set of choices that had a political outcome, and he did it on purpose in the hopes that it would have such an outcome. One can argue all day about whether this interventionism was "ethical" or whether what Assange practiced was "journalism", but it doesn't really matter. The people who are deciding Assange's future -- the ones who Assange hoped to put into office -- don't give a crap about any of those questions.
- mc32 6y agoCouldn’t you apply this to all political scoops during a political campaign, when the reporter is on the opposing side —so all opposition reporters would not be journalists in this take.
- hallihax 6y agoWell exactly - this is the problem. When reporting documented, verifiable evidence is treated as 'political activism by journalists', everyone should be worried.
- matthewdgreen 6y agoMy point, which I should have made more clear, is that none of this matters. If every civil society and journalistic organization in the world rallied to the defense of Assange and agreed that he was performing essential reporting activities, it will have absolutely zero influence on the people who are targeting him.
- hallihax 6y agoAssange is on record dismissing both candidates in the 2016 election as terrible choices, and the DNC / Clinton documents WL released also included oppo-research on Trump. Wikileaks publications preceding and during the 2016 campaigns weren't targeted at damaging Clinton, as much as the Clinton camp and its surrogates like to claim. It was about informing the public, which is exactly what journalism is supposed to do. What people subsequently do with that information is entirely up to them.
- fanatic2pope 6y ago> “Hey Don. We have an unusual idea,” WikiLeaks wrote on October 21, 2016. “Leak us one or more of your father’s tax returns.” WikiLeaks then laid out three reasons why this would benefit both the Trumps and WikiLeaks. One, The New York Times had already published a fragment of Trump’s tax returns on October 1; two, the rest could come out any time “through the most biased source (e.g. NYT/MSNBC).” > It is the third reason, though, WikiLeaks wrote, that “is the real kicker.” “If we publish them it will dramatically improve the perception of our impartiality,” WikiLeaks explained. “That means that the vast amount of stuff that we are publishing on Clinton will have much higher impact, because it won’t be perceived as coming from a ‘pro-Trump’ ‘pro-Russia’ source.” It then provided an email address and link where the Trump campaign could send the tax returns, and adds, “The same for any other negative stuff (documents, recordings) that you think has a decent chance of coming out. Let us put it out.” https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2017/11/the-secret-correspondence-between-donald-trump-jr-and-wikileaks/545738/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2017/11/the-sec...
- hallihax 6y agoThis is called 'cultivating sources', not 'collusion'. In any case, the conversations led to nothing. WL wanted info and data - which is their trade, and to boost the reach and impact of their publications; again, completely normal. What's the problem, exactly?
- fanatic2pope 6y agoIf you don't see a problem with wikileaks specifically looking for a curated "leak" to help Trump's campaign and their own appearance of "impartiality", there's not much else to say here.
- raxxorrax 6y agoWikileaks looks perfectly solid compared to the US democrat party.
- beardwait 6y agoIt's crazy to me that everyone is onboard with hating journalists that do their job in reporting on the corruption and wrongdoing of politicians. The real criminals have done a great job of distracting everyone from their wrongdoings by making them all angry at the dude who reported on real news instead of spending 4 years reporting on things like "2 scoops"
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]