4 ms·
I think the bigger problem is that the general population does not want the law enforced. There is also a sentiment that there are so many laws on the books th
by s1artibartfast 6y ago
I think the bigger problem is that the general population does not want the law enforced.
There is also a sentiment that there are so many laws on the books that there is nothing wrong with breaking them or LEO letting people off the hook.
If the average person is good and still commits "3 felonies a day", then it is easy to believe that LEO is giving people a reprieve from systemic injustice, opposed to carrying out injustice.
Nobody shames an individual who get out of a speeding ticket with a warning, when the individual was randomly selected from 10,000 other speeders the same road that day.
- teknopaul 6y agoI agree with your sentiment, but clearly "the bigger problem" is that the system is corrupt.
- _jal 6y agoYou don't get one without the other. The collection of all laws is such that even, consistent application would be untenable. That which cannot work, doesn't; instead, enforcement becomes selective. At that point, you're doomed; your system only works by being a system "...of people, not laws".
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI disagree. I think this type corruption is inevitable when you have legal system where the police are responsible for arbitrarily enforcing the law on an arbitrary subset of offenders. If you remove or universally enforce the law, the grey area for this type of corruption will go away.
- thereisnospork 6y agoSure the system is corrupt, but selective enforcement is how corruption happens. Remove the mechanism and there stops being anything to be corrupt over. If everyone got pulled over and ticketed for speeding, every time, it would be impossible to e.g. pull over black drivers disproportionately, or give a warning in exchange for a PBA card.
- cm2187 6y agoOr charged for rioting and looting
- jacobolus 6y ago> If the average person is good and still commits "3 felonies a day", then it is easy to believe that LEO is giving people a reprieve from systemic injustice, opposed to carrying out injustice. It’s the same people arguing for maximal support of the police (e.g. to beat the shit out of people for no reason, to confiscate innocent people’s cash and just keep it, to threaten people with made up charges and get them to sign false confessions, to fabricate evidence, to illegally stalk and harass anti-police-brutality activists, etc., and suffer no consequences) and arguing that friends of the police shouldn’t get punished for their infractions if they have the special card. (And also the same people arguing against both things.) More realistically, the little “courtesy cards” are a result of tribalism and corruption, and have nothing whatsoever to do with “systemic injustice”.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI think you misunderstood my point and I don't see any contradiction. I am saying that the general public is not very offended by "courtesy cards" because they think the law is bad to begin with. If I don't think speeding and jaywalking should be a crime, I certainly don't care about people using cards to get off the hook for these crimes. I see this as a separate issue from police brutality, confiscation, ect.
- jacobolus 6y agoThe people promoting these courtesy cards have absolutely no problem with speeding and jaywalking being crimes, and in fact are proponents of police discretion to e.g. constantly pull black people over and give them tickets for made up infractions just for the fun of it. It isn’t the “friends and family” of the police who want to end stop-and-frisk, decriminalize minor drug offenses, end cash bail, stop funding police departments from speed traps, .... You have diametrically misunderstood the point of the “3 felonies a day” book/argument, and you are shoehorning it in here to confidently promote your pet theory, without evidence.
- s1artibartfast 6y ago>The people promoting these courtesy cards have absolutely no problem with speeding and jaywalking being crimes, and in fact are proponents of police discretion I agree on both counts. They are proponents of police discretion to let them off for crimes they dont want to be charged for, and have no problem with it. >to e.g. constantly pull black people over and give them tickets for made up infractions just for the fun of it. It isn’t the “friends and family” of the police who want to end stop-and-frisk, decriminalize minor drug offenses, end cash bail, stop funding police departments from speed traps, ... I disagree and dont know where you are getting this from. The characters in the article clearly wanted to get off the hook themselves, but that doesnt mean they want to see minorities targeted and abused. I want to get off the hook when stopped for speeding, but that doesnt mean I want police to be shooting and terrorizing minorities. >You have diametrically misunderstood the point of the “3 felonies a day” book/argument, and you are shoehorning it in here to confidently promote your pet theory, without evidence. Again, I disagree. The point of the book is that everyone is a criminal and LEO can currently use their discretion to go after anyone they choose to. MY POINT, is that by making 100% of citizens criminals, we have eroded public support for the enforcement of the law. Those who get get caught for everyday crimes are considered unlucky, and those who get off the hook are celebrated. We should enforce the laws we have uniformly, and get rid of the ones we don't want. This is far superior to unwanted laws on the books and rarely enforcing them hoping we wont be affected. Infrequently enforced laws are terrible for a number of reasons, but a big one is that those without power and connections are the ones who are most likely to be affected.
- scarface74 6y agoI think the bigger problem is that the general population does not want the law enforced They want the law enforced against people who don’t look like them. See the “War on Drugs” vs. “Drug Abuse is a Disease” when it hit “rural America”.