11 ms·
Is it primarily a biological or cultural phenomenon that most creators of this content are women and most consumers of the content are men? Honestly, I don't kn
by renewiltord 6y ago
Is it primarily a biological or cultural phenomenon that most creators of this content are women and most consumers of the content are men? Honestly, I don't know if that's true, but from what little this intersects with my news feed it appears to be true.
- kvgr 6y agoMost woman can get attention at some appropriate level. Even if not coolest, prettiest, smartest. A lot of man can't. And the way to get together to be attractive is sometimes hard. Better to pay for only fans than to shoot up some place...
- actuator 6y agoBut is paid attention worth it, wouldn't it end up making you feel hollow once that interaction is over and you realize how made up the whole thing was.
- chongli 6y agoIf you can get paid attention then you can get free attention. I would imagine a lot of these female performers are already in relationships. They just work very hard to conceal their relationships online in order to preserve the illusion for their fans.
- actuator 6y agoI was talking about the males who are paying, not the female performers. They definitely should be able to get attention, and for them from an economic opportunity perspective this makes complete sense.
- chongli 6y agoOh in that case I don't think they realize how hollow it is, at least not at first. The top performers (on Twitch, anyway, I have never visited OnlyFans) work very hard to keep their top donors happy. They thank them profusely, grant them moderator status, single out their chat messages to read and respond to on stream, and likely even chat with them in private messages after the stream. Anything to maintain the illusion that this is a real relationship rather than a transactional one. This is why OnlyFans was created in the first place: a site outside of the rules of Twitch terms of service that lets performers take things "to the next level" with their top donors. It's like the VIP room in a strip club. Edit to add more thoughts: I think strip clubs are the right analogy for how to evaluate these channels (the "just chatting" ones and any of the gaming ones that prominently feature very attractive performers). They are fundamentally about creating and maintaining an illusion with the (usually male viewers). Unfortunately, this can be very dangerous. It's pretty common knowledge that strippers are much more likely to suffer violence than the average woman. They may be safer than street-walking prostitutes, but nowhere near as safe as a woman in a white-collar job. How safe are these streamers in the long run? The distance and pseudonymity provided by the internet may afford a level of safety, compared to the closeness of a strip club. On the other hand, streamers can have several orders of magnitude more viewers than even the largest of strip clubs. A large viewer count can magnify the risk that one disillusioned fan decides to "go rogue" and stalk the streamer, dox her, and attack her in person. I would not be surprised if we see a case of serious violence (or murder) against a top streamer within a few years.
- chillwaves 6y agoRealistically, the streamers are safe. You can't really compare it to a girl working in meat space, who is potentially being threatened by not just her clients, but also the management of the club, potentially her own pimp, other pimps and maybe other girls in the business as well. Streamers getting doxxed is not really a thing, and they have viewers from around the world. Anyhow, I think your concern is not warranted, otherwise we would already be hearing more about these kind of incidents. I have heard of a few incidents like this happening to Kpop groups, but there you have 1) mega audience 2) crazy fans 3) physical interaction (concerts) so streamers at least at an advantage re: 3.
- lostgame 6y ago>> Streamers getting doxxed is not really a thing ...what?! I mean, really? I have friends who have had this issue, I am baffled by this perspective. It's always been an issue, it will always be. What?
- Nextgrid 6y ago> I have heard of a few incidents [...] but there you have [...] crazy fans Is there no "crazy fans" in the OnlyFans/Twitch community? I'd argue that the probability of crazy/mentally unstable fans would be a lot higher in this weird "parasocial relationship" environment compared to a typical music band fanbase.
- the_af 6y ago> But is paid attention worth it Well, good old prostitution has been pretty successful since the dawn of mankind, so the answer must be "yes" for a lot of people.
- bsder 6y ago> Well, good old prostitution has been pretty successful since the dawn of mankind, so the answer must be "yes" for a lot of people. To be fair, much like drug dealing, it's not clear how "successful" prostitution is. Much like anything else, there is a power law distribution in effect. A few make a lot of money, but a lot make very little. Of the women I have known on that path, I know of only two who actually didn't wind up in a bad place at the end. Drug addiction was the primary problem--if you work in the sex industry you work with a LOT of scumbags who want to hook you on drugs in order to control you.
- the_af 6y agoYou're replying from the point of view of the providers (the prostitutes), but the question I answered was about whether paid attention "was worth it" from the point of view of the clients. It obviously is, otherwise prostitution wouldn't have been so widespread for so long.
- bsder 6y ago> It obviously is, otherwise prostitution wouldn't have been so widespread for so long. Maybe, but "It's worth it" encompasses from "I have lots of choice and can afford it." (Heidi Fleiss clients) to "I have no other means of access so it's this or nothing." (the slum streetcorner)
- chii 6y agoIf you change the topic from prostitution to food, does it make any difference? You could pay for michelin star quality food, or eat chickpeas. Both will sustain you just fine, but which is "worth it"?
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoWestern culture has generated a wide range of superficial behaviors and attitudes in half the population. This is just an expression of that.
- dragonwriter 6y ago> But is paid attention worth it, wouldn't it end up making you feel hollow once that interaction is over and you realize how made up the whole thing was. We pay for lots of (social/emotional) illusions in entertainment. People tend to suggest that this is a risk of the kind of illusions they don't indulge in, and you certainly can see examples of it with lots of those illusions, but I don't think it's exclusive to any of them. Though in the illusion of personal connection, it's probably more dangerous to the seller when the buyer gets lost and expects reality instead of illusion.
- cblconfederate 6y agoYou mean, like an actor or a singer?
- kennywinker 6y agoThere are many male creators on onlyfans, they're just largely catering to a gay audience.
- null0pointer 6y agoThat's true. It's more accurate to say the primary consumers are men, rather than that the primary producers are women.
- shard972 6y agoMost creators being women is also true.
- afiori 6y agoit is likely that the gender ratio in the creators (or market size) is linked to the sexual preferences of the (predominantly male) audience. I mean, I suspect that the gender imbalance in "willing to pay for lewdness and smiles" is greater than the imbalance for "willing to sell lewdness and smiles"
- symlinkk 6y agoThis is a good question and is something I’m wondering too. The same phenomenon is occurring on Tinder, where women will get hundreds of matches and men will get less than 10.
- b0rsuk 6y agoPeople associated with alt-right say this is because women have built-in hypergamy and only ever trade up partners. According to this line of thinking, a woman would rather share a top male and be a part of a harem than have an average man all for herself. I don't have enough experience or data to prove or disprove it.
- afiori 6y agosimilarly to you I don't know what to comment on that, but an interesting trivia is that (in terms of cis hetero preferences) the median woman is above average and the median man is below average. but as always we should be wary using too much deduction on soft science topics
- hackinthebochs 6y agoThe central limit theorem manifested in XX vs XY chromosomes.
- afiori 6y agoClarification: by "is above/below average" here I mean "is perceived as above/below average"
- globular-toast 6y agoIt's biological. The same patterns can be seen in other great apes. Huge inequality amongst males but equality amongst females.
- ecmascript 6y agoOf course it's biological. You see the same behavior across the globe, in all cultures and societies.
- Mossly 6y agoCulture echoing biology. Sexual reproduction evolves convergently from the fusion of similar gametes (isogamy) to those of dissimilar gametes (anisogamy). Sexual differentiation produces dimorphic sexual asymmetry, a binary mating system of two types. Males produce many small gametes, females produce few large gametes. Factored by the expensive cost of selection, copulation, gestation, and rearing, and females are naturally inclined to be more selective. In a sellers market where everyone wants to buy, humans mate assortatively. I highly recommend ‘The Evolution of Insect Mating Systems’ (1983) by Randy Thornhill and John Alcock. The diversity of insects provide excellent insight into the evolution of sexual reproduction.