3 ms·
If you never use production data for anything other than production this stops being a problem. You can put all the dev and staging JWTs you want in to jwt.io a
by onion2k 6y ago
If you never use production data for anything other than production this stops being a problem. You can put all the dev and staging JWTs you want in to jwt.io at no risk if those things aren't available to the outside world.
- wardnath 6y agoAgreed. This pretty much applies with any data & tool. If the data is extra sensitive, make extra sure the tool you are using is secure. If your data is for dev purposes only, the tool doesn't have to be validated as thoroughly.
- thinkloop 6y agoHe addresses this. He mentions leaking implementation details, and possibility for mistakes.
- beardedwizard 6y agoWow really? Lateral movement is very real, your mindset is dangerous.
- wardnath 6y agoThat is a good point to make. If the development data can lead to exfiltration of higher privacy data then I would define it as "more sensitive" and take that into consideration, this particularly applies to config information required for authentication. I understand your perspective however, it is important to take lateral movement into account.
- notimetorelax 6y agoSome attacks exploit vulnerabilities in dev infrastructure. Exposed dev JWT token may enable such an attack.
- onion2k 6y agoThis is precisely why my comment makes it clear that dev shouldn't be available to the outside world.
- woogley 6y agoSecurity in layers. You should keep your dev environment private but also not paste credentials into a networked textbox.
- beardedwizard 6y agoThis, I can't believe we are even debating it...
- dathinab 6y ago"making things not available to the outside world" Has been proven repeatedly to not reliable work. And security model must assume a attacker somehow got access to the VPN it whatever you use for isolation. If not it's not a reliable security model.
- dathinab 6y agoExcept, habits some catastrophic failure coming together. The later one makes you need to access production data even through you don't want to the former one makes you leak it in the hurry to fix that catastrophic failure. To just name one example.