6 ms·
Hurricanes don't threaten government credibility the way successful terrorist attacks do. We might not like it but it makes perfect sense that a government age
by throwaway0a5e 6y ago
Hurricanes don't threaten government credibility the way successful terrorist attacks do. We might not like it but it makes perfect sense that a government agency prioritizes threats to the government.
- whatshisface 6y ago>Hurricanes don't threaten government credibility the way successful terrorist attacks do. This is one of those claims where the only reasonable answer is... "do they?" Bad disaster responses can make administrations look pretty bad.
- microcolonel 6y ago> Bad disaster responses can make administrations look pretty bad. Whether disaster responses are considered good or bad depends largely on which narrative the media select.
- aequitas 6y agoBut they often just blow over whereas terrorists can keep a lingering presence.
- akman 6y agoBoth good and bad responses to successful terrorist attacks threaten government credibility, simply because they were successful. The key is for a government to prevent them from being successful in the first place. Only bad disaster responses make administrations look pretty bad.
- whatshisface 6y agoThat would imply that it would only be worth trying to prepare for hurricanes, because work there would improve public reception, while terrorist attacks would go badly no matter what you did.
- akman 6y agoUnless you prevent them from being successful in the first place. As a side note, I wonder if there's also a bias that human minds are more easily controlled than forces of nature. That may also come into play here.
- shalmanese 6y agoDoes it though? Can you point me to a free, western style Liberal Democracy where a bad handling of COVID has resulted in an appreciable drop in popularity? Even Donald Trump, though people polled think he handled the pandemic poorly, his 538 approval on Jan 1st was 42.6% and his approval now is 42.2%.
- arethuza 6y agoI don't think it's done much for the Boris Johnson government here in the UK: https://yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/trackers/boris-johnson-approval-rating https://yougov.co.uk/topics/politics/trackers/boris-johnson-...
- tzs 6y agoNote, though, that he went up to almost 46% which is the highest he has had since right after he took office, when COVID started becoming serious in the US and it briefly looked as if he might handle it somewhat competently.
- UnpossibleJim 6y agoWhile this may be true, one is carried on a news cycle for a longer period of time. Weather events are a normal and predictable happening, so the "shock and awe" don't carry the ratings necessary for the news coverage, regardless of the human tragedy. Unfortunately, our society's attention span for weather tragedy is short and it is very unlikely any federally funded memorials will be built for victims of wildfires, floodings or hurricanes.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoI don't know about that. Katrina was in the news for a long time, as a bunch of people were in the Superdome. Then there was news coverage of people trying to recover and rebuild. Katrina is still in the public consciousness, even today. (I mean, so is 9/11. My point is, I think the claim "one is carried on a news cycle for a longer period of time" is wrong.)
- thatcat 6y agoPeople can’t disagree with and hate hurricanes the way they do other people.
- saagarjha 6y agoPerhaps, but some apparently think they can with global warming.
- malandrew 6y agoIt doesn't last though. Without doing the math with dates, do you intuitively remember what administration was in power during 9/11? How about Katrina? Benghazi? Hurricane Andrew?
- 24gttghh 6y agoactual guesses: W Bush, Also W Bush, Obama, and...Clinton? Pretty close on the last one. It was the end of HW Bush's term in '92.
- cafard 6y agoKatrina helped take the shine off the GW Bush administration.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- dylan604 6y agoDid Maria have the same effect to the current administration? Maria devastated Puerto Rico, and the gov't response was embarrassing.
- 24gttghh 6y agoyes, all of the embarrassing/horrendous things the current admin is doing/has done...certainly embarrass them to a majority of the population. They really should be ashamed, but of course they aren't.
- ashtonkem 6y agoThis is a classic problem with power; it’s not uncommon for people in power to confuse what’s good for the country with their own self interest. It really shouldn’t be the FEMAs job to weigh disasters based on political impact; that’s not their mandate. Their job is to help with disasters, and with hurricanes being so common they should focus their efforts there.
- bhupy 6y ago> This is a classic problem with power; it’s not uncommon for people in power to confuse what’s good for the country with their own self interest. It reminds me of a quote by Milton Friedman: "Is it really true that political self-interest is nobler somehow than economic self-interest?"
- sudosysgen 6y agoIt's undeniably true when political power is distributed to the masses, and less and less true when it concentrates. Basically, the more democratic the political system, the truer it is. Which hints at the fundamental nature of political self-interest versus economic self-intrest - economic self-interest is fundamentally alienating while political self-interest conforms to both material and immaterial goals.
- bhupy 6y ago> It's undeniably true when political power is distributed to the masses, and less and less true when it concentrates. In other words, it's only "undeniably true" in a direct democracy, where the people vote to decide on everything. Otherwise, you have the same centralization of power (a representative by definition has more power than their constituent), and you have to hope that they will act in the public good. I'm not sure that you can reasonably claim that every person in Congress today is virtuous. > economic self-interest is fundamentally alienating That's for sure a popular claim, but it's not really backed by any evidence other than the way a handful of people feel. And that's largely driven by ideology rather than mass empirical evidence. The entire developed/industrialized world largely operates on economic self-interest, and life in the 21st century is, by pretty much all measures, better than life at any other time in the past.
- trophycase 6y agoOur government threatens their credibility just fine by themselves.
- Zenst 6y agoMay be down to many aspects and insurance certainly would be a factor in gauging risk/costs for the number crunchers when creating budgets. Given hurricanes tend to fall into the act of God clauses and Terrorism tends to fall into its own special category of exceptions/coverage extra's. That along with overall impact upon society and fiscal impact. Does get down to hurricanes you can't prevent, only clean-up and terrorism you have a better chance of preventing - also when people die from the later - they are more inclined to place anger at the government/administration over hurricane victims. Terrorism - case of dammed if nothing happened and you spend money, and dammed if something does happen irrespective of how much money spent. Certainly - would people feel better if the government spent less on terrorism and just put it down to something people have to just accept could happen and part and parcel of living in a city! That won't traction well with many people I'd say. Yet the people have that mentality towards hurricanes - they accept they will happen, unlike terrorist acts and that kinda see's why budgets are the other way.
- roywiggins 6y agoKatrina definitely did.
- marcosdumay 6y agoHow does that work? Does the US people give a monolithic credibility rating to the government? Whose credibility exactly is that? I bet FEMA's credibility suffers more from a badly handled natural disaster.
- AnimalMuppet 6y agoBungling of highly-visible things by agencies of the executive branch reflect affect the credibility of the president. As Truman said, "The buck stops here."