3 ms·
It is a strawman because the response made suppositions that the gp did not imply. That is not a good faith argument. Forcing positions upon people is not a pro
by godelski 6y ago
It is a strawman because the response made suppositions that the gp did not imply. That is not a good faith argument. Forcing positions upon people is not a productive means of discussion.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI felt that the post was just interjecting with a fact and did not explain how it relates to or modifies the parent post. It is hard to respond without supposition if they fail to put forth an argument. I read the interchange as follows. >mabbo: states that we should focus on crime reduction, not enforcement >ticmasta: questions if crime prevention is economically or practically viable. They propose that increased expenses have not and will not result in a reduction of "serious crimes". > Camgunz: points out that incarceration is expensive and this could support a lot of social services. > Natsu: questions again how social programs will stop violent crimes like rape when existing programs have failed. > Camgunz: Dont strawman me, Nonviolent incarceration is expensive. Camgunz seems to be talking past the question of if social programs can work and reiterating that incarceration is expensive.
- godelski 6y agoI think the crux comes down to this section of the exchange. > Camgunz: points out that incarceration is expensive and this could support a lot of social services. > Natsu: questions again how social programs will stop violent crimes like rape when existing programs have failed. How __I__ read this (and I'm guessing Camgunz) is that camgunz provides context to ticmasta's questions about being economically viability by noting how much we spend within the prison system. Implying that this is the metric that we are working with. There was an assumption made here, which is extremely common, that policy just adds cost and does not reduce it somewhere else. What Camgunz is suggesting is that by spending money elsewhere we can reduce the costs mentioned. IMO a net even would be a gain in the sense that we are being more humane and maximizing individual freedom (considering being in jail means pretty low individual freedom as well as potential long term consequences like being unable to vote in the future). Natsu then made a non-sequitor argument that is commonly associated with dog whistling (it may not have been intended this way, but that is part of the power of dog whistling. By definition it is coded language). The supposition that Natsu implied was that rapists are going to rape and this cannot be prevented, therefore we should just contain them. The data does not support this nor is it effective because we can only prosecute those who have already committed an action or are in the act (this isn't Minority Report, we don't do pre-crime and I think we'd all agree that is highly immoral). Further Natsu said that prisons already do not solve the problem, therefore we should just contain them. The context of the discussion was about reform, which acknowledges the fact that prisons do not accomplish this. Starting with mabbo we get a claim that we should be focusing on crime prevention, which would include (presumably) changing how prisons work. With a focus on reformation as opposed to punishment. Additionally, Natsu's statement is associated with an "all or nothing" approach, which is not what anyone here is suggesting and is a common technique used to derail a conversation, because there will always be outliers in data (i.e. letting perfection get in the way of improvements). Simply, the discussion is about reduction not abolition. Lastly, the jump to rape is one to extreme cases. A drive to an emotional appeal above everything else. Simply, the response was not in good faith and had a high potential to be intended to derail the conversation. It exhibits many of the tactics that people use to perform such a task (again, it resembles dog whistling enough that it is reasonable to be taken that way). I will also direct you to my response to Natsu where I link evidence of a negative cost policy (legalizing and taxing prostitution) that fulfills said objectives. I also stress the focus on reduction over abolition. There are many other policies similar to what I mentioned, including reform around marijuana laws (referencing back to Camgunz, which would you rather have? Spending 80k/yr for a non-violent pot dealer (max punishment is several years) or taxing pot, regulating to increase safety, de-stigmatizing and allowing people to seek professional help if it is negatively impacting their lives, and reducing funds that go to cartels that also contribute to migrants fleeing their countries and heading to America? The former costs a significant amount of money while the latter distributes money through the economy and allows taxes to be taken off the top). Not all policies will end up working like this, but again, this isn't an "all or nothing" situation, it is about improvement through iteration and utilizing the data that we have to make better policy. These two are low hanging fruit but do illustrate the point being discussed here.
- camgunz 6y agoNice, thank you! Yeah that was my point, an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure, etc. I felt like the rape hypothetical was too hyperbolic to be good faith. You did a way better job with this than I did, thanks again.
- s1artibartfast 6y agoI read your post a couple times and I think I get where you are coming from. I think the disconnect between us comes from the different assumptions and emphasis we made filled in for each post. You assumed that Ticmasta ignored indirect costs in a cost/benifit analysis. Camgunz addressed this as you point out. And I assumed that tomasita's central point was that additional spending does not reduce crime or recidivism, and camgunz sidesteped the issue. I imagine Natsu's reading would be the same, given that they restated the same ting, but with more inflammatory language. I tend to agree with you and camgunz that decriminalization of many activities is attractive based on it's own merits. That said, I think that it is also important to acknowledge that not all problems can be solved by dumb money, solved by smart money, or solved at all.
- godelski 6y agoThe problem comes down to a few parts. 1) The language is similar to that used by dog whistlers. 2) We have higher expectations from people on HN and expect them to be more familiar with subjects they are responding to. 3) We require good faith arguments here [0] 4) that aren't lazy 5) and can't be disproven with a simple search. ( 6) (which wasn't violated in this case) we expect people to read the article). HN has always had higher standards and expectations than other forums. I'm happy to get conversations back on track, because it is a problem we're facing a lot in society (in general), but now the conversation is derailed. [0] There's three parts to communication. 1) The idea intended to be conveyed. 2) The words said. 3) The idea that was heard. The three things can convey three different ideas. A good faith argument means that you are trying to understand what was intended. It usually means giving the benefit of the doubt.
- s1artibartfast 6y ago
- camgunz 6y agoNah it’s well proven that social programs work. I was pointing out that most people in prison aren’t violent offenders, let alone rapists, and that we shouldn’t let those kinds of arguments sway us. It’s worth saying that people don’t stop being rapists or raping people once incarcerated; further there are hundreds of thousands of rapes each year in the US. If incarceration is supposed to stop rape, it’s not working.