3 ms·
I read your post a couple times and I think I get where you are coming from. I think the disconnect between us comes from the different assumptions and emphasi
by s1artibartfast 6y ago
I read your post a couple times and I think I get where you are coming from.
I think the disconnect between us comes from the different assumptions and emphasis we made filled in for each post. You assumed that Ticmasta ignored indirect costs in a cost/benifit analysis. Camgunz addressed this as you point out. And I assumed that tomasita's central point was that additional spending does not reduce crime or recidivism, and camgunz sidesteped the issue. I imagine Natsu's reading would be the same, given that they restated the same ting, but with more inflammatory language.
I tend to agree with you and camgunz that decriminalization of many activities is attractive based on it's own merits. That said, I think that it is also important to acknowledge that not all problems can be solved by dumb money, solved by smart money, or solved at all.
- godelski 6y agoThe problem comes down to a few parts. 1) The language is similar to that used by dog whistlers. 2) We have higher expectations from people on HN and expect them to be more familiar with subjects they are responding to. 3) We require good faith arguments here [0] 4) that aren't lazy 5) and can't be disproven with a simple search. ( 6) (which wasn't violated in this case) we expect people to read the article). HN has always had higher standards and expectations than other forums. I'm happy to get conversations back on track, because it is a problem we're facing a lot in society (in general), but now the conversation is derailed. [0] There's three parts to communication. 1) The idea intended to be conveyed. 2) The words said. 3) The idea that was heard. The three things can convey three different ideas. A good faith argument means that you are trying to understand what was intended. It usually means giving the benefit of the doubt.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI agree with everything you said about communication and still stand by my original point and suggestion. Camgunz would have a more productive conversation if they added more context to their post, describing how it relates to the parent. I agree that the other posts could be improved as well. I don’t think that there was any dog whistling. As I understand the the term, it Requires a hidden meaning, and rape is simply inflammatory and hyperbolic. The exception is if you think that the poster was intentionally using “rapists" as code for blacks and Hispanics. If so, I didn’t pick up on the intentional racist angle.
- camgunz 6y agoOh yeah, totally agree about the money thing. It’s also important to have plans that can survive beyond one government. The Finnish school system is a great example of a relatively radical reform that took more than a generation to bear fruit. There’s a lot involved for sure.