7 ms·
> But a few years after it's over, we'll be acting as if [COVID] never happened. We're good at that. I fear this prediction won't come true. There's a great r
by samatman 6y ago
> But a few years after it's over, we'll be acting as if [COVID] never happened. We're good at that.
I fear this prediction won't come true.
There's a great risk that 'health theatre' will join security theatre as a durable if not permanent part of our existence. That years from now, we'll be getting temperatures checked, schools will be shutting down for worse-than-usual influenzas, and so on.
I still can't bring an ordinary-sized yogurt on a plane, and have to remove my belt and shoes. Something made our society irrationally risk-averse, and I glumly suspect that COVID won't be the turning point in that trend.
- jkubicek 6y agoI don't think there's any chance at all this is going to happen. Security theater in airports is perpetuated by an agency that depends on fear to secure its funding and a government that depends on us fighting the "bad guys" (even if they aren't any close to as dangerous as they want us to think). COVID fear isn't being perpetuated by any government agencies at the national level. If anything, the federal government desperately wants us to forget that COVID exists. Once the actual risks are gone, we're going to go right back to normal, though hopefully we will have learned a lot of lessons about pandemic preparedness.
- hkai 6y agoThe federal government doesn't promote the covid fear only because of which party is in power right now. One of the presidential candidates promises a nationwide mask mandate, and, judging from the actions of authorities in NYC or other places, there will be other severe restrictions on freedom of business, assembly and travel. So yes, I also tend to agree that many people will continue supporting the health theater and fears for the foreseeable future.
- specialist 6y agoWhat plan do you favor for ending the pandemic?
- hkai 6y agoUnless the IFR of covid is shown to be significantly higher than other common diseases that we accept and don't fight by locking down cities, it doesn't seem that any major, world-shattering intervention is needed. Please wash your hands for 20 seconds though, and don't come to the office if you're sick.
- take_a_breath 6y agoThis isn’t proof that those measures will stay in place after the pandemic subsides, as they have for travel. Since you brought up political parties, it’s worth noting that the party who lead that round of fear is the one in power.
- adventured 6y ago> One of the presidential candidates promises a nationwide mask mandate Fearing polls, Biden has run away from his position (made multiple times on record) of a national mask requirement. The other day he lied and said he never said it in the first place, claimed he's a constitutionalist and wouldn't seek a mask requirement because of that. This was all on video. So who knows what to believe from these clowns.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoI fail to see how this is "health theater", especially mask mandates, which show high effectiveness and relatively low imposition on personal freedoms, considering the pandemic is currently ongoing.
- whiddershins 6y agoCitation needed. Where are deaths increasing?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- whiddershins 6y agoI’ll answer my own question: India. India is a big country and deaths are going up there. The US and Europe seem past it to me.
- maxfurman 6y agoHere in Philadelphia, cases and deaths are both spiking. Not as bad yet as the peak from April but the pandemic certainly is not past us.
- whiddershins 6y agoI just looked it up and there were 4 deaths in all of Pennsylvania yesterday.
- tasogare 6y agoThe pandemic has stopped. Sure, there are more and more infected people, yet the hospital admissions are stale. It’s really hard to understand why governments that first reacted like there was no problem when the situation emerged and the virus was totally unknown are now acting like it’s a deadly threat when the data clearly shows it’s only a real issue in aged population. Sure taking precautions is good, imposing authoritarian sanitary rules is not. At least in France the situation is clearly being used to control opposition, which was strong before the pandemic since the government tried to push a lot of economic reforms. Now, the economy was purposely destroyed there, so harsher reforms will be imposed and people will be really angry when they’ll discover the lockdown was not needed (for the record, I live in Japan where there was no lockdown and things went totally fine). The sanitary rules will be used to control those revolts too. The fact it is a political only move was made super clear when the government allowed huge demonstrations that mimicried BLM in June.
- hkai 6y agoNot to mention that mass media is an agency nearly entirely dedicated to promoting health theater. "You and your children will die soon and there's almost no way to stop it" is the dominating message on the front page of many media organizations.
- MaysonL 6y agoName one, please. EDIT to add: with a link or screenshot.
- hkai 6y agoHave you read any news recently? CNN: "A whole generation wiped out" "China still vulnerable to deadly second wave" "Covid-19 tests could encourage workers to play Russian roulette" "Stories of discarded bodies reveal a city totally overwhelmed by covid-19" "Coronavirus may lurk deep in lungs after patients recover" "Nearly all patients put on ventilators died" "Welcome to the house of horror" "Covid-19 causes sudden strokes in young adults"
- DominikPeters 6y agoAirport security is very similar (if more efficient) in non-US airports, so rent seeking can't be the whole explanation. As far as I know, in most countries security is done by private contractors and not a government agency.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- danielheath 6y agoIIRC, if you want to fly through US airspace (say, to land an international flight in the US), the airport you are leaving has to comply with US airport security rules, so the rules are pretty standard everywhere.
- DominikPeters 6y agoMajor differences: no ID checks at security, and boarding passes aren’t scanned by humans in make-work jobs, no shoes to be taken off. If it was mostly the US imposing on the rest of the world, you would see separate security for US flights in airports whose layout allow it (and international flights to USA already have lots of annoying extras, like adversarial interviews at the gate (e.g. AA at LHR), and hand searches of cabin luggage).
- firebaze 6y agoFlying within EU, the security theater boils down to restricting fluids to individually less than 100 ml in hand luggage, having all metallic stuff removed from your body as far as possible in order to be screened and maintaining a certain posture while being body-scanned. Occasionally your shoes will be scanned. That's it, at least from my (quite frequent within-EU flying experience) perspective.
- tim333 6y agoAnd annoying though the liquids thing is I can see an argument if terrorist types are thinking nitroglycerin or anything along those lines. I'm glad they allow nail scissors again (in EU) - that was kind of dumb.
- tazjin 6y agoI've had a thought about this that I haven't articulated before, so bear with me if this sounds a little rambly: There's a large group of people who've become extremely scared as a result of what's going on at the moment. Most of them haven't actually evaluated what the risk for them personally is, yet they've made significant changes to their behaviours in the name of the health theatre. On the other hand, you've got people who either are in life situations where that isn't an option or people who have actually done risk analysis. These people have not changed their behaviours much (beyond sticking to the random new legal requirements). Now for the thought: I think that many of these behavioural changes (or lack thereof) will stay, essentially meaning that we've got a group of people who will act as before and a group that will act (and overreact) irrationally from now on. I think this is going to give the people in the first group an advantage for getting things done, which can have interesting long-term implications.
- TheDong 6y agoI think there may be a third option: people recognize both that the risk is low and selfishly they need not change their behaviors, but they also recognize that the socially correct behavior is to change their behavior so in aggregate we lower risk. I do believe that the risk is fairly low right now. So low that if I'm only thinking of myself, there's not sufficient justification to change my behaviors. However, I also believe that if no one changed their behaviors, the risk would be high enough I'd have to (as is the nature of an exponentially spreading thing). As such, I behave how I need everyone else to: I change my behaviors in the hope everyone behaves similarly to me. For a very similar analogy, there's no need individually to get vaccinated risk wise. Developed countries have such a high level of vaccination that there's a vanishingly small probability you're exposed in your entire life to the things you're vaccinated against. There's a higher risk of side-effects from being vaccinated. However, if no one got vaccinated, the math doesn't work out anymore, and it's back to vaccination making sense for you as an individual. As such, most people get vaccinated since it's the socially conscious thing to do, it's what we ourselves need most other people to also do for our own health.
- somewhereoutth 6y ago
- WalterBright 6y ago> Something made our society irrationally risk-averse Our brains are finely tuned to detect danger. If there isn't any danger, danger will be exaggerated or simply invented. Our society has been very successful at eliminating all sorts of dangers, hence the irrational view of the remaining risk today.
- WanderPanda 6y ago- If there isn't any danger, danger will be exaggerated or simply invented. Citation needed
- WalterBright 6y agoRead any daily newspaper :-) and then compare to CDC statistics of what people actually die from.
- sombremesa 6y agoIsn't there any difference between claiming "our brains" do something versus a publication publishing something?
- dhbradshaw 6y agoI think this is insightful. Interestingly, in an immunology class I just took, the instructor suggested that allergies come from our immune system doing the same thing. If the environment is too sterile, it will come up with things to worry about even if the danger isn't really there.
- WalterBright 6y agoThat's what the doc told me, too.
- Zak 6y agoHere's one: a majority Americans surveyed on various occasions usually believe crime rates at the time of the survey are worse than some point in the past. This holds true even when there has actually been a large decrease in crime over the given interval. https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2016/11/16/voters-perceptions-of-crime-continue-to-conflict-with-reality/ https://www.pewresearch.org/fact-tank/2016/11/16/voters-perc...
- JMTQp8lwXL 6y agoThis analogy didn't one-hundred percent land with me. There's a difference between security theater and 'health theater'. The probability of getting on a compromised plane is the same for everyone. The consequences for getting COVID are different based on personal risk factors. Framing the discussion with the phrase 'health theater' suggests one's personal risk factor is low (which is wonderful, it's great that we have low-risk groups), but it unfortunately doesn't apply to everyone. Our health policy shouldn't be based on notions of one's individual risk.
- vlunkr 6y agoOn the other hand wouldn't it be good for some of the extra hygiene to stick around? Allowing kids to do online school when they're sick rather than prioritizing in-person attendance is a great step forward IMO. Not only because schools spread illness quickly, but because it's a horrible experience to be sick at school. Same goes for work.
- XorNot 6y agoNot getting sick at all this year has been an ironic benefit of measures to deal with the pandemic.
- hn_throwaway_99 6y agoPerhaps some, and I think the examples you give of staying home when sick are great ones. I also hope wearing masks when sick stays socially acceptable. That said, this "hyper sterilization" mindset is not appropriate if we're not in a pandemic. Copious hand sanitizer, social distancing, masks when not sick, limiting crowds, etc. are not needed when we're not in a pandemic and they have huge downsides for society.
- MaysonL 6y agoAnd when you've got a respiratory infection, wear a mask.
- CPLX 6y agoIt is worth noting that there has been a 40+ history of organized terrorism against commercial aviation with dozens of fatal attacks. It’s essentially a law enforcement problem. I agree liquid rules are ludicrous but the current situation didn’t happen overnight, and also it’s not that similar to an infectious disease threat.
- dustingetz 6y agoinexploitability, not risk aversion. Human systems behave in ways that are inexploitable, otherwise they are exploited.
- paxys 6y agoWe are at maybe the peak of the COVID crisis and none of this is happening in the USA. What makes you think things are going to change once we get back to normal?