3 ms·
> But is paid attention worth it Well, good old prostitution has been pretty successful since the dawn of mankind, so the answer must be "yes" for a lot of peo
by the_af 6y ago
> But is paid attention worth it
Well, good old prostitution has been pretty successful since the dawn of mankind, so the answer must be "yes" for a lot of people.
- bsder 6y ago> Well, good old prostitution has been pretty successful since the dawn of mankind, so the answer must be "yes" for a lot of people. To be fair, much like drug dealing, it's not clear how "successful" prostitution is. Much like anything else, there is a power law distribution in effect. A few make a lot of money, but a lot make very little. Of the women I have known on that path, I know of only two who actually didn't wind up in a bad place at the end. Drug addiction was the primary problem--if you work in the sex industry you work with a LOT of scumbags who want to hook you on drugs in order to control you.
- the_af 6y agoYou're replying from the point of view of the providers (the prostitutes), but the question I answered was about whether paid attention "was worth it" from the point of view of the clients. It obviously is, otherwise prostitution wouldn't have been so widespread for so long.
- bsder 6y ago> It obviously is, otherwise prostitution wouldn't have been so widespread for so long. Maybe, but "It's worth it" encompasses from "I have lots of choice and can afford it." (Heidi Fleiss clients) to "I have no other means of access so it's this or nothing." (the slum streetcorner)
- chii 6y agoIf you change the topic from prostitution to food, does it make any difference? You could pay for michelin star quality food, or eat chickpeas. Both will sustain you just fine, but which is "worth it"?
- lostgame 6y agoSmart drug dealers, like smart prostitues, generally make a ton of money in a short time, 4-5 years, and get the hell out while they can and invest in something. I know a handful of people who have been hugely successful at doing both.
- bsder 6y agoExactly. A handful. And everybody else gets pulled into a terrible world. This is similar to high school sports in terms of percentages (but probably not quite such a terrible adverse outcome). A handful do well. The rest would have a MUCH better life spending that energy on education/trade/anything else instead.
- lostgame 6y agoWow, that's such a valid point. The number of kids who go into sports is ridiculous, and it's just...it's not a career. Just like drug dealing isn't a career. tbh the average NFL player's career isn't going to last too much longer than the average smart drug dealer or prostitute.
- lmm 6y agoThat logic would say that drugs, junk food, etc. are worth it. Plenty of people spend money on things that bring them no joy in the long term because they feel like they need them in the moment.
- afiori 6y agobeing "worth it" from a market and profitability perspective is quite different from being "worth it" in a long term life planning perspective.
- the_af 6y agoIt's very difficult to objectively evaluate whether something is universally "worth it" or "hollow" (I'm using terms from the original comment). You have to place yourself as the ultimate judge of "long term" worth, which is a doomed proposition. You're entering the realm of philosophy (or religion, of course). Why is long term always better than short term? Aren't there people who enjoy junk food, and in fact love it? Is going to the movies a wasteful act, since most movies don't give you long term enjoyment? Is playing videogames? Is having sex with a person you don't intend to marry something that will "leave you hollow"? Is casual sex worthless, or is it only a problem if you pay for it?
- lmm 6y agoI'm not taking a position on the broader question, but the blithe "it must be worth it because people pay for it" is simplistic to the point of being wrong.
- the_af 6y agoBut your counterpoints (drugs & junk food) are trivially disproven: for a lot of people, those are truly "worth it". Why, I still remember an argument I had here on HN, years ago, where I said real homemade burgers were way better than McDonald's, and had more than one people reply to me with "nah, sometimes I really want a McDonald's burger, I really enjoy them". As for prostitution, you have to admit such a long tradition of existing -- the "oldest profession", as the saying goes -- is strong evidence that it's indeed worth it to a lot of people. I'm not making a moral argument, by the way. Only your own personal convictions, or your religion's, can tell you that.