4 ms·
I think, if this had been abused, Tesla would be out of business. But the fact that $50000 is chump change for Tesla does not mean it's chump change to the rec
by Aeolun 6y ago
I think, if this had been abused, Tesla would be out of business.
But the fact that $50000 is chump change for Tesla does not mean it's chump change to the recipient.
- falcolas 6y agoIt's funny, we always talk about compensating leaders for the value they provide to the company. Yet when it comes to non-leaders, it's transforms into a question of "value relative to their current/recent income".
- Talanes 6y agoPeople who assume the world is fair will always find the justifications for why any status quo is valid.
- rtlfe 6y ago> It's funny, we always talk about compensating leaders for the value they provide to the company. Yet when it comes to non-leaders, it's transforms into a question of "value relative to their current/recent income". That's maybe true for founders, but not really for hired executives: > One major consideration that goes into how much a CEO should be paid is what other companies are paying. Compensation committees benchmark CEO pay against a self-selected peer group -- often 12 to 20 companies that may be of similar size and complexity, and have similar business models, according to Robin Ferracone, CEO of Farient Advisors, an executive compensation consulting firm. https://www.cnn.com/2019/10/24/success/ceo-pay-packages/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2019/10/24/success/ceo-pay-packages/inde...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- filleduchaos 6y agoThe bounty was $5,000 not fifty thousand. And frankly that would be chump change anywhere for the opportunity cost.
- sellyme 6y agoIt was $50,000: > He didn’t end up getting a new Tesla, but the automaker awarded him a special $50,000 bug report reward — several times higher than the max official bug reward limit: You're looking at the $5,000 bounty awarded for exposing Supercharger-related data that Tesla "didn't want [...] out there", which is obviously a much less severe issue than remote control of the entire fleet.
- filleduchaos 6y agoAh okay, thank you. Not sure why the $5000 figure stuck with me
- jefftk 6y agoNo, $5k was for an earlier bug. "the automaker awarded him a special $50,000 bug report reward — several times higher than the max official bug reward limit"
- autisticcurio 6y ago$50k is not alot considering how much it would have harmed the share price with the negative press reports around the world. It could have even taken the company to the brink of extinction. For comparison, to get middle section, right hand side 1/2 page article written in the Sunday Times and Observer would have cost you about £30k 10 years ago to be introduced to the journalists writing your advert masquerading as a story. Multiply that up for all the global news outlets and the $50k bug bounty was a pittance. I wouldnt have been surprised if Musks day to day wine cellar was several times more expensive than that $50k bug bounty. 18 years ago my peak earning rate was £5k an hour so dont knowingly undersell yourselves in your day job or with bug bounty's. Simple letter govt agency's will also cover stuff up, using state broadcasters and other so called free press media outlets to put a spin on things or outright mislead. Seen this twice now.
- StillBored 6y agoHow long do you think it takes for someone to find an exploit? Sure, a long time ago I found problems in web pages by clicking "view source" and going "I wonder what happens if.." and doing POST/GET with a huge buffer, or with "\");...." embedded in it. These days companies that take their security seriously are hopefully harder to exploit. If it takes someone a couple months of slow fuzzing/etc to find an exploit that is probably below market for the persons skills here in the US. Maybe a part of these bug bounties should be not only how critical the bug is, but some metric of how much work the individual put in before finding the problem.
- TheSpiceIsLife 6y agoAny one individual could put in an arbitrarily huge amount of work, or claim to have, in order find a bug. How do we classify what constitutes work to find any particular bug?