14 ms·
TSA tries out another biometric system
- Nacdor 6y agoLooks like it's already working again but I'll just leave these in case. Google cache: https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:qm8IZ5Rxq-4J:https://papersplease.org/wp/2020/09/01/tsa-tries-out-another-illegal-biometric-id-verification-system/+&cd=1&hl=en&ct=clnk&gl=us https://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:qm8IZ5... Text-only cache: http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:qm8IZ5Rxq-4J:https://papersplease.org/wp/2020/09/01/tsa-tries-out-another-illegal-biometric-id-verification-system/&hl=en&gl=us&strip=1&vwsrc=0 http://webcache.googleusercontent.com/search?q=cache:qm8IZ5R...
- btilly 6y agoIt stopped working again, so thanks.
- miguelmota 6y agoGetting a 404 on both links
- dessant 6y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20200902171741/https://papersplease.org/wp/2020/09/01/tsa-tries-out-another-illegal-biometric-id-verification-system/ https://web.archive.org/web/20200902171741/https://papersple...
- iammru 6y agoDemented
- gregallan 6y agoThis site is completely broken on mobile.
- kevinwang 6y agoYeah, "reader view" works fine though
- codazoda 6y agoExcept on Google for Android I only randomly see the reader or simple option. For this site, it's not there. This is a stupid "feature" of Chrome's. Edit: Got it. If I enable simple view in accessibility features, the option shows up for this site. The way it's implemented by Google is still dumb. This should be in the menu.
- stuff4ben 6y agoI don't know why it's a big deal to identify yourself when flying on planes? Being "illegal" because you have to remove your facemask is stupid as well. I'd rather have this than some underpaid, high school graduate who'd rather frisk all the pretty ladies that come by or racially profile others.
- sneak 6y agoShowing/checking ID to travel doesn’t make anyone safer, and it makes a lot of people less safe.
- apearson 6y agoHow does it make a lot of people less safe?
- thinkmassive 6y agoFrom the article: "each traveler has to touch the same ID card or passport scanner. Then, immediately after touching the scanner, they have to touch their face again to put their mask back on."
- pbhjpbhj 6y agoIt's a mag stripe reader isn't it, why do they have to touch it? Presumably you can use hand gel, and take the actions serially. And the whole thing is optional.
- techsupporter 6y ago> And the whole thing is optional. For now. Just like how going through the original "nude-o-scopes" was technically "optional" but TSA employees (I refuse to call them "officers") would give you no end of shit and pointlessly delay anyone who requested an opt-out.
- jkinudsjknds 6y ago
- beamatronic 6y agoContractor loses a laptop full of this data in 3...2....1....
- jcstauffer 6y agoI find that completely unrealistic... It will almost certainly be found on an unsecured S3 bucket
- Crosseye_Jack 6y agoMy money is on a unprotected Elasticsearch server.
- randylahey 6y agoDefinitely a password-less, Internet facing MongoDB instance.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoHow else will you get web scale security breaches?
- ev1 6y agoUnprotected MongoDB with committed writes turned off
- beamatronic 6y agoI agree that is very likely these days, but the laptop thing has happened before [1] [1] https://www.scmagazine.com/home/opinions/blogs/the-data-breach-blog/laptops-stolen-from-tsa-contractor-contain-personal-information-of-3930/ https://www.scmagazine.com/home/opinions/blogs/the-data-brea...
- tolbish 6y agoPress release: "A sophisticated cyberattack has breached our system. Although we assure you that no public data was accessed, we are advising those who have traveled within the last 10 years to assume a new identity."
- gavreh 6y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20200902162045/https://papersplease.org/wp/2020/09/01/tsa-tries-out-another-illegal-biometric-id-verification-system/ https://web.archive.org/web/20200902162045/https://papersple...
- WilTimSon 6y ago"Illegal" seems like a huge overstatement, especially since the COVID crisis isn't going to last forever (do I have to say 'fingers crossed'?) If they're stressing the illegality by saying the TSA doesn't have proper authority to do this, well, I'm no expert on US politics but I'm pretty sure they'd get that authority sooner than anyone would even think of changing this system.
- eesmith 6y agoThey stress that the TSA doesn't have the authority, not simply because of COVID. Eg, "we believe that in the absence of OMB arrproval [sic], assignment of an OMB Control Number, and a valid PRA notice including that OMB Control Number, the pRA provides an absolute defense against any sanctions for declining to have data from an ID card or passport collected by the TSA." The site links to an article of Form 415, which points out that the TSA has not had OMB approval for that form for 12 years, so "sooner" and "changing this system" are both long time scales.
- IncRnd 6y agoToo bad the TSA now acts as a gatekeeper for this website. Each time, before you post, you will need to scan your id and have your picture taken. Illegal is not an overstatement. The reasoning was given in the article - there are federal requirements on the TSA to have specific authorization. They can't just start to demand people's papers in order to travel! Police demanding to see people's papers has happened elsewhere, and the whole world knows why that was done and how it turned out.
- al3xandre 6y agoThose things are basically standard in other (developed ;) ) parts of the world. Like in Singapore you just skim through immigration in 30sc by flashing your passport and fingerprint/face. Never get any queue... quite enjoyable. While I agree that entrusting this data to a third party provider is not ideal... I also don’t think that hiring people to look at your passport, and then your face before letting you in the country is the future... seems a bit archaic no?
- URSpider94 6y agoThe point the site is making is that this is primarily for DOMESTIC travel within the United States. I'm not a strong proponent of this point of view, but many people are highly opposed to any kind of ID check for travel within the borders of the US.
- voiper1 6y agoI had to stop reading because of the "S" in the font.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- ericcholis 6y agoThere's a number of companies that do this type of KYC for various online transactions. AU10TIX is one such, that apparently does identity verification for many airports in Europe.
- _red 6y agoCovid is the new form of this security theater. Just saw local school announced that parents should buy special mask with holes cut in mouth piece so kids can play instruments in band. Wish I was kidding...
- ticmasta 6y agoThe province of New Brunswick announced their plans for choir after "some of the hardest planning and preparation of my career" (from the Minister of Education). The master plan: "sing quietly"
- newacct583 6y agoIn fact there was a paper in just the last few days showing that voice volume correlated strongly with aerosol particles emitted. That sounds like good advice to me, likewise singing inside a mask. Obviously not singing at all is safer still, but this still seems like it would be effective mitigation. Even worse than "security theater" precautions are misunderstandings of the threat model. Pandemic mitigation is not a boolean function. Do what you can and choose strategies to sustain suppression, then stop. Find efficiencies where they lie. In a low-infection-count region, I don't see why you can't sing quietly in a chorus with masks. It's surely safer than eating in a restaurant.
- clairity 6y ago> "misunderstandings of the threat model" > "It's surely safer than eating in a restaurant." by saying "safer", without any qualifiers on magnitude, that's making the same mistake. most things we do on a daily basis are safe. being 0.001% less likely to get infected is technically safer, but not practically so. what's not relatively safe? gathering with random people breathing each other's direct exhaust for long periods. now, you might think a restaurant is an example of that, but it's not. yes, you'll be sharing exhaust with your tablemates, but you shouldn't be eating with people you don't know/trust in any indoor setting, not just in restaurants. and with just a little precaution (i.e., distance), tables are relatively isolated transmission-wise, despite the general misperception of the risks of aerosol transmission (most people aren't infected, but when they are, virus particles land nearby and fall apart relatively quickly). restaurants aren't particularly unsafe. the same can't be said for bars and clubs, which resist such safety mitigations by their very nature. also, if singing softer is the only mitigation, rather than distancing with an awareness of vocal exhaust flow, then it isn't really much safer. avoiding extended exposure to natural exhaust is the key, proper distancing being the easiest (and often least inconvenient) and therefore most effective measure.
- camillomiller 6y agoBut hey, let‘s ban TikTok.
- saxonww 6y agoIsn't this just an actual use of the RealID for its (purported) intended purpose? Don't get me wrong: I don't like this at all, and I think the TSA is at best worthless, but this seems like a complaint that the inevitable happened. And resting a legality accusation on a form not having a paperwork reduction act notice is kind of :eyeroll: even if it's true.
- njarboe 6y agoYou don't have to show ID to get past security at the airport. Lose your wallet on vacation and you can still fly home. Tell them you don't have ID and you'll get a special security check. How that will work in practice at different airports and for different people with different TSA agents is hard to say. Could be a answering a few questions, a pat down, and a quick chemical test or something else much more involved.
- briandear 6y agoNot completely true. You do have to confirm your identify to the satisfaction of the security officer. So while you technically can fly without an ID, you still have to prove your identity. The ID card is just an expedited way to do that. https://www.tsa.gov/travel/security-screening/identification https://www.tsa.gov/travel/security-screening/identification “ In the event you arrive at the airport without valid identification, because it is lost or at home, you may still be allowed to fly. The TSA officer may ask you to complete an identity verification process which includes collecting information such as your name, current address, and other personal information to confirm your identity. If your identity is confirmed, you will be allowed to enter the screening checkpoint. You will be subject to additional screening, to include a patdown and screening of carry-on property. You will not be allowed to enter the security checkpoint if your identity cannot be confirmed, you choose to not provide proper identification or you decline to cooperate with the identity verification process.”
- jimbob45 6y agoPro tip: make photocopies of your documents and stuff them in your luggage in case your wallet gets pinched. Happened to my dad and it solved that issue quickly.
- gumby 6y agoWhat is the practical* justification / value of knowing the name of every air traveler? Literally how is safety in any way increased (or any other benefit obtained for that matter) for anyone, either traveler or non-traveler. I can’t even reason about cost or burden to benefit trade offs without knowing a benefit, and I have never seen any clearly stated. Just vague handwaves (“obviously this makes us safer” or circular justification. * I am not asking for legal justification, which is itself unclear as explained elsewhere on John’s site.
- mschuster91 6y ago> What is the practical* justification / value of knowing the name of every air traveler? Literally how is safety in any way increased (or any other benefit obtained for that matter) for anyone, either traveler or non-traveler. Having a giant government database that documents precisely the travels of all citizens. This can be cross referenced to put names to de-anonymize cellphones and SIMs that have been bought in cash.
- shajznnckfke 6y agoI figured the idea was to join the list of travelers with the list of people who have somehow been red-flagged as a terrorism risk. Your physical scanning will fail some fraction of the time, your electronic system will fail some of the time, but it’s less likely that they will both fail. I’m not saying I agree with this idea - perhaps a dedicated attacker could get around both systems. And I haven’t put much thought into the downsides of this system, so I don’t have an opinion of whether the tradeoffs are worth it.
- jgust 6y agoWith the ease and prevalence of identity theft these days, it seems almost trivial to do for any determined actor.
- shajznnckfke 6y agoPresumably the facial recognition system described in this post is meant to help address that issue.
- judge2020 6y agoNot illegal (even though it should be) unless they prevent you from flying without it. Currently you can go through security with no identification at all as long as you answer their questions and they can verify your citizenship some way (which can add a few hours to your tenure at the airport).
- JoshTriplett 6y agoThey've tried to make that as hard as possible, and in particular, they'll deny it if they think you're refusing to provide ID rather than just "forgot it" or some other reason they deem "legitimate".
- ColanR 6y agoHow would your citizenship be verified without identification?
- judge2020 6y agohttps://www.fodors.com/news/travel-tips/navigating-a-nightmare-how-to-get-through-tsa-without-an-id https://www.fodors.com/news/travel-tips/navigating-a-nightma...
- ErikVandeWater 6y agoIs there a term for something illegal recognized by the courts as legal? TSA searches fail to catch 95% of illicit objects (including bombs) according to their own tests and require detaining hundreds of millions of people per year who have not given any indication that they've done something wrong. If those searches aren't the "unreasonable searches" mentioned in the 4th amendment I don't know what is.
- altdatathrow 6y agoTSA was intentionally designed from day #1 to cause so much of a burden that people would willingly give up absolutely everything with regards to personal privacy in exchange for saving time.
- eplanit 6y agoRemoving a face mask for a few seconds so that a person or algorithm can compare the person's visage to that of their ID is "giving up absolutely everything with regards to personal privacy"?
- altdatathrow 6y agoTSA has been around for nearly 20 years. It's not about a face mask. It's about how if you wanted to bypass the excruciatingly slow and invasive TSA checkpoints, you need https://www.tsa.gov/precheck https://www.tsa.gov/precheck or https://www.cbp.gov/travel/trusted-traveler-programs/global-entry https://www.cbp.gov/travel/trusted-traveler-programs/global-... which involve extremely thorough background checks. You sacrifice personal privacy in exchange for saving time. TSA has been a global people-tracking effort from the beginning through security theater. This is simply the latest addition to their repertoire.
- briandear 6y ago> ... in many jurisdictions, orders issued by state or local health authorities currently require all people in public places such as airports to wear masks. This premise is ridiculous. The Raleigh airport specifically addressed this: “ Am I required to keep my face covering on while processing through security? Travelers should wear a face covering while processing through security. TSA officers may ask an individual to adjust their face covering during the screening process for identification purposes, which is permitted under the executive order.” https://www.rdu.com/fly-confident-fly-rdu/face-coverings/#4 https://www.rdu.com/fly-confident-fly-rdu/face-coverings/#4 And from the actual North Carolina Executive Order: “C. Exceptions. This Executive Order does not require Face Coverings for-and a Face Covering does not need to be worn by a worker, customer, or patron who: ... 8. Is temporarily removing his or her Face Covering to secure government or medical services or for identification purposes.” https://files.nc.gov/governor/documents/files/EO147-Phase-2-Extension.pdf https://files.nc.gov/governor/documents/files/EO147-Phase-2-... While the article says “many jurisdictions,” and I cited only one specific jurisdiction, the onus is on the claimant to prove that there are, in fact jurisdictions that prohibit security exceptions. It’s unlikely that security exemptions don’t exist in every relevant executive order, yet the article requires accepting that premise in order to make the claim that this is “illegal.” As far as the conspiracy theory that collecting names and positive ID by TSA is somehow nefarious — this information is already available through passenger manifests from the airlines — airlines that themselves establish a positive ID for every passenger, requiring ID to board a flight. I am not sure what the controversy is. Every country in which I have ever boarded an airliner does an ID check and shares manifest data with authorities. If we are going to claim this is illegal, then a reasonable person would expect some proof of that, such as citing the actual statute relevant to the jurisdiction that is being violated. Is is interesting that many people opposed to this are supportive of government run health care — a situation that doesn’t only give government your name, but also access to your entire medical history. HIPAA (in the US,) has numerous government exceptions, including the nebulous “public health interest.” If we are worried about TSA positively identifying travelers, then certainly we should all be fearful of positively identifying people under the auspices of health care. https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/guidance/disclosures-public-health-activities/index.html https://www.hhs.gov/hipaa/for-professionals/privacy/guidance...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dheera 6y ago> and remove their face mask Having thousands of travellers unmask themselves at exactly the same physical spot within seconds of each other [and inevitably breathe in and out a couple times] sounds like a MASSIVE risk to me during COVID-19.
- diebeforei485 6y agoThis is way overkill for domestic travel.
- geuis 6y agoThat site is unreadable on mobile.
- mmm_grayons 6y agoUnpopular opinion: The TSA shouldn't exist, at all. Three thousand deaths doesn't justify curtailing the liberties of three hundred million. 9/11 was used to scare Americans into accepting massive violations of our liberties. As Rahm Immanuel said, "Never let a good crisis go to waste."
- neil_s 6y agoI detest the TSA, and government overreach, but I'm failing to see the issue here. Even before the optional photo system was introduced, they would stick my ID in a scanner, this seems like the same thing but the work is outsourced to me. Admittedly, I place less value on my privacy than the average HN commenter, given I opted in to Clear which lets me bypass lines using biometrics, a trade-off I was glad to make. Then, people have raised the unrelated issue of why ID checks are needed at all, and I can think of a couple, not sure of the actual reason: 1) Checking that you're not on the no-fly list. 2) Checking that there isn't a BOLO out on you, so that people with warrants, parole etc can't skip town easily. The argument that it is to prevent secondary markets for tickets sounds hollow - airlines do their own ID checks when printing the boarding pass and at the gate.
- aphistic 6y agoI'm not sure anyone will see this because this post is over a day old, but what can someone traveling really do about it? If you refuse they'll just refuse to let you board your plane. I usually (especially now during a pandemic) don't fly when there's no reason for me to, so refusing me access to my flight is a pretty good way to make me comply, illegal or not. About a month ago I had to be in court at a certain time and from past experience (filing and getting paperwork to the court) I knew they'd make you take off your belt if it had metal on it. That day I specifically wore a belt with no metal on it so I wouldn't have to take it off, but it didn't make any difference. The sign at security said "no metal objects" and then gave a list of example items with metal on them, belt included, and that was what the security agent pointed to when telling me I still needed to take my belt off. I objected, telling her my pants would fall down if I did and that the list was an EXAMPLE of metal objects, but the only response I got was that if I wanted to I could complain to someone at some other time. Another agent chimed in that they require you to take your belt off because "people could be hiding a knife in their belt", as if that made any sense at all. Isn't that what a metal detector is for in the first place? Anyway, I had no option but to take off my belt or I just wouldn't get to court on time. I let my pants fall down (I decided to do this earlier because I knew it was a possibility) and waddled through security with my pants around my ankles. So yeah, what could I have done in that case? Just miss my court date?