3 ms·
That’s exactly my point: it’s entirely naive and insufficient for Google alone to promote “Don’t be evil” if, at any time, known-racist and known-politicized “l
by sneak 6y ago
That’s exactly my point: it’s entirely naive and insufficient for Google alone to promote “Don’t be evil” if, at any time, known-racist and known-politicized “law enforcement” in the US can do whatever evil they wish with the data they’ve collected. When PRISM came along, they had no choice but to comply or suffer the same fate as Joseph Nacchio.
One would have to be a total fool to think that an internal prohibition on evil would be at all meaningful, even if somehow it were strictly adhered to. Literally nobody at Google is willing to be imprisoned to defy the orders of the nation in which its situated.
(Before you point out that it requires judicial oversight: please read a dozen federal search warrants. The standard for search warrants is hilaribad, and feds suffer no consequences whatsoever for putting whatever fantasies they want into their applications for same.)
- jlarocco 6y agoOh yeah, that I agree with. "Don't be evil," was always a gimmick, IMO. Not sure there's any real solution, though. As long as there's a government, there's going to be somebody who thinks it's evil.
- pbhjpbhj 6y ago>"Don't be evil," was always a gimmick, IMO. // Always? It struck me that it was a genuine creed for a burgeoning tech company who recognised established tech companies were evil, and so were themselves endeavouring to be "not evil".
- jstarfish 6y agoThe worst people you'll ever meet are always very forthcoming with insisting that they aren't monsters-- well before you've had any cause to question their integrity. Consider their business model from day 1. It didn't take long before the allegations of email data mining started to surface.
- cromwellian 6y agoPeople who constantly status-signal over absolutes also raise concerns over hypocrisy and situational ethics.
- XMPPwocky 6y agoWhat do you mean by this?
- jlarocco 6y agoYes, always. No company is explicitly, purposefully doing evil. Also, "evil" is such a subjective word that it's almost meaningless with no context.