10 ms·
Robots that can walk are now striding to market
- sradman 6y agoBoston Dynamic's four-legged Spot [1] and bipedal Atlas [2]. Agility Robotic's Digit [3]. It looks like robotic actuators are about to hit an innovation wave. [1] https://www.bostondynamics.com/spot https://www.bostondynamics.com/spot [2] https://www.bostondynamics.com/atlas https://www.bostondynamics.com/atlas [3] https://www.agilityrobotics.com/meet-digit https://www.agilityrobotics.com/meet-digit
- Robotbeat 6y agoQuasi-direct-drive actuators (BLDC motors with position Feedback and a modest, 5:1 or 10:1 gear ratio) are what you’re thinking of for Spot and similar. For Atlas, you kind of need the specific force and low speed specific power than hydraulics give you. That’s what Boston Dynamics uses for those larger dynamic robots (Atlas, Big Dog, etc). (Hydraulics are under-rated! They can be electrically pumped, so they need not be super loud.)
- forgotmysn 6y agoactuators and slip rings are going to change the game for robotics
- k__ 6y agoare they a suitable alternative for wheelchairs? Because of stairs, etc.
- lowdose 6y agoThis is an unexpected original application. Do you think people in a wheelchair would like to upgrade to a robot?
- k__ 6y agoDon't know. But maybe it would 1. allow them to stand 2. allow them to use stairs
- jon_richards 6y agoThat’s starting to sound like an exoskeleton
- ufmace 6y agoIf we're going in that direction, might as well get rid of those useless bio legs and replace them with robot legs
- k__ 6y agoI'd assume some people aren't fond of surgery.
- tgflynn 6y agoI think a bigger problem is that there isn't really a good safe way to directly interface a human limb to a mechanical one. Conventional prostheses distribute weight over tissues that didn't evolve to carry those loads and are therefore much less comfortable than a natural leg.
- ufmace 6y agoMmm yeah, I suppose you'd have to figure out a way to connect up to bones for structural support and to connect actuators to. But hey as long as we're dreaming big, why not?
- k__ 6y agoI'm not dreaming big. I just asked if we could strap people to these things to let them climb stairs, lol
- samcheng 6y agoA previous attempt (dynamically balancing wheelchairs) was the progenitor to the Segway: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBOT https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IBOT
- jpm_sd 6y agoLooks like they are working on a relaunch (re-relaunch?) https://mobiusmobility.com/ https://mobiusmobility.com/ I think unfortunately the main reason the iBot did not originally succeed is that it was too expensive.
- tlb 6y agoCost was a big factor at ~$400k. Also, it was heavy (~100 kg IIRC) so it shook the whole house going up stairs. Also, it was too wide for stairways in older houses. And, if anything went wrong halfway up the stairs, you'd be going down ass-over-teakettle strapped to something metal weighing more than you. All those things could be improved on. Maybe Mobius will succeed.
- adrianmonk 6y agoCould also be useful for movers. Right now when it's time to carry that heavy desk, couch, piano, etc. through doorways, halls, up/down stairs, etc., two really strong people do it manually. Imagine if they showed up with a robot that could do it. In addition to walking, it would need to understand gripping and balancing heavy objects and how to orient and maneuver 3D objects through tight 3D spaces, but I bet those things are understood well enough.
- ufmace 6y agoHaving worked as a mover for a while once upon a time, I don't think it would make much difference as it is now. It's very rare for any moving job to require more physical strength than an average adult male has. The challenge is more like understanding how to handle items without damaging them or the building, what order to move things in so that a truck can be packed well. We'll need a lot more real-world intelligence from robots before they can do something like that. Unusual physical strength, or powered mechanical aids, are mostly only used with unusual items. Ex, most "gunsafes" are more properly Residential Security Containers, and aren't all that heavy (~200lbs) and can be moved around, including up stairs, by two average adults. Real safes weigh more like 600lbs and are much more rare, partly due to the difficulty and expense involved in moving them anywhere remotely tricky. I have heard of powered stair climbers being used to lift such things up a flight of stairs.
- silvestrov 6y agoThis sounds like you're used to moving between suburbs and not old European multi-storey buildings with narrow stairs without elevator and no ability to use an external lift due to small windows.
- ufmace 6y agoA good mix of types of places. Some suburbs, though they sometimes have awkward internal stairs. Plenty of American style 3-story apartments, their stairs mostly aren't too bad. I dunno man, it mostly isn't that tough once you get used to it.
- golemiprague 6y agoSolving the issue of climbing on stairs seems to be much more simple than a robot with legs, there are already solutions in the market, most of them based on wheels or tracks
- samcheng 6y agoYoutuber Marques Brownlee had a cool video on Spot last week. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s6_azdBnAlU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s6_azdBnAlU His takeaway was that the big use cases currently are around LIDAR and mapping, e.g. tracking construction progress, in irregular / uneven terrain. I'm less convinced that walking robots are useful for some of the use cases described in the Economist article, like moving boxes in a warehouse. After all, warehouses are generally built to facilitate wheeled vehicles (forklifts) already...
- clairity 6y agoyes, it's been common knowledge in biomechanics that wheeled vehicles win on flat surfaces, hands down (ha). legs are good for the 99.9% of earth's land that isn't nearly as predictable. the general utility of accessing that 99.9% is relatively dispersed though (and hard to build a business on).
- Robotbeat 6y agoSimply using big wheels or tracks work for non-flat surfaces, too, and are cheaper & more efficient (especially the wheels). Legs allow you to climb, ie a ladder, very steep stairs ( more than 45 degrees), a tree, or an extremely steep rough slope (think: mountain). A tracked vehicle or large-wheeled vehicle can go almost anywhere a legged robot can go with a large efficiency and cost advantage. However, you can run into space constraints. Bipedal robots are good for navigating human-scale environments while still having a tall and stable robot. But generally, tracks or big wheels are way cheaper and more efficient and can do the same thing.
- clairity 6y agosure, bigger wheels and tracks can get you some greater percentage of navigable land, but nowhere near 100%. most terrestrial animals uses legs and not wheels for a reason (and it's not because it's not evolutionarily possible). but yes, bigger wheels and tracks probably cover a greater percentage of the commercially viable landscape.
- jariel 6y agoPlease make me some AI that can clean my toilet, do my laundry and make me a ham sandwich. This will be the revolution.
- ipnon 6y agoThis is disparagingly referred to as momtech. Young silicon valley transplants try to replace the role of their parents with technology. They want to avoid cooking and cleaning so they can code all the time. "If only a robot could do my dishes for me!" It's the epitome of fitting a solution to a problem. Cooking and cleaning are simple tasks that any able bodied person can do themselves. There is no shortage of able bodied people in the world.
- tlb 6y agoA good rule of thumb when dismissing some new technology is to ask, "what previous technologies would I have dismissed for the same reasons?" And if those technologies became successful, try to learn from the mistake. In this case, clothes washing machines and vacuum cleaners seem to fit your thesis.
- function_seven 6y agoAnd the Roomba fits this rule of thumb again by replacing the vacuum cleaner (which replaced, what, taking rugs outside and beating them with sticks?) On a tangent: How was wall-to-wall carpeting cleaned before the invention of the Hoover? Did it just not exist before then? Or it just collected dirt until it was replaced?
- melling 6y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carpet_sweeper https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carpet_sweeper
- function_seven 6y agoOof. We had one of these growing up, so I know about them. Just didn't remember it when I replied. Still useful for collecting crumbs around restaurant tables.
- DenisM 6y agoSo how about some Mountain-Boting[#]? Riding a BigDog" on the mountain bike trails at crazy-stupid speeds. [#] Mountain-Boting is now a word
- Animats 6y agoThe slow march to cost-effectiveness continues. But no killer app yet. Much of this is a mechanical design problem. You need to be able to generate large forces from a small package, but not all the time. Hydraulics can do it, but then you need a big pump and power source, like the older Boston Dynamics machines. Until recently, all-electric didn't have the power density. Now it does. Which is why quadrotor drones work. Small polyphase permanent magnet motors ("brushless DC") have taken over. The controllers to drive them at variable speed are now cheap. No brushes, no arcing, no magnet demagnetization. The remaining limit on motor power is cooling. It's too bad Schaft Robotics was liquidated. They were doing well on humanoids. Then Google bought them, trashed them, and dumped the remains. They were into small liquid-cooled motors. That's a way to get huge torques when you need them. Reduction gears are always a problem. If they're big enough not to snap gear teeth on shock loads, they're too heavy. Better materials for toothed belts have helped. Those have more space to absorb a shock load. Researchers like harmonic drives, because they can put a big reduction in a small package, but harmonic drives are especially vulnerable to broken gear teeth on overload. Direct drive, without gears or belts, would be nice. The advantage of direct drive is, as someone said a century ago in the context of electric locomotives, "You cannot strip the teeth of a magnetic field." Washing machine motors are often direct drive today. The electronics is cheaper and more rugged than a gearbox. It's encouraging seeing that happen in a mass-market product. There's a lot of engineering like that which needs to be done to get mobile robots down to the price of a non-luxury car.
- pharke 6y ago> Then Google bought them, trashed them, and dumped the remains. This seems to be a too oft repeated refrain. Google has become such a mire of intra-office politics that being acquired by them is almost a guaranteed death sentence.
- Ygg2 6y agoGoogle is the new IBM.
- andromeduck 6y ago
- neonate 6y agohttps://archive.is/D0rEJ https://archive.is/D0rEJ
- elihu 6y agoIs it possible to make one of these robots cheaply? It seems like the cost of actuators (which you might need dozens of) and to a lesser extent sensors would make this cost-prohibitive for most uses. For instance, if you were replacing a human salary, it might make sense to purchase a hundred-thousand-dollar robot, but if you just want something to pull weeds in your yard once in awhile, it might be hard to justify spending more than a couple thousand. If the parts alone cost tens of thousands, then that's a pretty big economic limitation on how the technology gets used.
- banmeagaindan2 6y agoI don't believe robots will have human level walking skills in our lifetime. This is something that looked easy for 70 years. Hans Moravec described why it was harder than it looked. It is possible to look impressive by pouring in more brains and money but unless you have a general purpose breakthrough it can not be useful and economical. AI vs AGI is well understood in cognitive tasks but tasks that require motion would also require a parallel breakthrough.
- simonebrunozzi 6y ago> I don't believe robots will have human level walking skills in our lifetime. If "lifetime" can be considered to be the next 50 years, I absolutely disagree with you. I'd even venture to say that we will see robots with human level walking skills within the next 15-20 years, at most.
- banmeagaindan2 6y agoI assume you are the famous simone of youtube robot fame. I just speak as outsider looking in. I like robots. It would emancipate society to a new level of existence. I have trouble believing they are real - and have dark ideas about what robots really mean in our society - that they might be a symbol of something like a political belief in a sort of utopia in much the same way the Soviet and Fascist investments in science were not value neutral. I remember looking at some original robots developed around midcentury in England. They were inexpensive and very bad but did function basic functions. I look at the Boston Dynamics robots and see these are very expensive robots performing more natural movements. Let us suppose the BD and similar teams are at the half way point. To get human level performance at this rate of change means trillions of dollars. This robot would impress us - just as the original English robots and BD robots do. The French Empire invented expensive and difficult to create toys and no robot revolution started. I don't see anything continuous between the idea of a robot and the idea of machine automation - I think that is too much generosity. I know people want to give it because the field is very difficult - but this is not being honest. The ideal of the robot - people have different ideas about this - but the ideal for me is that there is an economical and effective alternative to human level physical articulation. I'm sure you have more advanced definitions - this is just the basic benchmark. It should be plausible for a robot to sew a thread or squeegee a window with grace. It is not just human level articulation - it's also generalist application. General purpose machine articulation looks like a high bar to the point it is difficult to imagine what the world would look like were we to be successful.