3 ms·
> If a bank takes a $1,000,000 deposit one customer, and lends $850,000 of it to other customers, there isn't $1,850,000 worth of money all of a sudden. Not al
by pdonis 6y ago
> If a bank takes a $1,000,000 deposit one customer, and lends $850,000 of it to other customers, there isn't $1,850,000 worth of money all of a sudden.
Not all of a sudden, as in instantly, no, but there will be. See below.
> There is $850,000 worth of debt held by customers, and another customer with a $1,000,000 balance
Yes, but what do those other customers do with that $850,000 of debt? They either deposit it in another bank, or they use it to pay someone for something, and that someone deposits it in another bank, or...
In short, virtually all of that $850,000 of "debt" ends up as $850,000 of additional bank deposits in other banks. And to those other banks, those deposits are simple deposits--there are no debts (yet) against them on the other banks' books. So there is nothing to stop the other banks from lending out as much of that $850,000 as they can again. Which means the other banks have just turned what was $850,000 of "debt" into $850,000 of new money.
> Fractional reserve banking doesn't create money out of thin air
Yes, it does. I just explained how.
> it's just a system that allows for deposits to be put to productive use
More precisely, it's a bad system for putting deposits to productive use, because it mismatches maturities and therefore leaves the entire financial system open to bank runs, which then have to be prevented by additional "protective" measures. Which will sooner or later fail, and fail all the more catastrophically because the protective measures enable financial institutions to hide the fact that bad investments are being made.
The correct way to put deposits to productive use is to make them time deposits, not demand deposits. In other words, if you have a spare $1,000,000 that you have no good use for, you deposit it in some financial institution for a period of time, say a year, or 5 years, or 10 years, and that financial institution promises you some particular rate of return over that time in exchange for the use of your money to finance productive endeavors. Of course this is just another way of describing a bond, or a certificate of deposit, or a money market certificate, or whatever your financial institution chooses to call it.
But suppose you buy, say, a 5 year bond with your $1,000,000, and then, a year later, you find you need the money? Well, that's what a bond market is for--so you can sell your bond, at a fair market rate, and get cash in exchange, while someone else has now invested their money for the remaining term of the bond. There is no need for the financial institution to treat your $1,000,000 deposit as a demand deposit, withdrawable at any time, while it is transforming maturities by investing that money in other productive endeavors that take time to mature, just to shield you from unavoidable uncertainty about the future. There is certainly no need to expose the entire financial system to possible collapse to do this. The only reason this wacky system persists is that people in power benefit from it, and ordinary people have gotten so used to it, since it has been around for so long, that they don't connect it with the occasional meltdowns that it causes.
- onezerozeroone 6y agoThe person that received the $850k loan spent it, so their balance is then $0 and the bank also has a corresponding entry for -$850k of debt that they are owed and can collect interest on. The debt is an asset held by the bank until it is paid off, is sold, or is defaulted on. Person A deposits $1M Person A $1M, total deposits on hand = $1M Person B takes $850k loan Person A $1M, Person B $850k, Person B -$850k debt Total deposits on hand is STILL only $1M. The combined balances are 1.85M but these are just entries that have no impact on what is actually in the bank's vault/account. If A and B both ask for their entire balance at that moment the bank will have to go to the overnight window or some other facility to take a short-term loan that it will owe interest on and may need to provide collateral to receive. In that case the bank's overall balance sheet would be $-850k of debt it owes someone. Because that debt isn't collateralized their rate will probably be higher. This is what led to things like the credit market freeze up that the Fed needed to step in to provide liquidity for. Banks usually borrow from each other not just the Fed, but when shit hits the fan banks might not be willing or able to loan to each other except at extremely high rates. When the bank repays its loan (perhaps when Person C is paid by B and deposits the money into their account) the situation will unwind and we'll be back to the previous situation. In real life it's much more complicated because the bank probably has many other types of assets like CLOs, CDOs, etc. https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/040715/what-difference-between-collateralized-debt-obligation-cdo-and-asset-backed-security-abs.asp https://www.investopedia.com/ask/answers/040715/what-differe... Sometimes the Fed will take assets as collateral for a loan and the bank is expected to repurchase it later at a slightly higher price a/k/a the Repo market https://www.bankrate.com/banking/federal-reserve/why-the-fed-pumps-billions-into-repo-market/ https://www.bankrate.com/banking/federal-reserve/why-the-fed...
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- msh 6y ago>The correct way to put deposits to productive use is to make them time deposits, not demand deposits. In other words, if you have a spare $1,000,000 that you have no good use for, you deposit it in some financial institution for a period of time, say a year, or 5 years, or 10 years That will not work for normal accounts where peoples salary are deposited in, they need to use that money over the month. Also my savings account, I dont know when I will need the money. There might be emergency expensive repairs needed to my house or car that I need to take from that account.