3 ms·
It seems unnecessarily close to turning each Canadian ISP into another branch of the Canadian government's surveillance agencies. Only if you consider Bell Can
by cperciva 16y ago
It seems unnecessarily close to turning each Canadian ISP into another branch of the Canadian government's surveillance agencies.
Only if you consider Bell Canada to be a branch of CSIS. None of the requirements being proposed for ISPs go beyond what is already required for telephone networks -- and unlike phone conversations, it's easy to encrypt your internet communications.
- joshes 16y agoHonest question: does the RCMP require background checks for employees of civilian telephony providers?
- joe_the_user 16y agoActually, I think that's also a fine rhetorical question - in the sense of a question of who's answer is fairly obvious and which points to a large reality. ("Honest question" is fine way to say "this is not a rhetorical question". That's just to help clarity, rhetorical questions are fine tools of expression...) Even in the unlikely event that the RCMP is filtering some civilian employees, the overall reality is that far more information flows across the Internet to far more people than one could assure accountability around. So it is completely idiotic to up a surveillance network which looks so deeply into each person's communication that it would require serious accountability among the watchers. Since that accountability won't be there. Look airport security personnel, then imagine them going through your emails for bad stuff. It is worth remembers that the abusiveness of a society of surveillance often doesn't come so much from a single dictator but rather from a vast array of unaccountable Apparatchiks abusing their petty but unchecked power.
- cperciva 16y agoEmployees of phone companies generally? No, of course not. Employees who have access to the wire-tap systems? I'm sure they do.
- joe_the_user 16y agoCan you back that up with anything other than your personal certainty.
- cperciva 16y agoI have reasons to believe this, but none I can present here.
- joe_the_user 16y agounlike phone conversations, it's easy to encrypt your internet communications Considering the bill's clear intention is to prevent Internet communication from being private, how long do you imagine encrypted communication would remain legal?
- cperciva 16y agoPoliticians can be incredibly dumb, but I don't think any of them are dumb enough to make it illegal to access facebook over SSL.
- mindslight 16y agoI agree politicians avoid upsetting the majority. Large SSL sites will simply get permission/transit after setting up similar surveillance infrastructure. Small companies that explicitly go out of their way (with custom software, even!) to avoid knowing what their customers are doing - well, who knows?
- joe_the_user 16y agoThere's a standard that appears in the surveillance debate. "X is OK because no would be dumb/provocative/bold enough to do Y". But that arguments doesn't take into account that make X standard means that Y is no longer the stretch it would otherwise be. And in practical terms, the state indeed would have a hard time if they had to stop each individual using SSL for various logins. But it would be simple matter to either prohibit SSL for various things or to demand the right/ability to snoop on every SSL connection (in fact, it sound like this is more or less what's being planned now - but of course, "no one would be so dumb as to do it" so we have nothing to worry about).
- caf 16y agoOf course not - that's not necessary, as long as there's at least one CA beholden to the jurisdiction of the Canadian government.