3 ms·
I think a lot of people work with an assumption that the non-profit colleges at least have pure motives, so they may fall short on execution but they're trying.
by yummyfajitas 16y ago
I think a lot of people work with an assumption that the non-profit colleges at least have pure motives, so they may fall short on execution but they're trying.
This fallacy (what I sometimes call the "non-profit fallacy") is certainly being exploited by the people looking to harm for-profits.
But make no mistake - it is a fallacy. Non-profits want money just as much as for-profits - the only difference is that the money is distributed as salaries to employees (particularly the bloated administrations) rather than as profits to shareholders.
Institutional incentives matter far more than the explicit corporate charter.
- jbooth 16y agoEh, I'd say that it affects decisions at the topline more. Empire building happens everywhere, but if the attitude at the top is "we're here to make it rain" vs "we're here with a holy mission to educate", then that permeates everything.
- joe_the_user 16y agoThis fallacy (what I sometimes call the "non-profit fallacy") is certainly being exploited by the people looking to harm for-profits. In another part of this thread, you essentially admit the point that for-profits are engaging in a massively fraud against the Federal government as selling garbage degrees. So the problem with "harming" these shysters is what? That you don't want this to be specific to for-profit education institutions. Fair enough but any effort to "harm" this group would essentially involve reigning any college's ability to print federal government dollars. Is there a problem that rather pressing concern?
- yummyfajitas 16y agoI didn't essentially admit the point, I strongly agree with it. I'm just trying to put the idea out there that we shouldn't limit our attention to for-profits. I'm sure some for-profits do a good job, and I'm sure many non-profits don't. I suspect the majority of crappy schools are non-profits, simply because most colleges are non-profits. I strongly favor reigning in all crappy schools, I merely oppose limiting our efforts to for-profits.