5 ms·
Delaying Herd Immunity Is Costing Lives
- Rebelgecko 6y ago>Nursing homes should be isolated together with some of the staff until other staff who have acquired immunity can take over Just this one sentence has a lot to unpack. How do we know that a staff member immune to COVID? My understanding is that an antibody test is correlated but not necessarily indicative of immunity. What does this mean for staff members that aren't immune? Will they be furloughed indefinitely or fired? Should there be financial incentives to deliberately infect yourself?
- seppin 6y agoAlso there's substantial proof COVID19 antibodies don't last forever, in some cases only a few months. This article is riddled with questions.
- timr 6y agoNo. All recent data points to long-lasting immunity. A normal, gradual decline in antibody response is coupled with longer-lasting B- and T-cell response. https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1285618977654407169.html https://threadreaderapp.com/thread/1285618977654407169.html https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.07.14.20151126v1 https://www.medrxiv.org/content/10.1101/2020.07.14.20151126v...
- seppin 6y agoHow does that explain repeat illness (not via testing but someone that is in hospital once month and back the next?)
- timr 6y agoTo date, there has been one documented case of re-infection. From everything we know, this very rare. There are many reasons a person with a severe illness might have to return to a hospital (e.g. lung damage from ventilators), but this has no relationship to repeated infection from the same virus.
- seppin 6y agoMultiple (confirmed) cases, meaning there are many more that are missed. https://www.statnews.com/2020/08/28/covid-19-reinfection-implications/ https://www.statnews.com/2020/08/28/covid-19-reinfection-imp...
- arcticbull 6y ago> How do we know that a staff member immune to COVID? Antibody tests are already quite available and easy to get. In the longer term, you'd need to test for T-cell response.
- lkrubner 6y agoIn the USA, it is estimated that herd immunity would lead to 2.1 million deaths: 330,000,000 ÷ 100 x 65 = 214,500,000 ÷ 100 = 2,145,000 That's 330 million people, 65% exposed, and 1% death rate. Keep in mind that 9% of people have suffered a crippling illness that lasts several months. That's 19,305,000 people with a crippling multi-month illness. Aiming for herd immunity is pure madness.
- arcticbull 6y agoA few key things you're leaving out. 1. The mortality rate for children is lower than even the flu, and this is likely to do with age-related ACE2 expression. This is fact, and hopefully it leads to something that can help us lower the mortality rate in older folks, too. [1] They can of course spread it to older folks, though. 2. Mortality rate among the young is in line with the flu. 3. Mortality rate in older folks is terrible, and needs to be managed, but it can be managed. Those folks, and those with immune issues can and must be protected at all costs. These three things together mean the death rate of such a strategy is nowhere near 1%. > 330,000,000 ÷ 100 x 65 = 214,500,000 Serology studies pin the number closer to 0.6%, but of course that doesn't make the decision any less difficult -- although that is heavily, heavily age dependent. What you're neglecting otherwise is the thrust of the article: lockdowns are temporary and the disease won't be stopped by lockdowns. Even under the most optimistic projection for vaccination, we may be hurtling towards the 65% number in the US one way or the other. This article basically documents Sweden's approach. There hasn't been a COVID death in Sweden since August 24th, and at the moment, they continue to see ~150 new cases per day. [1] https://www.uth.edu/news/story.htm?id=b40ccaec-50c5-465c-b2d5-a911c0344614 https://www.uth.edu/news/story.htm?id=b40ccaec-50c5-465c-b2d...
- kjs3 6y agoMortality rate in older folks is terrible, and needs to be managed, but it can be managed. Yeah...I keep seeing this handwave from the "I should be able to do whatever I want" crowd. How exactly can it be managed? Basically it's "if you have any possible risk factor, you should lock yourself away so me and my friends aren't inconvenienced by your existence". Ignoring the fact (and the associated abdication of responsibility) that there's no established risk assessment beyond "if you're an oldster, stay home", and it's not clear why the many otherwise low risk are getting sick and dying. They are apparently the cost of partying on weekends.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- WildParser 6y agoThe author missed that the whole narrative around herd immunity is based on very very weak papers. The growth dynamics of COVID-19 is following very precise mathematics. Like any seasonal virus it starts strong - and trickles down slowly. Not doing containment while it is growing will make the situation a lot worse. Spreading the virus deliberately to get some immunity will make the situation worse. Using non-functional lockdowns that only slow down the descend and spread the virus more evenly also make things worse.
- legerdemain 6y agoThis is the same load of horsefeathers that is on display in every popular narrative arguing for herd immunity. The author writes: "We need to shield older people and other high-risk groups until they are protected by herd immunity." I've read this sentence almost verbatim literally dozens of times over the last few months. Those who promote this meme either offer no explanation for how this can be done, or offer a hand-wavy and anemic explanation of what is really a titanic effort on an untried scale. The oldest members of our society either live with their families or are attended by medical caretakers, who are an obvious source of infection. We can't put our elderly into Bubble Boy-style hospital wards or ship them to Old People Island. If we all go back to work and school, we can't help dramatically increasing the risk to the elderly from increased social mingling and network effects. The author offers the wan suggestion that the institutionalized elderly could be attended by a rotating cast of medical staff who are somehow certifiably safe. "Immunity passports" have been a conservative meme since the start of the epidemic, when we had zero evidential foundation for such a belief. The body of evidence for COVID immunity remains mixed. Six months in, we are starting to see cases of apparently incontrovertible reinfection. The question whether one can be immune and yet still infectious remains open. The enthusiasm for the "immunity passport" meme among a segment of commentators really feels like a spectator's desire to see some dog-eat-dog competition in the labor force. But all this, of course, is predicated on a third meme, which is that the effects of COVID are possible death for the very old and "water off a duck's back" for everyone else. No. A number of college athletes are currently grounded with pericarditis, a risky diagnosis with an indefinite time course. Unlike our Swiss cheese understanding of practical COVID immunity, our picture of COVID complications is becoming clearer, and it includes common incidence of dangerous internal inflammation, reduced lung function, and chronic fatigue. If we're concerned about the drag on our economy, let's consider what kind of drag a chronically ill labor force will generate. This is the scenario in third-world countries, where infectious diseases like malaria and AIDS eat into labor productivity and sap the average life expectancy. In other words, this is a dangerous complex of memes that show up in tandem and aren't particularly affected by gathering evidence. It is externally motivated and could very well endanger each of us individually.
- lbeltrame 6y agoRegarding the so called long term effects: is there any research that tells us how prevalent they are? A lot of people mention cases like these, I'd like to see some figures, also taking into account that pulmonary problems and fatigue, for one, are common to other diseases (even treatable ones). To be clear: I have no interest in downplaying severe effects of this infection. But I want to look at the whole picture.