15 ms·
Apple blocks Facebook update that called out 30-percent App Store ‘tax’
- perryizgr8 6y agoI feel that the condition Apple puts on app devs to not indicate to customers in any way that 30% of their purchase is going to Apple is the most problematic. It shows that Apple knows their cut is too high, and customers won't stand for this rate if they knew what they were paying for. If they genuinely believe their service is worth 30%, they should be confident about it, let users understand the break up of their bill. Truly insane levels of monopoly on display here.
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoIs this in-place-of or on-top-of the credit card transaction fees? A lot of in-app purchases are for less than $3. Doesn't Apple need to pay Visa a $0.35 transaction fee, plus ~3% of the purchase price. On a < $3 purchase, that's 15%+ already.
- drrotmos 6y agoIn-place-of
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- hboon 6y agoApple bundles purchases fit each account and don’t charges cards immediately so in practice, the average is much lower.
- mijamo 6y agoApple must have a better deal than that with Visa, big actors with have a much better deal than what you commonly see, with no fixed fee. I think they must pay less than 1. 5% transaction fee with no lower limit or fixed addition.
- username90 6y agoTransaction fees are just 0.3% in Europe since levying a 3% tax on every purchase is insane and hurts progress. You should probably go after those companies in USA as well. Basically in Europe it is illegal to levy an unreasonable tax for generic services like this. The same applies to Apple.
- onlyrealcuzzo 6y agoSo is Apple not allowed to take a 30% cut in Europe? How about Amazon for Kindle books? Are digital distributers allowed to charge 30%? Where does Europe draw this line?
- drrotmos 6y agoAs a counterpoint, those 30% account for more than just processing fees. Why should the average consumer be tasked with deciding whether a given cut is reasonable without knowing what that cut actually goes to?
- luckylion 6y agoThat's a bit like saying "the citizenry shouldn't know how we spend the money collected by taxes", isn't it? The users wouldn't need to decide whether it's reasonable, they could just ignore it. Not allowing information to get to the user is a different thing though.
- drrotmos 6y agoI don't think so. It's more akin to not posting a sign saying "our landlord charges us $5,000/month in rent" in a brick-and-mortar shop. At the end of the day there are costs associated with doing business online. If Facebook was able to have their own payment processing pipeline, and still charged no cut, that's them processing payments at a loss, and subsidizing it with other income streams. The Apple cut doesn't just cover payment processing though, (in Apple's opinion at least) it also covers the costs of maintaining the app store, reviewing apps, developer tooling etc. There's really two separate questions here, is 30% as a cut for the entire App Store ecosystem reasonable, and is it reasonable to charge a cut paying for the entire ecosystem to someone who really is only "getting" the payment processing parts of it. In a sense, when Facebook is providing this kind of platform, they're essentially competing with the App Store. Instead of whomever is running "Jasper's Cooking Class" making a cooking class streaming app and posting it to the App Store platform, they're able to use the Facebook platform to provide the same service. Because this becomes sort of a platform-in-a-platform, it starts getting expensive pretty quickly, because you have to pay for both. Of course, the people behind "Jasper's Cooking Class" (presumably Jasper himself) are probably not in a position to make an app and posting it to the App Store, so Facebook providing a lower barrier to entry is probably a good thing for the market as a whole, but they're not doing it out of the good of their hearts, it's still a very deliberate business decision, aimed at keeping people on Facebook, where the users are monetized in other ways.
- WrtCdEvrydy 6y agoWhen Epic referenced 1984, I didn't think the Apple folks could read... maybe they can.
- bmarquez 6y agoI have no particular love for Facebook, but good for them. It's one thing to charge a 30% app tax to sign up for "Jasper's Cooking Class" on an iOS device, but it's even worse to ban disclosure of that tax. Forbidding that speech is certainly 1984-esque.
- CamperBob2 6y agoYou either die a hero, or you live long enough to become the guy on the telescreen. The problem is, the chick with the hammer wouldn't make it past the cheap seats today.
- sitkack 6y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zIE-5hg7FoA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zIE-5hg7FoA
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- HenryBemis 6y agoEasy-peasy.. just like when you go to the super market or a restaurant and the receipt has the analysis of the amount: $15 pizza, $15 salad, $3 soft drink, $10 VAT, $8 Apple's 30% fee (I didn't do the math, but you get the spirit). They CANNOT force you to remove transparency and visibility of the line items. I understand that they want to hide the 30% cut and not being called out. They can also split the receipt in three parts: A) you purchased: Pizza $15, Salad $15, Soft drink $3 B) Other fees: Apple's 30% fee $10 C) Taxes: VAT $3 Edit: it just hit me. Don't write that ONLY in the receipt. Write it up front, BEFORE a user completes the transaction. Total price of ticket $10. Analysis.. X, Y 30% Apple's fee, VAT.
- pawnednow 6y agoMaybe Facebook should go make phones and then try and waive fees that help third parties build momentum that they will eventually capitalise on.. I can understand the 30% tax being tough for indie publishers but when I see companies like hey.com and FB & Epic taking this stance, I feel like they are being treated exactly how they will treat others if they were in position of power in the relationship.
- spike021 6y agoIt's definitely kind of surprising coming out of Facebook when technically they're the ones profiting off of users' data without any kind of cut. I'm not even one to usually complain about that, but this certainly gives off a double-standards vibe.
- avalys 6y agoThe “cut” that users get is the ability to use all Facebook services for free?
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- return1 6y agofacebook's platform has existed since before ios and it has made thousands of developers millionaires. It was always completely free. Facebook payments exist, but they are optional. If anything, FB is the complete counter-example to apple
- newbie578 6y agoI love reading the Apple fanboys comments. Please do keep defending Apple and it's mafia cut, I am honestly amazed that people cannot see Apple's fault in this, not only do they make you increase your prices by 43% (to get the 30% cut, prices need to increase by 43%) they won't let you even explain to customers the reason why it is more expensive (Hint: they won't let you do it because they know it is a highway robbery). When I buy something and get a bill, I like to know how much of the price goes to taxes, if anything else at least for the transparency.
- awerawerawrjhui 6y ago> Hint: they won't let you do it because they know it is a highway robbery This. If Apple thought their fees were reasonable they wouldn't be so insistent on hiding them from users.
- paublyrne 6y ago> Apple said the update violated an App Store rule that doesn’t let developers show “irrelevant” information to users. I'm curious which rule this is and to what or whom the information needs to be irrelevant to to be in breach.
- disillusioned 6y ago3.1.3(b) is probably what they're obliquely referencing, but I was once told by an Apple App Reviewer that "not all of our rules or guidelines are published" which caused me to have an aneurysm and shout "THEN WHAT'S THE POINT OF THE RULES?" "You must not directly or indirectly target iOS users to use a purchasing method other than in-app purchase, and your general communications about other purchasing methods must not discourage use of in-app purchase." 2.3.10 has a bit about not including "irrelevant information about Apple or the development process." It's under the Metadata section, but still: "2.3.10 Make sure your app is focused on the iOS, Mac, Apple TV or Apple Watch experience, and don’t include names, icons, or imagery of other mobile platforms in your app or metadata, unless there is specific, approved interactive functionality. Make sure your app metadata is focused on the app itself and its experience. Don’t include irrelevant information, including but not limited to information about Apple or the development process." https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/ https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/
- tristanj 6y agoThe app store guidelines are a complete joke. Apple can change the guidelines at any time. They make up 'rules' to their own benefit. And selectively enforce existing ones so major players get a free pass. Developers have no recourse, other than leaving the platform.
- aembleton 6y ago> And selectively enforce existing ones so major players get a free pass. Are Facebook not a major player on iOS?
- xyzal 6y agoWhy they don't just make purchases on iPhones 30% more expensive?
- akmarinov 6y agoThey do, but they want their users to explicitly know that those 30% are going to Apple.
- luckylion 6y agoDo they? According to the screenshots in the article they don't. It seems that whoever is actually selling something via Facebook will simply get less from Apple users.
- chrismorgan 6y agoNote that for parity you need to boost prices by about 43%: (100% + 43%) × (100% − 30%) ≅ 100%. (I love sevenths in decimal. One seventh is 0.1̅4̅2̅8̅5̅7̅, two sevenths 0.2̅8̅5̅7̅1̅4̅, three sevenths 0.4̅2̅8̅5̅7̅1̅, &c. Just remember 7 × 2 = 14, 14 × 2 = 28, 28 × 2 = 56 and change the six to a seven for some reason and start again with that, and rotate the whole lot as necessary. It’s just beautiful.)
- sillysaurusx 6y agoI can't help but ask followup questions about what you're saying re: the 7's. Firstly, why are your numbers wearing hats? (I know it represents a repeating number, but how do you type numbers with hats? I assume you're not copy-pasting 5̅7̅1̅ whenever you want to write it out. Is there a shorthand on MacOS?) Regarding the 7's, I don't understand the pattern from 0.142857 to 0.285714 to 0.428571. Are you saying that 0.428571 is easy to remember, somehow? Or derivable from 0.285714? In fact, did you write out these numbers without using a calculator? I see what you're saying with 7 x 2 = 14, x 2 = 28, x 2 = 56. And I see that if you change 56 to 57, then yes indeed it does match the ending of 0.1̅4̅2̅8̅5̅7̅, and then you can repeat the pattern of 7 x 2 = 14, which matches the ending of your 0.2̅8̅5̅7̅1̅4̅ number. But what's the connection to 0.4̅2̅8̅5̅7̅1̅? It's unclear how to use your trick to go from 7̅1̅4̅ to 5̅7̅1̅. Or even why that's helpful in general, or what the overall connection is between all of these seemingly unrelated things. Thanks for sharing!
- inopinatus 6y agoMisuse of market power and unconscionable conduct that misleads the consumer are hard to prove, even in jurisdictions where they're flat-out unlawful and the consumer regulators have enforcement teeth, but it's almost as though Apple is actively trying to become a textbook example.
- chrismorgan 6y agoI’m curious whether Apple’s conduct here would be illegal in Australia—I suspect it might be, and believe it should be. Credit card networks used to tell businesses “you’re not allowed to itemise or pass this fee on to your customers”; at some point (maybe 10–15 years ago? Can’t find a reference quickly) this was confirmed to be illegal in Australia: businesses are allowed to apply a surcharge to cover their transaction costs (and nothing more, though in practice I think many businesses just apply a flat rate like 1–2% which will be higher than their costs for some transactions), per https://www.accc.gov.au/consumers/prices-surcharges-receipts/credit-debit-prepaid-card-surcharges https://www.accc.gov.au/consumers/prices-surcharges-receipts.... The relevant legislation only applies to certain payment methods, so it would probably not be directly applicable to Apple’s 30% tax, though perhaps other legislation might protect your ability to at least itemise it (I don’t know); but given that the payment are probably ultimately coming from such payment networks, I wonder whether Apple could become subject to this rule to at least some extent, so that e.g. they had to let you split out the card transaction fees from the rest of their 30% cut and itemise and charge it. (And the purpose of doing that would be to begin pushing them to reduce their absurd 30% tax. Thinking of that, I wonder how many people have complained to ACCC about the 30% tax—it can’t be zero—and why they haven’t come down on Apple like a ton of bricks yet, because what they’re doing is basically the same as what credit card networks did, only 20–50× as greedy and infinitely more anticompetitive since no alternative is permitted on Apple’s platform, whereas credit cards had cash and cheques as alternatives.)
- PeterStuer 6y agoIt was the same over here in Belgium when electronic payment terminals were introduced in shops. The contracts stipulated that the extreme fees (up to 10% at start) could not be passed onto the customer, so all the shop owners could do was spread them over all sales (or swallow them) making everyone pay for this new platform whether you used it or not. Of course customers demanded the convenience of paying with cards, and since the bill could not be itemized, shopkeepers had a hard time explaining the ramifications to the customers.
- jagged-chisel 6y ago
- hiisukun 6y agoI wonder how this would interact with various consumer laws. In Australia, for example, there are standards that prevent ticket sellers for events from being deceptive about fees - adding costs beyond a reasonable amount required to provide the service, etc. I'm not making any specific case, rather just feeling curious about how this impacts consumer rights and expectations. As a purchaser, I think it might be fair to know that $3 goes to apple when I buy a $10 cooking class using Facebook. Edit: chrismorgan below posted a much more informative comment in this vein while I typed.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- thefounder 6y agoI believe visa/mastercard has a similar rule. You can't charge more(to compensate the fees) for credit card transaction either.
- tristanj 6y agoNot anymore. They removed the rule in 2013 after they were hit with a $5.7 billion antitrust settlement. https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/us-judge-approves-visa-mastercard-57-billion-credit-card-settlement-with-retailers/2013/12/13/bd42b88c-643a-11e3-aa81-e1dab1360323_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/business/economy/us-judge-app...
- mFixman 6y agoThis is about telling the user that Mastercard is charging you a fee.
- youngtaff 6y agoYou can in the UK
- jimsmart 6y agoNot in most cases, since 2018. https://www.gov.uk/government/news/card-surcharge-ban-means-no-more-nasty-surprises-for-shoppers https://www.gov.uk/government/news/card-surcharge-ban-means-...
- Mindwipe 6y agoThey tried and got absolutely hit hard by anti-trust and legislation in the US and Europe. They no longer try. The same is pretty inevitable for Apple at this point.
- lvturner 6y agoA hilarious and unlikely scenario would be if Apple just pulled the plug on in-app purchases and forced everyone to charge an upfront fee for their apps. While the downsides are fairly obvious - there are a few things that this would improve.
- summitsummit 6y agothere does seem to be mounting pressure for the current model to change. i doubt it will be like the scenario you offered, but i wonder what the options are. i suppose more transparency on them getting a cut, and/or decreasing the size of the cut are plausible.
- Havoc 6y agoApple is going end up getting the short end of the stick here. The optics on this whole debacle are just too bad. Walled garden and enforcement of strict rules to protect the user is one thing, but walled garden to protect profits hits a little different.
- tomp 6y agoIndeed. I'm generally libertarian, but I see business as a privilege and in service to society. So this would be a great place for some measured and targeted government action. Hoping the EU acts, like some time ago they limited credit card fees, preventing an unproductive race to the bottom ("top"?)
- mFixman 6y agoWill they though? They have a complete monopoly on distribution for all iOS devices and are willing to remove certificates for OSX programs. For all we know, they will remove SSL certificates for HTTPS websites on Safari if a company oversteps their bounds too much. Congress will do nothing about this, and the EU and other governments are busy legislating other problems.
- Mindwipe 6y ago> Congress will do nothing about this, and the EU and other governments are busy legislating other problems. The EU already has legislation, and will absolutely be passing further legislation on it in the next year to eighteen months.
- SyneRyder 6y agoApple have already gone a step further, they've started intercepting website traffic and redirecting it to their own walled garden Apple News app instead, without permission from the websites: https://www.macrumors.com/2020/08/13/apple-news-web-links-redirection-concerns/ https://www.macrumors.com/2020/08/13/apple-news-web-links-re...
- username90 6y ago> the EU and other governments are busy legislating other problems. EU made laws to reduce credit card fees to stop American credit card companies from extracting a tax, also GDPR to stop American companies from bullying Europeans. I totally expect they will do something similar for app store taxes if American companies don't stop bullying European companies soon.
- znpy 6y agoThe craziest thing is that a 30% cut is close to what most state ask in terms of taxation.
- chillacy 6y agoYea so as a developer I pay two taxes: The first 30% goes to Apple, the next 30% goes to the government, now for every dollar my app sold for I make 49 cents.
- znpy 6y agonow compare how many services you're getting for that 30%: a legal system, roads, schools, hospitals, an army to defend the nation you live in, in some countries healthcare etc etc... now back to apple: for that 30% you're quite literally getting the permission to keep working.
- chillacy 6y agoI mean to be fair I'm getting payment processing and hosting but yea it's a pretty steep fee.
- znpy 6y agoCan I ask you something? Could you evaluate the storage/bandwidth price by using something like the S3 price calculator as a reference and stripe for payment processing? It would be interesting to see how much is apple actually getting on top of publicly-available, practically retail prices.
- return1 6y agoIsnt that breaking consumer protection laws by intentionally misinforming customers? Users have a right to know where their money is going, and this is also presents false information to the user about how much the service costs (much like a receipt or ticket that does not break down the tax) I m also surprised how people nitpick over apples rules as if they re some kind of laws. They re not , nobody voted for them and if enough ppl complain they may change
- Traster 6y agoIt's funny, I looked but I can't find where Facebook discloses the credit card charges that come out of the transaction when you do the transaction on their website. Doesn't that seem like deliberately misleading anti-consumer behaviour. Do you transaction on our competitors' device and we'll harangue you about how your money is going to the evil guys, but do you transaction on our platform and we'll still take transaction fees, we just won't tell you about it.
- dwild 6y agoEdit: Seems like they don't actually surcharge on Apple device. You can ignore this comment, I'll keep it for posterity. I believe it's because they surcharge on Apple platform because of that fee, thus they want to show why they have to surcharge. It's like saying that websites shouldn't show shipping if they got a physical store because at the physical store they didn't show the shipping rate they got there.... It's possible though that the 30% Apple fee could include the transaction fee, I guess they could round it up to 28% but then your comment right now would probably be that the number is incorrect as transaction fees are variable between cards.
- lowdose 6y agoTit for tat with the lost of their audience capabilities Facebook leverages momentum on Apple's tax friction with Epic Games.
- thoughtstheseus 6y agoFacebook should also mention the product Apple is “taxing” has near $0 marginal cost (in most cases).
- chillacy 6y agoIf these events are anything like the some of the AirBnb experiences I've attended, there's material cost and effort to adding more attendees: more cooking supplies, more equipment, more instructor attention, more work to followup, etc.
- NotAnAccountNO 6y agoHow is informing users of some true fact not protected by the first amendment. How is this not free speech?
- eanzenberg 6y agoInteresting how every big dog is attacking Apple as they continue to be the lone-wolf in enabling privacy and a secure platform for their users. Apple users are mostly computer illiterate because its Apple’s mission statement to enable computing for everyone. Because of their ease of use, they are now targeted to open up their platform in ways that will jeopardize both their increasing user-privacy and user-security.
- fsociety 6y agoYou’re extending too much good faith to a corporation. Apple’s privacy statements are a strategic position, as is not allowing apps to mention the 30% cut. If Apple was seriously concerned about their users, they would not be concerned about apps mentioning the 30% cut - which is a truth!
- eanzenberg 6y agoLet me know next time you buy something and receive a distribution invoice knowing how much it cost to you.
- coronadisaster 6y agonow it is getting interesting
- afrojack123 6y agoWhat your thought process should be if your an Apple employee trying to maximize his value: If the megacorps are equally sized and competing against each other, your dependence on one employer will go down.
- whalabi 6y ago> Facebook said that Apple cited an App Store rule that bars developers from showing “irrelevant” information to users. This is incredibly draconian. I know it's Apple's platform but when ¼ of Earth uses that platform, letting one company have that much power and control seems dangerous.