10 ms·
That's a clever trick. Make the medium you want to censor a private property than it's legal.
by croes 6y ago
That's a clever trick.
Make the medium you want to censor a private property than it's legal.
- judge2020 6y agoI doubt the US Government has any hand in this, other than not wanting to be the ones running social media.
- huntertwo 6y agoI don't think it's a question of the medium but a question of the actor doing the censoring. If the feds mandate the censoring on a private medium, I don't think it makes it legal. I think one difference is the enforcement, Google can't censor an individual universally, just on their platform, whereas the government can enforce it universally with force/jail/etc.
- MaxBarraclough 6y ago> If the feds mandate the censoring on a private medium, I don't think it makes it legal FCC regulation of TV broadcast comes close, but apparently obscenity isn't protected under the First Amendment (perhaps you can tell I'm not a lawyer, or for that matter an American). https://www.fcc.gov/consumers/guides/obscene-indecent-and-profane-broadcasts https://www.fcc.gov/consumers/guides/obscene-indecent-and-pr...
- fiddlerwoaroof 6y agoYeah, there is this vague idea that the First Amendment doesn’t apply to certain categories of speech (yelling “Fire” in a crowded theater is the classic example) that get stretched to fit this sort of thing.
- lukifer 6y agoAnd of course, the infamous fire in a crowded theater argument was first coined as a rationale for punishing pamphleteering against the draft: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_theater https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Shouting_fire_in_a_crowded_the...
- skissane 6y agoIt's a problem with the drafting – the original authors always meant for there to be exceptions, but decided not to specify explicitly in the text what those exceptions were going to be – thus leaving it up to the courts to decide in practice what exceptions are allowed and what are not. The obscenity exception was largely non-controversial until the 20th century, because there was a broad societal consensus, among both popular and elite opinion, that obscenity and pornography did not deserve First Amendment protection. It was only in the 20th century that societal consensus broke down, and it was in that context the US Supreme Court decided to reduce the scope of that exception. (It still exists, and is still occasionally enforced.) The original authors and ratifiers of the First Amendment supported laws against obscenity, and didn't believe the First Amendment prohibited them. Ultimately the courts have to decide what laws mean, even constitutional laws – but they could always have given them more guidance, by being more explicit in the text about which exceptions are valid and which are not
- selestify 6y agoHow did that shift in attitudes about obscenity happen?
- _jal 6y agoA super-interesting question that is also an invite for people to flog their own personal theories. People will tell you lots of reasons: increasing incomes, the development of ubiquitous media, increasing diversity, weakened religious control mechanisms, etc. There is probably at least a little truth to each of those, although I think many of them are also effects of central causes (e.g., religious control over common people's lives declined because of increasing incomes, which increased due in part to advances in communications tech).
- Bud 6y agoPotter Stewart knew it when he saw it.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- robertlagrant 6y agoOf course, being in a crowded theater violates social distancing guidelines, so now you don't need to shout anything :-)
- alasdair_ 6y agoI assume the reason for that is that the FCC grants a government-protected monopoly on wireless spectrum to a single entity. In the granting of a monopoly, they also demand extra "protections", in much the same way that there are regulations on other monopolies.
- electrograv 6y agoUnfortunately, it becomes virtually universal when a small set of massive companies (with similar censorship ideas) control 99% of all our communications and social media. I think this evades the spirit of the legal protections here, at least. Note: I'm not disagreeing with you, and don't really have a solution here. Just pointing out how the current situation feels like dangerous territory.
- jakelazaroff 6y agoIronically, I think one promising solution is the Fediverse. Or, more generally: given how subjective ideas about acceptable speech are, the only real solution is to break up giant gatekeepers like Google.
- stinkytaco 6y agoIt's the side effect of allowing a small number of largely unregulated companies to control so much of our communications. TV and radio using public right-of-ways like radio bands are much more tightly regulated to ensure "equal time". That's not the case for social media or mobile platforms and I suspect any attempt to regulate those would be met with a great deal of resistance. Not the least complaint would be that regulation has a history of keeping small players out, potentially further cementing the monopoly of a few companies. I don't know the answer to any of this, but I think it's something that will need to have an answer if our democracy is to survive.
- nescoiquid 6y agoThe equal time doctrine was eliminated in 1987: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FCC_fairness_doctrine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/FCC_fairness_doctrine >> The fairness doctrine of the United States Federal Communications Commission (FCC), introduced in 1949, was a policy that required the holders of broadcast licenses to both present controversial issues of public importance and to do so in a manner that was—in the FCC's view—honest, equitable, and balanced. The FCC eliminated the policy in 1987 and removed the rule that implemented the policy from the Federal Register in August 2011.
- nybble41 6y agoAnd for good reason. It doesn't make sense to mandate equal time for mainstream and fringe positions, rational proposals and ones riddled with contradictions. Either some government censor is responsible for deciding which positions are "serious" enough to warrant equal time or the media eventually gets overwhelmed with nonsense and conspiracy theories. If you want to see where the "fairness doctrine" leads, just have a look at some of the less discriminating social media sites.
- jounker 6y agoEvidence suggests that the fairness doctrine worked really well until we ended it. Until it’s elimination mass media news in the US was pretty middle of the road.
- IntelMiner 6y agoAnd yet. There's a certain "side" that wants to have that both ways Private companies can't censor "bad opinions" But private companies can also arbitrarily refuse service for say, making a "gay wedding cake" How is this disconnect rationalized?
- colpabar 6y agodoesn't it go both ways? if you flip both positions, it's also inconsistent.
- SkyBelow 6y agoI have to say I generally agree with you that when someone points out a contradiction in some common political stance, the reverse of that contradiction exists in the opposite stance. It seems pretty common, though it generally results from distilling a more complex view into a simplified statement (which may edge into the territory of creating men of straw).
- colpabar 6y ago>generally results from distilling a more complex view into a simplified statement couldn't agree more. it's so frustrating seeing this everywhere online. this isn't twitter, you can write as much as you want. I read comments online to try and understand other viewpoints, and I can't do that without substance.
- ivanbakel 6y agoHow so? The first hypocrisy is the defense of the right of a business to make arbitrary decisions w.r.t. service (not bake the cake), while simultaneously demanding that the business not have the power to refuse service (condemning private censorship). The reverse position is not hypocritical in the same way, because condemning discrimination against customers on LGBT grounds is not at odds with censoring discriminatory speech - in fact, the two positions are aligned. You could try to argue that private censorship is itself a form of discrimination, but most people who hold the second position would not concede that the people who practice hate speech are a minority worthy of protection - so for them, no discrimination is occurring.
- MiroF 6y agoCapitalism rests on a negative conception of freedom, so yes.
- masukomi 6y agonot really. it's just saying "this is mine, it's not public property or a public service, and thus i get to manage it how i want." I think MOST people would agree that that's a reasonable approach. just because a lot of people rely on the google play store doesn't mean it's a public service in the legal sense. It's a very private piece of software that is NOT open source and is very obviously owned and managed by a single entity. just like you get to choose who you let in your house. they get to choose how their software is used. side note: monopoly is a separate issue.
- Proven 6y ago> side note: monopoly is a separate issue. I upvoted you but regarding this last sentence - monopoly shouldn't be a separate issue. The same private property rights should apply.
- nybble41 6y ago> just like you get to choose who you let in your house. they get to choose how their software is used. The first instance is property rights. The second is copyright, a privilege granted by the government at the expense of others' property rights. When a private party leverages copyright to conduct censorship it's ultimately the government that is responsible for violating the victim's freedom of speech. Google certainly has the right to grant or deny access to their services as they please, but that is not the same as having a natural right to decide how the software they develop is used after it has already been released to the public.
- LegitShady 6y agoI agree with you, but the flip side is that they are not liable for the speech on their property due to an exception in section 230 of the communications decency act. If they have shown the ability to control speech on their platforms section 230 should be repealed and Google etc should be responsible for the content on their property like any other publisher.
- kube-system 6y agoSection 230 exists because it is operationally impractical for websites to affirmative approve of all, most, or even a significant portion or content before it is published by users. If there's anything that is an indisputable fact, it's that no high-volume platform with user content can proactively police their platform 100%. I think that's a silly rationale to say that they should be prohibited from manually policing content that is brought to their attention afterwards.
- Causality1 6y agoThat's the problem of the all-private internet. There is no virtual street corner at which to protest. There is no internet post office to handle your mail. There is no internet water utility who isn't allowed to shut off your service no matter how many people complain about you. There is only profit. The moment you become unprofitable for whatever reason you will lose everything. If tomorrow 51% of the world decided they hated left-handed people they would all find their accounts disabled, their website registrations suspended, their entire online presence forced into secrecy. So far that's only happened, to my knowledge, to terrorists and white supremacists, but there is absolutely no legal reason why it can't happen to anyone else.
- jerkstate 6y ago>There is no internet water utility who isn't allowed to shut off your service no matter how many people complain about you. speaking of shutting off water, this is happening in meatspace too: https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/los-angeles-mayor-eric-garcetti-001106201.html https://www.yahoo.com/entertainment/los-angeles-mayor-eric-g...
- RonanTheGrey 6y agoYep, and this is the core problem that I think much of the debate around social networks and online services in general is missing - the debate typically centers around these entities' legal rights, and completely forgets the fact that the online scenario actually has very little equivalent in the real world. The real world contains public spaces. It contains within it the recognition that some part of all of this around us, belongs to everyone. And while that has been the center of much of the rhetoric about the internet since its inception, that rhetoric has never actually been true IN FACT. It's a mishmash of private entities controlling their piece of the puzzle. I think, as another poster mentioned, if democracy is to survive, the concept of "some part of the internet and its services are a public good" must take hold. Now, that's a scary-ass thing to say because unlike a piece of land, or drinking water, these things don't just "exist". They exist only as long as some entity pays for them, which means that such a statement implies things about who pays (government? subsidies? you pay but it isn't yours? special kinds of taxes?). And yet I think avoiding dystopia requires going that way. I have no idea what it would look like. Of course, there's an alternative. Google/Twitter/FB/etc. can agree that they don't censor anyone unless that person breaks the law. That puts the discussion right back where it should have been in the first place: In the public, political sphere, where The People have the ability to influence the outcome. But then, why would Google etc. do that? Too enticing, all that power.
- kmeisthax 6y agoActually, this doesn't work. There's a specific court doctrine called the State Actors Rule. If a private entity is working on behalf of the government, then all of the constitutional protections applied to the government also apply to that private entity within the scope of them being a state actor. For example, this is why it is unconstitutional for Donald Trump to block you on Twitter, or for the Air Force's esports team to block you from their Twitch streams. This also extends to physical venues and company towns.
- mindslight 6y agoIt's not a deliberate trick on anyone's part, but rather complexity induced contradiction. Similar destruction has happened to other rights - jury trial via plea bargains, equal representation via forced arbitration clauses, "papers please" via driving and flying, unreasonable search and seizure via web services, double jeopardy via overlapping jurisdictions, and of course federated government via pervasive commerce.
- vertis 6y agoOr another trick, just place it in another country and then you don't have to worry about the 1st amendment at all, and no I'm not talking about China. UK or Australia will do just fine.
- kube-system 6y agoThis is not true at all, and neither is the comment you responded to. The constitution doesn't apply to a location or a medium, it applies to an actor: the US government (and state/local subdivisions). The US government has to follow it everywhere, and nobody else has to follow it anywhere.
- vertis 6y agoMy comment was a bit tongue-in-cheek, as I think the parent was as well. Americans do tend to run around quoting their first amendment rights like the whole world has them. As you say, it's strictly a US government thing. While Australia for the most part enjoys free speech, it is not enshrined in the (AU) constitution. The government will occasionally order censorship[1], usually around whistle-blowing, investigations and court cases. There was a protest in the major Australian papers last year about the erosion of press freedoms[2]. [1]:https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/14/world/australia/australia-gag-order-court.html https://www.nytimes.com/2018/12/14/world/australia/australia... [2]: https://www.bbc.com/news/world-australia-50119559 https://www.bbc.com/news/world-australia-50119559