7 ms·
This is just a group that is using "right to repair" to get attention for themselves. Nice and topical, complete with a clickbait headline and "think of the ch
by reaperducer 6y ago
This is just a group that is using "right to repair" to get attention for themselves. Nice and topical, complete with a clickbait headline and "think of the children" plea.
The right to repair won't help the school computer shortage. There aren't enough broken computers, nor enough people able to repair them, to make a difference.
I'm in favor of the right to repair. I've been repairing broken computers and electronics almost my entire life. I have a couple of Apple machines on my bench right now that I'm bringing back to life. But this is just opportunistic attention-seeking.
And even if the most extreme ideals of "right to repair" were in place a decade ago, the situation would be the same as today because the need to manufacture new machines would have been lower, so we'd still have fewer available computers to sell or repair now.
- scarface74 6y agoAnd they are complaining that they can’t use them because they can’t remove the activation lock without the owner’s consent. That’s kind of the entire point. The government was actually pushing for something like an activation lock making stolen phones harder to use.
- wmf 6y agoHow many computers (not phones/tablets) have some sort of activation lock turned on? That part of the article is unclear.
- scarface74 6y agoI’m not aware of any PC that has an activation lock - maybe a bios password for a few but not many. Macs don’t have the concept of an activation lock do they? Even if it is password protected you can always reinstall the OS can’t you?
- wmf 6y agohttps://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208987 https://support.apple.com/en-us/HT208987 https://www.ifixit.com/News/34072/apples-activation-lock-will-make-it-very-difficult-to-refurbish-macs https://www.ifixit.com/News/34072/apples-activation-lock-wil... (biased obviously) Computrace may cause similar problems on PCs.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dehrmann 6y agoYeah; they didn't cite a great source about how repaired laptops can meet the need, they just had sales figures. I buy that unused computers in closets could help, but it's not clear how many there are or how broken they are. Also, lots of laptops actually are repairable. Maybe this is Thinkpad owner bias, but I've been able to find replacement parts for pretty much everything that'd broken on a Thinkpad. But at $150 to repair compared to $350 for a new, in-stock Chromebook?
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoIf you agree with the conclusion, why wouldn't you just politely concur? I agree it's not the strongest argument, but taking the time to point out that it isn't a strong argument weakens the position you ultimately agree with. With the amount of technology that ends up in landfills, characterizing it as ineffective may not be correct.
- ineedasername 6y agoIf your conclusion is correct but not actually supported by you premises the you are correct only by coincidence, lacking true understanding. Probing the premises upon which a conclusion is made, pointing out flaws, and then pointing out stronger reasons... That process strengthens an argument, it doesn't weaken it.
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoThat's precisely the point. There was no stronger argument presented in the original comment, leaving the entire argument for 'right to repair' in a weaker position.
- ineedasername 6y agoPointing out a poor argument doesn't require the person to present a stronger on for it to be helpful. A home inspection that reveals a crack in the foundation but doesn't repair it has still rendered a very important service.
- franga2000 6y ago> The right to repair won't help the school computer shortage. There aren't enough broken computers, nor enough people able to repair them, to make a difference. I don't know what you're basing your prediction on, but we've managed to provide computers to over half the students that didn't have one here in Slovenia since the pandemic started, by taking broken or outdated computers from companies and individuals that were going to throw them away, repairing them and putting a lightweight Linux on them. The only reason that was possible is that desktop PC parts are very well understood and available to everyone. On the other hand, we also have several shelves stacked with various brands of laptops and tablets that we get from people in hopes we can repair and donate them, but even with access to an electronics lab with serious equipment, we have not been able to repair a single one as the process for that is currently: 1. Inspect the board for obviously broken parts 2. Find the board number and search a bunch of fishy Russian and Polish sites for a schematic 3. Buy the schematic (illegal, btw) 4. Read through it to find the correct replacement components 5. If they aren't passive or something ubiquitous like a 555, you basically can't get them - cry 6. If there are non-obvious defects, spend a week studying the schematics to be able to start probing the board 7. If you find a bad part, goto 5., else cry The vast majority of laptop defects are small things that require very little effort to fix with decent equipment, but access to the knowledge and parts required is intentionally made difficult by the manufacturers. With access to both, more than half of the laptops on those shelves would be in the hands of students already.
- rasz 6y ago> spend a week studying the schematics to be able to start probing the board Sounds like you lack people with particular skills, no amount of documentation is going to solve that for you. I emailed you a present, feel free to ask for more detailed help if you need it.
- GrantZvolsky 6y agoIf right to repair takes off, it will make room for a Stack Exchange-like site dedicated to debugging and fixing hardware. That in turn will accelerate repair just like SO and github accelerate SW development.
- canofbars 6y agoSchools actually end up with a lot of broken computers because kids are careless and destructive. They would pick the keys off the laptops. You used to be able to trivially replace the keyboard on laptops without pulling the whole laptop apart but now apple seals it up with rivets.
- judge2020 6y agoI'd be surprised if macbooks had any marketshare in public schools. They all seem to be favoring tablets or chromebooks since iPads are $329 (probably $300 or less for schools) and Chromebooks are <$300 each and integrate with GSuite, which is also free for schools.
- tekknik 6y agoApple has been, and continues to be, very involved in education. When I last worked with them in education they were testing/bootstrapping a “one laptop per child” program using iBooks. After educational pricing an Apple machine may be cheaper than Chromebook or iPad. GSuite also has a replacement on mac. Really Google is getting to the game about 30+ years too late.
- fanatic2pope 6y agoYou might want to check again. Chromebooks are dominant in education now and it is Apple and Microsoft who are playing catch up. https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/20/apple-google-microsoft-are-battling-for-dominance-in-education.html https://www.cnbc.com/2019/03/20/apple-google-microsoft-are-b...
- tekknik 6y agoA couple of things here: I worked in the industry, this is first hand experience. But it was 20 some years ago. High schools mostly chose windows for various science software, otherwise it was macs. This is very regional. So Google may dominate in one region while Apple dominates in another. Google could be giving these Chromebooks away to have this metric to throw around. Does this mean they’re used? Maybe, maybe not.
- Legogris 6y ago> The right to repair won't help the school computer shortage. There aren't enough broken computers, nor enough people able to repair them, to make a difference. I don't know how it looks in most of the USA, but in Africa this is absolutely the case. In uni I was part of a nonprofit and as part of that I spent 3 weeks in rural South Africa traveling between schools to help with cleanup, maintenance, installation and some basic computer training for teachers and staff. The vast majority could not afford classroom computers on their own but relied on donations through organizations like the one who was sponsoring us - in a lot of cases refurbished equipment that in often needed hardware replacements and repairs due to the environment they were in.