15 ms·
Physicists found a new quantum paradox that casts doubt on a pillar of reality
- 4ad 6y agoActual paper: https://arxiv.org/abs/1907.05607 https://arxiv.org/abs/1907.05607
- mellosouls 6y agoRendered for web: https://www.arxiv-vanity.com/papers/1907.05607/ https://www.arxiv-vanity.com/papers/1907.05607/
- jonahbenton 6y agoI don't know to what degree the metaphor is accurate but as a non-physicist I find thinking about quantum mechanical experiments easier if I think of them as running code on a vast decentralized computing infrastructure. The concept of "measurement" is just executing code on one node that populates local registers- "creating" not "measuring". Yes- by running code you are pulling on a reality fabric that we still know almost nothing about. But I find it easier to visualize than relying on my colloquial/non-QM intuition in words like "measuring"- which implies something like a single centralized reality database, not a creative decentralized infrastructure. QM experiments seem to create things, not measure them. Would love to learn metaphors of folks in the space.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thechao 6y agoI’m just now teaching myself QM (20 years after school). I can tell you that in QM, seemingly innocuous phrases like “locality” have highly unintuitive, nonstandard meanings. I’m just now getting a glimpse at how amazingly fucking awful pop-sci QM articles are. If you’re interested in QM, read “The Theoretical Minimum”; the second book gets into QM. There are video lectures of the same material that complement the series, we’ll.
- jonahbenton 6y agoAppreciate the reference, cheers.
- guerrilla 6y agoThere are lectures by Susskind at Stanford on YouTube that go with them by the way.
- ssivark 6y agoThis perspective is interesting and potentially valuable, but it must be emphasized that quantum mechanics has linear evolution and hence “no cloning”. That means, when the registers are quantum objects, there is no such thing as copying a value into a register — there is only one version of each object, and you’re always manipulating it directly. That’s one aspect which leads to very difficult questions when thinking of “creating” at local nodes — because it’s the same object/copy that’s accessed at different nodes by various observers — so how can we ensure consistency of observations?
- jonahbenton 6y agoThanks, understood- the metaphor wasn't intended to imply the registers themselves were quantum objects, more that the process of observation / measurement of some quantum phenomenon- metaphorically- could be a creative/derivative process. That metaphor/mental model would conflict, to some degree, with the centralized/cache coherency metaphor you cite, that aligns more with colloquial understanding of "measure." Whether one is more appropriate than another I don't know. But I find the decentralized model produces more interesting naive questions for me to puzzle over. Of course those questions likely lead in a completely wrong direction. Cheers, thanks for engagement.
- ahelwer 6y agoAn alternative way to view measurement is that you're just entangling yourself with the quantum system, and are as much in superposition as the system itself.
- jonahbenton 6y agoThanks, yeah. With this view I run into trouble understanding what constitutes "entry into" and "exit from" superposition.
- ahelwer 6y agoPresumably, nothing was in superposition when the universe began. Everything after that evolved in time according to the Schrodinger equation, with everything becoming more superposed (i.e. their exact properties less certain) and entangled with everything else to at least some degree. Things can be more or less entangled with other things, and when you measure something you become very strongly entangled with it.
- menzoic 6y agoVeritasium has a great video that explains the concept of parallel worlds vs wave collapse in a single world https://youtu.be/kTXTPe3wahc https://youtu.be/kTXTPe3wahc
- amelius 6y agoNice video. Now I wonder if God uses structurally shared data structures in his implementation of the world. I also wonder if there can be a kind of continuous description of branching that is more amenable to calculus than the discrete tree-like branching.
- FascistsAreLame 6y agoIt’s a functional immutable universe clearly. We’ve kinda reached the point where the believability of this construct is being stretched though. Good attempt, but I’d try again.
- c1ccccc1 6y agoI think MWI actually predicts continuous branching. The prescription for MWI is just to run the Schrodinger equation forwards in time. So the branching would look like one blob of probability gradually becoming bimodal, and then splitting into two components with less and less overlap. (There might also be 3-or-more-way branches, not just binary splits.)
- elwell 6y agoTell me about the 'superworld' that hosts the many worlds.
- bondarchuk 6y agoThe original Wigner's friend paradox: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wigner%27s_friend https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wigner%27s_friend The paradox seems to rest on magical thinking about consciousness, and if one simply accepts that a conscious observer can be in a superposition like any other piece of matter, the paradox is resolved. And, from the article: For Wigner, this was an absurd conclusion. Instead, he believed that once the consciousness of an observer becomes involved, the entanglement would “collapse” to make the friend’s observation definite. But what if Wigner was wrong? Well, obviously Wigner is wrong, sorry for being flippant. In this paper (preprint here: https://arxiv.org/pdf/1907.05607.pdf https://arxiv.org/pdf/1907.05607.pdf), the magical thinking about consciousness seems to be transmuted into "“Absoluteness of Observed Events” (i.e. that every observed event exists absolutely, not relatively)". The authors (it appears to me) mean by this that if an observer performs an experiment, while this observer is himself in a superposition, we have to regard the outcome of the experiment as absolute (i.e. not in a superposition) because it was made by a (conscious) observer. In my opinion, both "Absoluteness of Observed Events", and the equivalent from the layman's article, "When someone observes an event happening, it really happened", is a disingenuous and confusing way of talking about observers who are in a superposition. We have crossed over from "quantum mechanics is weird" to "these superficially intuitive but clearly false assumptions about quantum mechanics are weird". (by the way, I read the article here: https://theconversation.com/a-new-quantum-paradox-throws-the-foundations-of-observed-reality-into-question-144426 https://theconversation.com/a-new-quantum-paradox-throws-the... because that site doesn't think I'm a robot and then redirects me to the homepage after filling out the captcha)
- TheOtherHobbes 6y agoYou might consider reading the original paper. Because the experiment doesn't rely on conscious observers at all. (Unless you think photons are conscious, which I'm assuming you don't.)
- bondarchuk 6y agoWell, that's the point. The experiment shows that one of three assumptions has to be false. But one of these (AOE) being false is not surprising or concerning at all, when dealing with non-conscious observers (such as photons, indeed). With conscious observers it would be concerning to some (not to me, but to Wigner and presumably the authors), because of the supposition that there's something special about conscious observers (i.e., magical thinking, IMHO). So what has this paper really shown? Absoluteness of Observed Events is false when the observers are photons, which (my layman's assumption) should surprise exactly nobody. And then they propose to repeat the experiment with an AI in a quantum computer as the observer. Lol.
- lisper 6y ago> if the "friend" is a human-level artificial intelligence running in a massive quantum computer. Well, there's your problem right there. No AI can run on a quantum computer. Intelligence is inherently a classical phenomenon because it requires copying information, and quantum states cannot be copied, only classical states can be copied. The classical world "emerges" from the quantum world when you take a quantum system and choose to consider only a subset of its degrees of freedom. When you do that, what results is a "mixed state" which behaves classically. This is not a reflection of any (meta)physical reality, it's just a consequence of your point of view. But here's the thing: you yourself are a subset of a quantum system, and so you yourself have no choice but to take this point of view. You cannot ever take the "god's-eye view" and "see" the whole system. That is fundamentally impossible because "seeing" requires copying information, quantum states can't be copied yada yada yada. Even God cannot "see" the god's eye view!
- Zenst 6y ago> quantum states cannot be copied Wouldn't quantum entanglement enable a comparable ability?
- gjhan 6y agoEntanglement means that there are systems with highly (more-than-classically) correlated state - that the combined state is something that can’t be represented by considering the systems independently - not that the states are the same. The no-cloning theorem prohibits a process that takes the state of a system and replicates it on another system. It’s certainly possible to have or to generate entangled sets of systems that have identical separable state, but not to copy an arbitrary state.
- boomboomsubban 6y agoI may be wrong, but I'm fairly sure you need to entangle the particles before they become a quantum state.
- amelius 6y ago> Intelligence is inherently a classical phenomenon because it requires copying information, and quantum states cannot be copied, only classical states can be copied. Ok, so make classical pointers to quantum states and copy the pointers instead of the quantum states :)
- henearkr 6y agoThe part that seems the most dubious to me is the "choice": > 2. It is possible to make free choices, or at least, statistically random choices. I don't see what would be really compelling in that. If it's false it would just mean that our actions are all kind of mechanistically decided by other events, and that does not shock me. Other point: > 1. When someone observes an event happening, it really happened. What if it really happened in the reality of the observer (and maybe not in other realities)? What is meant by "reality"? Some insight is to be gained by precising what we call the reality, in relation to the corpus of all the observations in what we believe is our universe.
- coliveira 6y agoThe main problem of quantum interpretation is the supposed, artificial, distinction between observer and observed system. In a quantum world this distinction is not possible, every event capable of "observing" a system is itself part of the system, modifying it. That's why such interpretations (postulating this separation) give all kinds of strange paradoxes that are impossible to solve. In the quantum world, there is no such thing as an observer, it is just all part of the system. Consider for example the system composed of a pool table. In classical physics we can assume we can always measure the position and momentum of all balls in the table. But what would happen if measurement was not possible without big changes in position and velocity? Suddenly the whole notion of "observation" would lose its meaning, and the only way to describe the pool table is as a probabilistic mesh of balls moving around in uncertain directions.
- henearkr 6y agoYes, I think you put your finger on it. As the observer is part of the system, his "reality" is as much superposed, entangled, etc., as the quantum events that compose it (himself and his observation too). That would give credit to the multiverse interpretation of quantum mechanics then. Maybe the observation process of a quantum phenomenon by a human observer is akin to the orthogonalization of a matrix: as the observer becomes entangled with the observed particle, each possible observer-eigenstate (i.e. any observer in "his reality") ends up observing an eigenstate of the observed quantum phenomenon, instead of a dirty superposition. To call it "orthogonalization of the observer-observed system" would be more descriptive than "wave-collapse", but the main difference is that the orthogonalization treats in parallel all possible outcomes, each linked to a different state (outcome) of the observer too, whereas the "collapse" view insists on the fact that the observed eigenstate is unique. And moreover, at least in mathematics, there are conditions for the orthogonalization to be possible at all, so that should be interesting.
- 08-15 6y ago> Take a look at these three statements [...] they cannot all be true Okay, so we have to kill one. The easiest one to kill is > It is possible to make free choices. In other words, quantum mechanics is incompatible with free will. This is clearly shocking to any physicist who believes in Free Will (as defined by philosophers thousands of years ago). But hasn't Free Will been recognized as nonsense for at least two centuries by now?
- katmannthree 6y ago> But hasn't Free Will been recognized as nonsense for at least two centuries by now? Among some, sure and it's not just physicists [1]. Acknowledging that the concept we've called free will is not likely to be real has some troubling implications regarding how we've structured our society which is likely one of the reasons it's not talked about very often. [1]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ihhVe8dKNSA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ihhVe8dKNSA
- elwell 6y agoThe members of a system can 'experience' free will from their perspective, but it's a still a deterministic line of causation; their free will is part of the determinism.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoWe, the figures of your imaginative simulation, have free will, but have decided that you do not.
- tsimionescu 6y agoIn fact, all statistical experiments, from clinical trials to observations of Bell's Inequality depend on the idea that there exists either free will or true randomness (and that we can base our decisions on that source of randomness). If neither exist, then there is no such thing as statistically independent events, and no way to make statistical observations (since that would imply that your choice of what to measure would always be correlated with the result of your measurement).
- thayne 6y agoHow is this a new paradox? Isn't this paradox the whole reason for different interpretations of Quantum Mechanics?
- gliese1337 6y agoI'm pretty sure "many-worlds is false" is not, in fact, a "pillar of reality".
- Zenbit_UX 6y agoWhenever I hear about weird shit from the realm of quantum physics (this theory, double-slit, etc..) I can't help but think: Why would I hardcode values for imperceptible objects, that would take an enormous about of ram and cpu time to constantly update values in the off chance it's needed. Much more efficient to optimize for what the _player_ can see at their perspective. Oh and I should probably code in some error handling in the fluke event one of these particles is detected, I'll just calculate their position retroactively, the user will never be able to tell and we can host way more players due to the reduced memory. It would seem to me that god is a junior dev and no one reviewed his pull requests.
- rantwasp 6y agodisagree on the junior dev part and on the god part. what you’re describing is called “simulation theory” and it has been proposed and discussed at length i think lazy evaluation makes sense in that context. i also think that having a few basic rules and after that applying them consistently across your simulation space make sense. if your basic space unit of reality is way smaller than the sims in it can perceive and measure they’re gonna start making stuff up
- Zenbit_UX 6y ago> disagree on the junior dev part and on the god part. Good lord, some people here are definitely on the spectrum. FYI that was an attempt at humor. In case you want to mimic human social behavior in the future: you don't _disagree_ with a joke, you either find it funny or you don't. > what you’re describing is called “simulation theory” and it has been proposed and discussed at length I'm aware of the theory, just like everyone else whose seen the matrix or read Elon's Twitter feed. For the record, I was merely illustrating a point; both our universe and the code we write share certain optimizations that would seem to be too coincidental to be random.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- 6y ago
- rantwasp 6y agothis is not convincing at all. we pretend that we can have perfectly isolated quantum systems (a particle, a few particles) and we can reason about and extrapolate the findings. we cannot have isolated particles - they can be regarded as isolated for experimental purposes but the reality is that probably the whole universe is a massive wave function that encompasses everything and we can approximate in some really special cases (ie system above). we also pretend that consciousness is something special and altering the state a somewhat complicated wetware had consequences on “reality”. it doesn’t. the measurement problem is an extremely good example of how we think. a measurement does not make sense to a cow. it’s abstract. we made it up. we have conventions that help make it useful, but those conventions break down when our senses (or things we use to amplify out senses) cannot measure what we want to measure.
- colordrops 6y agoBased on my very limited understanding it seems that anything that interacts with a system can be treated as an "observer", and thus a chain of observations can occur as one particle interacts with the next, enlarging the system that is in superposition for the next observer. Do physicists axiomatically treat a "conscious observer" as an atomic unit? It seems the case based on neurological and psychological research that the mind is actually not a single unit but many units working together, and the sense of a singular self is an illusion, which would correlate with the fact that we are made up of a conglomeration of atoms and systems made of these atoms. When we say that a person is observing a quantum system, could this actually be a cascade of observations of various parts of the mind rather than a singular event, since the mind is not monolithic? On a side note (and perhaps unrelated), if different parts of the brain/mind could be in different quantum states, could this be a factor in how the mind operates?
- stared 6y agoHave it ever happened o you that you read "a pillar of reality" and it turned out to be more than a clickbait? Me neither. (To make it clear: the content is interesting, even if clearly for popular science audience (some statements about physics are false, e.g. "These are all intuitive ideas, and widely believed even by physicists." The title is worth a tabloid.)
- booleandilemma 6y agoI'm still trying to figure out what exactly the discovery is, if there's any.
- mensetmanusman 6y agoMaybe our dream state is how we resolve and wipe quantum paradoxes from our days experience.
- hggfkkbcfd 6y agoOne this I always notice to be missing from discussions of quantum physics is the effect of scale. Does differences scale have relativistic effects, in a similar manner to differences in internal frames, and if at what do events in one scale frame of reference become simultaneous of an observer in another? Note: IANAP
- Strilanc 6y agoThe article lists three assumptions that one might intuitively think hold. The problematic assumption is this one: > When someone observes an event happening, it really happened. Given the experiment from the paper, I would rephrase this assumption as "it's not possible to rewind things". But obviously inside a computer simulation made up of operations that are all individually reversible, it's trivial to rewind things. The experiment sets up a situation where certain information is reversibly recorded, and then the records are unmade by temporarily rewinding. The rewinding is obfuscated by hiding it inside of a measurement that is incompatible with the presence or absence of the record. I guess the authors might disagree about the measurement implying rewinding, but as a bit of evidence I'll note that Scott Aaronson and Yosi Atia have shown that performing the measurement in question over a simulated agent is at least as expensive as rewinding the simulated agent [1]. Whatever is being done, it is doing some seriously expensive screwing around with the agent's state. It's like the experiment has a step where you feed the human through a giant meat processing plant, and for some reason everyone is pretending that's not somehow important. Basically, the authors are appealing to the intuition that humans are big complicated in-practice-irreversible things, so clearly a record is permanent if it has affected the state of a human. But then they imagine instantiating the human's state inside a ridiculously powerful computer capable of reversibly simulating time advancing and of performing operations that have been engineered specifically to mess with the presence or absence of the record's effects on the human's state. Surprise surprise, the record gets messed with. Then for the actual experiment the big complicated ball of dependent spaghetti that is a human is replaced by a nice simple photon going along one path or another path. 1: https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=4786 https://www.scottaaronson.com/blog/?p=4786
- zxcvbn4038 6y agoSo, Schrödinger's cat has been alive the whole time and it’s rest of us in a state of superposition because the cat is conscious but can’t observe anything outside the box? Or because we are conscious and the cat conscious, we all retain our states regardless if we are in or out of the box?
- BTCOG 6y agoThink of it as LOD generation in a game. As something observes or is near enough to observe, atomic matter is generated on demand. The Matrix; our simulation.