5 ms·
They operate under the rules of a powerful political jurisdiction which is not particularly friendly to the US. Here's a simplified version of how the governme
by kube-system 6y ago
They operate under the rules of a powerful political jurisdiction which is not particularly friendly to the US.
Here's a simplified version of how the government thinks about it:
If Facebook has data on a government employee, it's not a big deal, because Facebook stores that data in the US, and is friendly to the US, and if they do anything bad, they ultimately answer to the laws and regulations of the US government. These things are not necessarily the case for TikTok data.
This is pretty much the first time that a service operated under the laws of a US rival has become popular in the US.
- 2rmm 6y agoWhy hasn't this been a problem for Zoom? If somebody has data about government employees or even recordings of meetings then it is Zoom, not TikTok.
- netsharc 6y agoThe joke is, kids/K-Pop fans communicated on TikTok to "prank" Trump by buying tickets to his rally and not showing up, making him look bad, and 10 days later Trump started roaring about the app. Of course Fox News, etc, claim "this Chinese app is subverting democracy", etc, but IMHO they were just using it to communicate...
- michannne 6y agoI would hope the majority of people who are aware of international affairs do not think so lowly of the American people, so dimly of American government, and so shallowly of international politics, that they'd believe our president would (or be allowed to, for that matter) coordinate a government-wide subversion campaign with far-reaching consequences over a prank
- modalkb 6y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24290910 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24290910
- martin_a 6y agoWe're still talking about Donald "grab them by the pussy" Trump here, aren't we? ANYTHING is possible in the USA since that guy got president.
- michannne 6y agoYou do realize Barack Obama fucked his wife right? Multiple times as they have 2 children. They probably talk dirty to each other when they're alone, like almost every other couple that exists. Should I now think less of Obama on the off chance he secretly spanks his wife in bed? My point is you have to be very far removed from society to believe that no one has ever talked in a vulgar fashion, especially in a country as sexualized as ours. And to then equate vulgar chat in private conversation somehow with the idea that nonsense is suddenly an acceptable state for Americans. You can think what you want.
- netsharc 6y agoFrom your 2 replies I'm presuming you are a Trump defender, at least you're denying parts of reality and twisting facts so they conform to your image of the world (that he's a good, at least decent president, and that you're not an idiot for supporting him). Sorry, the issue isn't the private conversation, the issue is that the contents of that conversation was him saying he can get away sexually assaulting women because of he's a "star". If Barack Obama was recorded saying something like that while talking to friends, would you defend him?
- michannne 6y agoYes of course, because anyone who would dare to not fill their post with detriment of the president, must in fact also support the president, contrary to any information otherwise. Assume what you want, I don't support Trump and apparently I don't need to attract hate from others like you, not that I am in any way suprised. >If Barack Obama was recorded saying something like that while talking to friends, would you defend him? I wouldn't care. Not a single bone in my body would resonate emotionally with what he said, because seemingly I have the rare, esoteric knowledge of understanding that humans will talk about particularly dirty topics when they're with friends.
- erklik 6y agoI mean this is the same President who falsified a weather map using a sharpie because it violated what he had said earlier in mistake (I am guessing it was a mistake). He was allowed to coordinate a government-wide campaign that was impacting a large amount of people, and violated various integrity codes of NOAA and resulted in citizens being provided with false information, as well as eroded the trust of people in an integral agency.
- seanmcdirmid 6y agoCome on, this is Trump we are talking about, all form of reason and decorum was thrown out the window along time ago. Whether he is allowed to or not is up for the courts to decide.
- netsharc 6y agoNot sure about the majority, but I do think dimly of the American government. Especially the last 4 years. As for the people? When they vote in QAnon supporters into congress ( https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-election-congress-conspiracy-idUSKCN2591C9 https://www.reuters.com/article/us-usa-election-congress-con... )... But on being "allowed to", incredibly Trump is surrounded by Yes-Men, and it seems only fools dare accept his appointment, even fools whose reputation was great so far in their lives: https://www.bostonglobe.com/opinion/2018/12/10/john-kelly-leaves-white-house-with-his-reputation-tatters/G9RS2iyzKgi1atydmsQvZP/story.html https://www.bostonglobe.com/opinion/2018/12/10/john-kelly-le... . Of course there are a lot things Congress and Senate can do to block him (but Mitch McConnell is another Yes-men, what is it with conservatives and their lack of spines?), but in the example of TikTok, he used executive order to demand the stuff.
- modalkb 6y agoI do, as an indian भारतीय think pretty low of Americans who would lap up propaganda because it comes from their preferred party. When it's Bernie "open borders is a koch brothers idea" Sanders then he is a messsiah for the poor, but when it's trump, he's a dotard. When it's Clinton "blacks are superpredators" , she's an angel, but when trump tries to give college fudings to blacks, he's racist. Liberal leftists are living in their own world and their failure to accept truth is what causes them to be constantly outraged
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoWeChat is a more credible threat but the anglosphere media is mostly ignorant of them so TikTok it is.
- kube-system 6y agoWeChat isn't a threat because barely any Americans use it.
- kevin_thibedeau 6y agoMany Chinese Americans use it to communicate with family. Some of them work on sensitive programs and are easily monitored by a multi app with broad permissions.
- seanmcdirmid 6y agoChinese immigrants are the primary users in the states, and they don’t use it for any economic transactions in the USA, obviously (stores might support wepay, but that is targeted at Chinese tourists).
- kube-system 6y agoThat is why I said “barely any”, instead of “zero”.
- kmonsen 6y agoThe executive order targets wechat as well.
- kerng 6y agoIsnt Trump's action including Wechat/Tencent as well?
- kube-system 6y agoThere have been some concerns about Zoom, but as far as why the feds don't care as much? Not sure, but if I were to guess: * I bet feds and their employees/contractors are not using zoom for official business * Most people aren't really putting their personal lives on zoom outside of work
- shafyy 6y agoZoom is a US company
- vacuum04 6y agoAnd zoom is not controlled by a Chinese company under the control of CCP
- threeseed 6y agoBecause I can file a lawsuit against Zoom or I can speak to the press and have them investigate any evidence I may have. You can't do either with a Chinese company.
- seanmcdirmid 6y agoYou can file a lawsuit against any company that operates in the USA.
- coliveira 6y agoTikTok is not a Chinese company, it operates under US laws. You're just repeating disinformation spread by the US government.
- kube-system 6y ago> TikTok is not a Chinese company, it operates under US laws. TikTok is a subsidiary of ByteDance which is headquartered in Beijing. It operates under US law, and it operates under the control of a parent company that operates under CCP control. > You're just repeating disinformation spread by the US government. The claims made by the person you are responding to are not things the US government has said. In fact, you can file suit against foreign companies in the US -- this person's misunderstanding of the situation has nothing to do with the US government's stated concerns.
- russli1993 6y agoBytedance is incorporated in the Cayman Island, its not a Chinese company. It has a subsidiary in Hong Kong that operates the Chinese business. Its this portion of the business that has to adhere to Chinese laws. The rest of the company, including the US subsidiary is not under the jurisdiction of Chinese laws, and the US subsidiary fully owns TikTok. The data storage and content moderation are all handled by US employees. If the parent company or Chinese government is forcing US employees to censor based on Chinese government demands or steal US data, I am pretty sure US employees would have said something by now. Instead, they seem to proud of the security work they have done. I have seen a lot of anti-China videos on TikTok. The US subsidiary of Bytedance that operates TikTok is subjected to US jurisdiction and US laws. US government has equal amount of control over it compared to Facebook. TikTok was sued and fined before for breaking under age related laws. Bytedance's CEO is Zhang yiming, is a Chinese national. And its board has one Chinese national and three non-Chinese nationals. It's owned by a number of international investors, these investors likely have a say in the company as well. These people would not have built a company with Chinese government DNA. Zhang yiming himself has criticized the government in the past. Although he has toed with Chinese government lines in China because he has to. But he personally admires the US and its political culture. The management is also saying they are moving HQ to other countries. I think given the management's mindset, they really want to deal as little with the Chinese government as possible. Working on behalf of the government, nah, its not their mindset. To be honest, it might be even smart for the US government to lure Bytedance management, get them to declare they support liberalism and American values and use Bytedance to spread American values to China. Instead, US gov's action to force a sale is basically extortion and coercion. And having government take a huge chuck of the transaction is stealing personal property. It goes against all that US stands for, rule of law, justice, protection of private property. There are a lot of people in China loves the US and American values like the above, in turn they emigrate to the US and hate Chinese government. That image has definitely being broken a bit by all of this.
- coliveira 6y agoThere is no point in showing facts, people here are operating under Trump's misinformation spell. They think china is in every corner trying to steal their data (of course Facebook has already done this first, but who cares).