10 ms·
The UK is actually the one that has ignored and destroyed ARM (and Imagination Technologies) and it has been compared to 'selling off the crown jewels' [0] to S
by rvz 6y ago
The UK is actually the one that has ignored and destroyed ARM (and Imagination Technologies) and it has been compared to 'selling off the crown jewels' [0] to SoftBank which was welcomed by a UK government cabinet minister in 2016 as a 'big vote of confidence in British business.' [1]
Actually, SoftBank got ARM at a special Brexit discount. For them, they saw it as the best deal of 2016 and for the UK, you might as well say they got scammed.
So fast forward to 2020, SoftBank didn't get that 10x return they wanted from ARM and is now selling to get a tiny profit, where it is apparently heading for Santa Clara.
The rest of the UK didn't care and didn't know what they had, until it was too late and the same fate was repeated for Imagination Technologies. What a shame.
[0] https://qz.com/734882/the-32-billion-japanese-takeover-of-a-british-tech-giant-is-not-a-big-vote-of-confidence-in-post-brexit-britain/ https://qz.com/734882/the-32-billion-japanese-takeover-of-a-...
[1] http://blog.policy.manchester.ac.uk/posts/2016/08/arm-holdings-takeover-deal-are-we-selling-the-crown-jewels/ http://blog.policy.manchester.ac.uk/posts/2016/08/arm-holdin...
- fluffything 6y agoThey should have thought about what could happen _before_ selling ARM. TBH seeing them crying is sad and pathetic.
- esperent 6y agoWho is "them" in your scenario? The entire British public? They didn't get a say in the matter. It was a small group of politicians and business folk. And as always, they are not the ones crying now because they made bank in the deal, no doubt.
- TulliusCicero 6y agoWell, collectively they did vote for the conservatives, who are exactly for this kind of thing.
- esperent 6y ago* Shadow organisations backed by US billionaires pumping hundred of millions of dollars into misinformation campaigns. * The Murdoch news empire which basically does the same thing. * Russia backed misinformation campaigns. * Decades of mismanagement of education. ... and probably lots more that I don't know about since I'm not from the UK. Blaming the misled and uneducated masses for this kind of thing just doesn't work.
- fluffything 6y agoThe ARM co-founder that's complaining in this story about how the people they sold their ARM shares to are not respecting their feelings by re-selling ARM to the highest bidder? Not sure how much money they made selling their stake on the company, but if Wikipedia's valuation for Acorn and ARM are correct, can't be more than a couple of million dollars. Those shares would be worth many billions of dollars today. --- Why do you think the brits have anything to do with anything? If ARM ends up being bought by NVIDIA, that would actually be this Hermann Hauser's guy fault for selling ARM for pocket change. Complaining that their buyer's buyer's buyer now wants to make money with those shares by selling them to the highest bidder is sad. If ARM was so important to him, then maybe they shouldn't have sold their stake on it in the first place... Making a show about it now is like complaining that your ex that you dumped now has a new boyfriend.
- frozenport 6y agoPerhaps ARMs success is precisely because its moving outside of the the UK?
- de_watcher 6y agoYou say "no 10x return", "reselling for tiny profit" and then "UK didn't care and didn't know what they had". What do you mean by that?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- almost_usual 6y agoYou’re comparing ARM pre SoftBank and post SoftBank. SoftBank has burnt a ridiculous amount of money and turns companies into money burning machines. I’m sure WeWork imploding and other portfolio businesses not meeting expectations are also influencing the sale.
- ethbr0 6y agoWould be curious on any Brits' opinions on if this (failure to support revolutionary technology) happens more there, and if so then why. Recognize biases of hindsight, but it seems like private equity markets in Britain aren't interested in technology at the requisite scale. There's an incredible historical tradition [1], but the majority tend to be either developed with the help of a (1) few angel investors (and the luck and smaller scale that entails) or (2) government contracts (and the politics that entails). [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_British_innovations_and_discoveries https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_British_innovations_...
- growlist 6y agoI've come to the conclusion that many of the powerful in the UK view the nation primarily as a means for personal gain of one kind of another, and have no particular attachment to the UK's history, culture, and people, indeed, many of them seem to view the English (in particular) with barely disguised contempt.
- someperson 6y agoThis statement is meaningful even if you replace UK with US, but the US is still where most of the revolutionary technology comes from
- ethbr0 6y agoThe US does lack a tradition of monarchy and/or a hereditary landowning class. Which is probably not nothing in subsequent social evolutions.
- brudgers 6y agoSince 1066.
- growlist 6y agoCorrect.
- tcldr 6y agoI attended a talk in the UK at Google Campus in London by Eric Schmidt. At the end of the talk there was some Q&A and one very apparently angry and frustrated member of the audience asked something along the lines of 'Do you think it's fair for Google and other big American Tech firms to keep buying up innovative and valuable British and European companies!?' Eric Schmidt immediately replied 'Well if you don't want us to buy them, then don't sell them!' It seems we're yet to learn that there's a possibility to go all the way.
- ChuckNorris89 6y ago100x this! I think it's our fault as Europeans that we don't value and invest in tech enough. Why is it the US's fault that they consider tech to be valuable to their economy and national security and we don't? What's stopping us from doing the same? As long as we'll keep treating tech as some cost center instead of a core business while we keep pumping money to keep afloat 19th century industries who's ships have sailed long ago, then we deserve what's coming to us.
- adventured 6y agoThat's a difficult and slippery slope type problem. If the Europeans stop the US from acquiring companies there, the US ends up doing the same to European companies trying to acquire US assets. We let Germany buy one of the most important companies on the planet in Monsanto. I consider Monsanto to be a national security level company, we should have never let it go. Seed & AG tech is critical for the coming century and Monsanto is one of the very few global giants. For a long time we've been allowing European pharma giants to catch up in biotech by acquiring several of our important biotech companies, as with Genentech, Genzyme, Baxalta, MedImmune, Bioverativ and so on. We let Germany's Merck buy up Sigma-Aldrich. We let our medtech juggernaut, Medtronic, rebase to Ireland, no doubt taking important IP and jobs with it over time. When I watch important US companies like Genzyme get consumed by a European company, I fully understand how the Europeans feel about ARM etc.
- coliveira 6y ago
- whereistimbo 6y agoUK seems to be easy to sell them out. Even France to this day still refuses dailymotion to be acquired by Chinese companies.
- kakwa_ 6y agoDailymotion is a bit of an exception, and somewhat of a waste (Specially when Orange, the national/historic telco operator in France, was forced to bought them by the government, and didn't help Dailymotion development). But one the other side, you have tons of small to mid size enterprises that got bought. For example, Adobe has bought quite a few French companies such as Neolane (marketing solution) Fotolia (image bank) or Alegoritmic (3D texture editor) in the past few years.
- kevingadd 6y agoThe withering death of Imagination Technologies isn't just bad for the UK tech industry either, IMO it slowed the progress of graphics technology, at least on mobile. I think it's inevitable that Apple would have taken all their graphics work in-house (as they did eventually) but given how successful the PowerVR chipset family was on mobile for a long time - and how robust their tech and overall design were - I suspect they could have kept doing well if the company remained well-funded and well-operated. Not only was Apple shipping their tech in phones, but Sony was shipping it in every PlayStation Vita as well. In another world, I could imagine the Nintendo Switch running on PowerVR tech. Instead, it's an NVIDIA SoC (not a bad one, to be fair)
- almost_usual 6y agoWeWork imploding and other portfolio companies not doing as well as expected could also be influencing the sale.
- valuearb 6y agoSoftBank massively overpaid for ARM, you can say they got a Brexit markup. There is almost no chance they make a profit on ARM.
- ksec 6y agoI am not sure I am reading this correctly? >SoftBank got ARM at a special Brexit discount... ARM was sold for $32B. It is easy to say they got a discount when even AMD is currently valued at $100B+ today. ( Yes.... the market is quite insane ) At the time many thought it was over priced, just like how WeWork was over priced. ARM make less total revenue than Intel's Net Profits. And at the time, $32B was 100x + its Earning. And I would not be surprised it is still in the three digit times earning in 2020. >So fast forward to 2020, SoftBank didn't get that 10x return I am not sure if SB wanted 10x return. But surely no one sane was expecting it to be $320B. You have RISC-V chipping away the bottom, low end embedded category, You have Qualcomm, ( or Had ) Huawei, Apple, Samsung representing ~80% of total Smartphone SoC Shipment. These four paid a one time license fees. I.e ARM could raise price for the next generation ARMv9, or current v8. But it wouldn't impact the big four. They could choose to stay with their current v8. It was the same with Imagination Technologies. Yes I am bitter mostly because I think Apple lied. ( They are still using PowerVR technology. ) I guess we may never know the full story. And it was sold off to some Chinese Capital. But IMG was not without its faults. Buying MIPS? Seriously? Had they done it 5 years earlier it might have been a better move. But when they bought it most MIPS vendors ( Mostly in Networking ) already had plan to move platform to ARM counter part. IMG PowerVR was competing with ARM Mali which is much cheaper ( ARM's main focus is licensing their CPU iP ). I dont see IMG fighting for more IP licensing, it seems they were happy Apple is using their IP and wants to simply continue to do what is working. And they could have sold themselves to Apple. Probably for a better price than they did to Chinese VC. I am not sure what is missing in the UK. But from a Strategic Perspective they are very often lacking vision and big picture. And that is especially true in Tech Industry. Talents within the UK saw their leaders and management have absolutely dismal understanding and decide to go somewhere else, mainly US.
- ansible 6y ago> You have RISC-V chipping away the bottom, low end embedded category... Yes. For relatively simple in-order cores, the RV32 instruction set is far simpler to implement than ARM, or even MIPS, and should be able to provide better performance. If the existing SW dev toolchain is sufficient for your needs right now, I think RISC-V can be a great choice for small embedded SoCs.