10 ms·
> he frequently receives PBA cards as a thank-you for extending cops small business favors and deals This is corruption. I've never understood how things like
by helsinkiandrew 6y ago
> he frequently receives PBA cards as a thank-you for extending cops small business favors and deals
This is corruption. I've never understood how things like this can happen in the US - why is this tolerated?
If this happened in the UK I'm fairly sure it would be raised in the press, then parliament and then the Home Secretary (in charge of policing) would be forced to make a statement and likely do something about it.
- MattGaiser 6y ago1.Plenty of Americans view enforcing traffic laws are nothing more than "a greedy gubbermint cash grab." For those participating, they view it as using corruption to avoid corruption. 2. You can't easily do something about it other than taking away police discretion. Unlike with a traditional bribe, where something is exchanged for something, you can't demonstrate that the person got off for the card compared to the officer just deciding to give them a break.
- bananaface 6y agoCan't you just ban the cards?
- pnutjam 6y agoMostly they are "secret". Edit: didn't read the article, but I still think they fly under the radar for the vast majority of people and they should absolutely be a career ender for Police to hand out. Sounds like low fruit for cleaning up America.
- cool_dude85 6y agoSure, we'll just have the police arrest the police officers who give them out.
- bananaface 6y agoSilly response. If the cards were illegal people would absolutely be hesitant to flash them to a random cop.
- darkarmani 6y agoIt's too late. You are better off sending millions of them out to people (inflation).
- randycupertino 6y agoBut, it's not just the cards. Sherrifs also hand out their business cards to their buddies and tell them to flash that if they get pulled over, or firefighters and EMTs show their public service license cards when they hand over their wallet to an officer to get out of tickets. Same thing with the 11-99 license plate holders- donate to the police retirement union to get out of tickets! http://zo-d.com/stuff/automotive/1199-foundation-license-plate-frame-culture-of-corruption.html http://zo-d.com/stuff/automotive/1199-foundation-license-pla... If the "cards" are banned, their still would be a system for insiders to show they have access to special benefits and treatment.
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoA different/related point - aren't (always on) body cameras taking away police discretion anyway?
- MattGaiser 6y agoI would have thought that they mostly take away the "rough em up" type of discretion. The public is fine with police giving warnings over fines in many cases. They are just upset when it is warning over fine along with the association card.
- nip180 6y agoNo. In many situations the officer has discretion to ignore an infraction, write a warning, or give a ticket. Many aspects of interactions between people and police officers are up to an officer’s discretion.
- heavyset_go 6y agoCops can turn them on and off, and no.
- raisedbyninjas 6y agoPlenty of Americans that don't run in these corruption circles view traffic laws and other intermittently enforced laws as a tool to hassle "undesirables".
- pnutjam 6y agoI've always said traffic laws mostly encourage a disregard for the law. I think they should set things like speed limits high enough that there is no reason to break them. They are LIMITS, not normal speed. Maybe post a recommended speed too. If someone breaks the speed limit it should be 30 day license suspension and impounding their vehicle.
- SketchySeaBeast 6y ago> I think they should set things like speed limits high enough that there is no reason to break them. I mean... that's not why the limit is there. The limit isn't "how fast can you possibly go without feeling out of control", it's "how fast can you possibly safely go". Are they still operating with 20th century cars in mind? Yeah, but it's hard to argue that a school zone should be 60 MPH.
- nitrogen 6y agoYeah, but it's hard to argue that a school zone should be 60 MPH. Most people who complain about speed limits are complaining about freeways, not surface streets.
- toast0 6y agoYou clearly don't live in a community that likes putting 25 mph signs all over the place.
- pnutjam 6y agoWe already have pretty draconian enforcement in school zones. And I am arguing for how safe can you safely go, it's just way too low.
- SketchySeaBeast 6y agoI've heard that it's not the absolute velocity on a freeway that's the issue, but instead the relative velocity of all drivers. A speed limit that all can comfortably hit keeps that to within a much more narrow band than a speed limit that some wouldn't be able to comfortably hit.
- krapp 6y ago>I've never understood how things like this can happen in the US - why is this tolerated? Police unions and a strong pro-police "thin blue line" culture.
- jopsen 6y agoWe have unions in other countries too, they don't endorse or organize corruption/nepotism/bribery, or the appearance of such.
- emteycz 6y agoMost European countries have a general police inspection and the unions are not as strong, and there are no 'federal employee' protections like the USA does.
- Anon1096 6y agoMost police aren't federal employees and thus have no "Federal employee protection".
- emteycz 6y agoGood catch. what's the situation of ordinary policeman?
- vkou 6y agoIf you have tenure, and you don't cross the thin blue line, you are untouchable. Your local police union can absolutely ruin a local politician's career[1], and in general, make life hell for your city, so most of the politicians don't try to rock the boat. When they do, they discover that the police, despite being employees of the city will just refuse to do what they are told. Sheriffs magically turn into constitutional scholars, and start unilaterally choosing what laws to enforce[2], start blatantly violating the city's bylaws, and instructions from the mayor[3], and when pushed in the only way they can be hurt (The budget), engage in malicious compliance. Picking a fight with the police union is generally speaking, not a politically savvy move. [1] Mostly by doing a deliberately poor job in the district they represent, and being incredibly vocal that the reason they are doing a poor job, is because the politician is causing them problems. [2] A number of sheriffs across the country made it clear that they won't issue Covid mask/gathering citations, despite state and local law, because the law is an obvious violation of... Some constitutional amendment that they can't name. [3] After weeks of violence, Seattle city council banned the use of crowd control weapons. The SPD celebrated the very next day by gassing and blast-balling crowds.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- netsharc 6y agoOh well, BoJo gave out a contract to a girl who he probably was fucking, and the inquiry concluded "No harm done": https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2020/may/21/boris-johnson-will-not-face-criminal-inquiry-over-jennifer-arcuri https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2020/may/21/boris-johns... This article https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/01/19/corruption-revolt https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2015/01/19/corruption-rev... is a review of the book about corruption "Thieves of State". It's an interesting analysis of corruption in several different countries, and I suppose if you're going to suffer because of it, might as well understand it.
- bediger4000 6y ago> This is corruption. I've never understood how things like this can happen in the US - why is this tolerated? Because "police" in the USA can mean a lot of things, from county Sheriff, to city police to state police to FBI or one of the other 2 dozen armed federal agencies. It's a patchwork. There's no central authority to enforce some kind of standard of behavior.
- WorldMaker 6y agoYet there is a central authority involved in this problem: the Fraternal Order of Police. It is that Fraternity that accepted, and made common, these "courtesy cards" as a way of business. The corruptive rot clearly has centralizing forces. The FOP and the police unions have the ability to combat them centrally and presumably enforce a higher standard of behavior, if they wanted to, just as they had a hand in creating the corruptions in the first place. If they wanted to fight it (they probably don't).
- bediger4000 6y agoExcellent point. I should have written "central authority that's accountable to the citizens and other branches of government".
- aaomidi 6y agoKeep in mind this happens most other places in the world too. The police force is generally a corrupt force. It's just not as obvious and not spoken about as much. Also keep in mind police force generally targets minorities more. So if your country doesn't have an obvious minority population that has systemically been kept behind, you're not going to see as much police corruption. But it's there. As a brown person, my worst experiences with cops was in UK and Germany. When I tell people this they're quick to dismiss it by "This shit doesn't happen here"
- acituan 6y ago> So if your country doesn't have an obvious minority population that has systemically been kept behind, you're not going to see as much police corruption. I don't buy this. There are plenty of ethnically homogeneous countries that also has rampant police corruption (e.g. in Eastern Europe), and there are tons of other parameters that affect police corruption overall. We can't single out presence of minorities as a factor.
- mcguire 6y agoI believe the key word there is "see". Without obvious targets, from the outside all you see is everyday activities, even if that includes bribes and preferences, because that is how it's always treated from the inside. On the other hand, you can always find a disliked minority somewhere. https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/sites/default/files/is-england-fairer-2016-most-disadvantaged-groups-gypsies-travellers-roma.pdf https://www.equalityhumanrights.com/sites/default/files/is-e...
- samatman 6y agohmm, when I hear "Eastern Europe", I don't think "ethnically homogeneous", I think "substantial Roma minority". I'm quite confident the police don't treat them particularly well, either.
- gostsamo 6y agoYou have no idea. Brown lives does not matter in Eastern Europe. Only thing that saves their lives is that gun ownership is not popular and cops cannot claim that they felt threatened. Beatings though...
- majormajor 6y agoThe US takes localism to extremes in order to preserve historic fiefdoms and injustices. The stated desire is to prevent government abuse of powers by keeping the governments small and limiting the powers of the larger ones, but if you look at actions rather than words, it's less about restricting government and more about preserving existing power structures. Reconstruction is one of the most egregious examples.
- rjkennedy98 6y agoYeah because our federal government is some grand example of honesty and good governance.
- eropple 6y agoBy comparison: yes, for the most part, the federal government is such an example. It's by no means perfect but, yeah, for the most part it works pretty well and relatively honestly. Always room for improvement--but the critical difference is that, when it is not, there are ways to expose the need for improvement and to push change that will not, full stop, ever even start at local and even state levels. And even were it not: the unquestioned (and, tbh, often profoundly racist when not merely corrupt) localized governmental structures in question are still wrong, so attempting to sandbag criticism of them by pointing at the federal government, regardless of its status, smells a mite bit fishy.
- mulmen 6y agoThe federal government may do its current job well but that doesn't imply it can do a better job at local governance than... local government. I'm thankful that no Kentucky voters are able to make decisions about my city, for example. There are real benefits to small local government. Yes, there are also problems but that doesn't mean the system is wrong fundamentally. This sword cuts both ways.
- bsanr2 6y agoAgain, this is a canard. Local government in some areas have been shown to make bad decisions that trample on explicit and enumerated rights (rather than the arbitrary or vague "rights" that are conjured to impede reform). Speaking broadly, and particularly of the late 20th century, when the federal government has stepped in to unilaterally overrule state and local government, it has been on the right side of history. There are, of course, a number of infamous exceptions, but the fact that I would likely be unable to converse with you w/o the federal gov't's historic interventions speaks loudly to their efficacy in suh matters.
- pravus 6y agoThe people involved are getting a huge benefit and there is no reason to report it. Others who don't receive the benefit either don't know about it or are shouted down. There is a culture in the US that the police are pristine warriors of justice and any accusations of wrong-doing are denied and ignored. There are also many laws that specifically protect LEO and government officials in general because there is a natural ethos that everyone working for The Good is always Good and whatever Bad they did must have been in the duty and service to The Good. Immunity is easy to achieve when the entire legal system wants you to be immune as a class and we are currently having a debate about qualified immunity regarding police in the US. In my view it is the entire system that is corrupt. A fish rots from its head as they say.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI think the bigger problem is that the general population does not want the law enforced. There is also a sentiment that there are so many laws on the books that there is nothing wrong with breaking them or LEO letting people off the hook. If the average person is good and still commits "3 felonies a day", then it is easy to believe that LEO is giving people a reprieve from systemic injustice, opposed to carrying out injustice. Nobody shames an individual who get out of a speeding ticket with a warning, when the individual was randomly selected from 10,000 other speeders the same road that day.
- teknopaul 6y agoI agree with your sentiment, but clearly "the bigger problem" is that the system is corrupt.
- _jal 6y agoYou don't get one without the other. The collection of all laws is such that even, consistent application would be untenable. That which cannot work, doesn't; instead, enforcement becomes selective. At that point, you're doomed; your system only works by being a system "...of people, not laws".
- 6y ago
- riffic 6y ago> why is this tolerated? Cynically, the answer is "what are you going to do about it, punk?"
- Spivak 6y agoOptimistically, this kind of "friendly-corruption" benefits everyone who participates.
- Sebb767 6y agoIsn't this true for unfriendly corruption as well?
- jfk13 6y agoAt the expense of everyone else.
- Spivak 6y agoOnly as long as you believe that mutually beneficial transactions don’t exist and networking is worthless.
- jolmg 6y agoIs there any other kind of corruption? Of course participants of corruption benefit, otherwise they wouldn't participate.
- gpm 6y agoYes, corruption where you are denied something that you are entitled to unless you pay a bribe. You are no better off than how you should be at the end and are out some money.
- tunesmith 6y ago- who is allowed to participate.
- rsynnott 6y ago> then the Home Secretary (in charge of policing) would be forced to make a statement and likely do something about it. I mean, I would think they'd be forced to resign, in practice.
- mcguire 6y agoThe state of policing in the UK took a considerable amount of work. https://theconversation.com/northern-irelands-police-transformation-may-hold-lessons-for-the-us-141259 https://theconversation.com/northern-irelands-police-transfo...
- DoofusOfDeath 6y ago> This is corruption. I've never understood how things like this can happen in the US - why is this tolerated? I think it shows that a sizable portion of the citizenry considers this acceptable. I.e., they're enamored with the idea of getting preferential treatment for themselves or their friends, with little regard for the implications. It makes me figuratively (and a bit literally) want to vomit.
- kbenson 6y ago> I think it shows that a sizable portion of the citizenry considers this acceptable. That only makes sense if you assume a sizable portion of the citizenry knows about it. I think people assume that cops are imperfect and let people off if they know them, or feel like it (the average hetero male cop probably lets disproportionately more pretty girls off with a warning), but that as a judgement call it's hard to alter (and there are good reasons to allow judgement calls). That it's often formalized and systematized into cards that are given out is another thing entirely, and I think you need to prove the average person knows it's happening before you can use it as evidence as to how average people feel.
- baron_harkonnen 6y ago> That only makes sense if you assume a sizable portion of the citizenry knows about it. Are you kidding? At least growing up in the 90s every teenager knew about PBA cards and any kid with cops in their family would eagerly whip out their collection of PBA cards for bragging rights. There were even different levels of cards, associated with different levels of officer you had connections too. I was honestly surprise to see this as 'news' since at least where I grew up this was widely known.
- kbenson 6y ago> Are you kidding? At least growing up in the 90s every teenager knew about PBA cards and any kid with cops in their family would eagerly whip out their collection of PBA cards for bragging rights. Have you considered that it might be affected by locale, and be more prevalent in some areas than others? I grew up in the 80's and 90's, and I never heard of this and have never seen a card. What makes you think your experiences with this when you were a teenager scale to everyone in the United States?
- mjw1007 6y agoWell, the Home Secretary would probably be forced to announce an inquiry, which might report over a decade later, long after said Home Secretary's political career was over. Consider for example https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Undercover_Policing_Inquiry https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Undercover_Policing_Inquiry « In 2012 Theresa May had commissioned Mark Ellison QC to review allegations of corruption » « The Undercover Policing Inquiry or Pitchford Inquiry … is due to report back in 2023 »
- helsinkiandrew 6y agoNonsense. That’s investigating thousands of investigations that took place over 40 years, with many questions and issues. Whether ‘get out of jail free’ cards are acceptable is a yes/no question.
- wolco 6y agoYet no one says anything about turning London into a police state. Are the press still on top of this story?
- Symbiote 6y agoI think you need to be clearer on what you mean by "police state" before anyone can answer that. https://www.theguardian.com/uk/police https://www.theguardian.com/uk/police
- s1artibartfast 6y agoIt happens because the general public, as well as LEO, don't believe that many of the laws on the book should be enforced. As far as I am aware, nobody thinks LEO is letting murders go as a favor. For example, 90% of Americans ignore posted speed limits, as do LEO. When someone gets a speeding ticket, it seems bad luck and unfair. This makes it seem more acceptable for LEO to let someone off the hook.
- notJim 6y agoIn the US, the police are essentially an occupying force with their own agenda that they pursue. At times it aligns with the agenda of broader society, but at times not. Because the police know not to mess with the "wrong" people, and because they're generally very well regarded by society, the police unions have considerable power, such that elected officials are often terrified to reign them in. A good example of this is NYC where hundreds of cops turned their backs on the mayor and basically accused him of stoking violence against the police after he was mildly critical of them. This was a huge news story[1], and the mayor has refrained from criticism since then. 1: https://time.com/3644168/new-york-police-de-blasio-wenjian-liu-rafael-ramos/ https://time.com/3644168/new-york-police-de-blasio-wenjian-l...
- ALittleLight 6y agoI think it's corruption too, but I have to roll my eyes at "If this happened in the UK..." The police, and city councils, in the UK have tacitly permitted, for decades, systematic child rape as seen in the Rotterham grooming scandal [1] and numerous others throughout the country. How can you suggest that cops wouldn't look the other way for minor infractions when there are countless examples of them ignoring obscene and severe crimes of the worst sort against the most vulnerable? I don't want this to come off as a "my country is better than yours" but at the same time, I don't think using the UK police as an example of anything to aspire to is a good idea. 1 -https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotherham_child_sexual_exploitation_scandal https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Rotherham_child_sexual_explo...
- crispyporkbites 6y agoThat’s absolute bollocks. The uk police has oversight from the IOPC and you can read all about the ongoing conduct investigation for that cherry picked example here https://policeconduct.gov.uk/news/independent-investigation-under-way-relating-gmp%E2%80%99s-operation-augusta https://policeconduct.gov.uk/news/independent-investigation-...
- ALittleLight 6y agoCherry picked? The "see also" section lists another 6 "grooming gang" scandals across the country and I have no reason to think that's comprehensive. UK police permitting the organized rape of children seems the norm rather than the exception from what I can tell. The fact that there is an investigation decades after the fact doesn't really negate what I've written. My point isn't really about the grooming gang scandals though. My point is: UK police look the other way for the crime of child rape, why should I believe they don't look the other way for minor infractions?
- jeffbee 6y agoHow can a city that small be that fucked up?
- Thorentis 6y ago> "The failure to address the abuse was attributed to ... fear that the perpetrators' ethnicity would trigger allegations of racism and damage community relations" Defund the police for being too worried about racism to do their job. Wait ... what?
- freeopinion 6y agoYour outrage reminds me of the "bribery scandal" of the 2002 Winter Olympics. Somebody "exposed" an extensive system of bribes made to officials who would vote on the host city for the Olympics. Every night more allegations of the scandal were reported with proper shock and outrage. It was a bit of a head scratcher for me. I remember, for example, when it was uncovered that one official had been gifted a very expensive custom-made shotgun. The news anchor was very solemn in reporting this outrageous misdeed. Rewind 9 or 11 months earlier and the exact same anchor was cheerfully reporting a public ceremony in which a visiting Olympic dignitary was presented with a gift from the organizing committee formed to win the bid. It was a happy day filled with optimism and hope for what might soon be. Lots of flash bulbs. That publicly-presented token of good will was the custom-made shotgun.
- secabeen 6y agoThe issue there is that the custom-made shotgun should be considered a gift to the Olympic organization as an organization, not to the official personally. The official could even display the shotgun in their office. Then, when they left that office, the shotgun stays behind, and doesn't become part of their personal collection.
- freeopinion 6y agoMy point was that we all observe blatant corruption all the time. Very often, we don't even think about it until somebody calls it out. Here's another example: When was the last time you saw a big shiny 4-door 4x4 with a company placard hauling a boat on a weekend? The company placard is for a construction company or something that is unrelated to towing boats on non-business days. Does it even register with you that this is probably committing some kind of tax or business impropriety? The truck is written off as a business expense, but its main purpose is personal. Do you even care? Does anybody care? Probably not too many who pass the boat doing 10 miles over the speed limit. Probably not the LEO who passes the people passing the boat. Probably not the guy at the marina who notices that the registration on the boat is expired, but sells beer to the 20ish-year-old kid driving the truck without ID.
- gnopgnip 6y ago"It is better that ten guilty persons escape than that one innocent suffer" Letting some people get away with speeding and other minor crimes isn't seen as an corruption, or something that needs to be stopped. It is also still up to the police to make the decision either way, they can still give you a ticket, flashing a PBA card could make some situations worse.
- Ichthypresbyter 6y agoThe closest thing to it in the UK is that traffic police would put "Black Rat" stickers on their personal cars. Of course, it didn't take very long for members of the public to find out what the stickers meant and for people who had nothing to do with the police to start making and selling them- by all accounts they don't really work any more, and haven't for years.
- lipstone 6y agoThe level of police corruption is much, much higher in many other countries. Why are you singling the US out?