14 ms·
> Every single year since I was 12 and paid attention/tracked hurricanes As a non-US resident, I'd like to ask: International news make it appear as if the sit
by xg15 6y ago
> Every single year since I was 12 and paid attention/tracked hurricanes
As a non-US resident, I'd like to ask: International news make it appear as if the situation has worsened in the last years (Katrina used to be a once-in-a-lifetime event, now hurricanes of similar size occur every few years)
Is this impression correct or overblown?
Also, going by news coverage, the US seem to be hit by at least four large-scale destabilizing events simultaneously this year (hurricanes, wildfires, COVID, political tensions). Does this influence the general outlook on the hurricane season?
- jennyyang 6y agoEvery few years? Katrina was 15 years ago, and has been a relatively lull in hurricanes since then.
- _fullpint 6y agoIn Texas alone, Rita, Ike and Harvey were all devastating. I’m not sure what relation you’re referring to in “relatively.”
- jennyyang 6y agoOverall the number of hurricanes is down dramatically. 2 in Texas don't break that trend.
- _fullpint 6y agoThere are three listed there and two more on the way.
- gojomo 6y agoDown dramatically from what reference period? Over what region & time period? According to what source? (I grew up in Houston. I'm skeptical of those with short memories, new to the concern, who impressionistically consider every report of a hurricane as "so much bigger & more frequent than before", without actual analysis. But I'd want to see numbers, and a theory of causality, for any claim that they're "down dramatically".)
- cvhashim 6y agoSuperstorm sandy wasn’t much later
- thrav 6y agoSignificant hurricanes are not rare. Significant hurricanes landing in places that expose massive vulnerabilities in American infrastructure (the levees: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_levee_failures_in_Greater_New_Orleans https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/2005_levee_failures_in_Great...) are more rare and lead to catastrophes like Katrina.
- wtvanhest 6y agoCovid is the only destabilizing event, and it looks as though the US system of decentralization resulted in a variety of outcomes, but overall non-destabilization. Wildfires make the news bc they are inconvenient, but largely impact rural areas. Hurricanes are local events that cause damage, but US building codes largely prevent loss of life. Katrina is still a once in a lifetime event due to the flooding caused by failed levees. Political tension is nothing more than the rise of news entertainment. The two political parties are extremely similar. In 4 months or 4 years, Trump will be out of office and the news entertainment business will manufacture other controversies. The 3 big ‘problems’/destabilizing factors in the US are, student loans, massive prison pop, a great, but vastly overpriced health care system.
- NoOneNew 6y agoI'm mostly going to split hairs here. I mostly agree with you. But I'd say the real destabilizing problem in the USA has been the partisan attitudes in politics. You could almost claim that America is 2 countries, Democratia and Republica. That's how ridiculous our politics have become and why some of our problems, especially the ones you mentioned, have gotten so bad. I think they would always be "problems", but no where near as bad if all of our Congress would remember, "Oh wait, we are all Americas. We should be working together, not against each other." Edit: Why the hell are you getting downvoted so much?
- dcow 6y agoYep. Just yesterday I encountered a pocket of “radical” anarchists that literally want to “utterly destroy the other side before rebuilding a good society”. Since when is that normal?
- hanniabu 6y agoI'm in New Jersey, not Texas, but I can attest that the storms have gotten worse. We're also getting more tornadoes here when that was unheard of 20-30 years ago.
- NoOneNew 6y agoWhat do you mean by worsened? Frequency? Intensity? Recovery response? As a general sentiment, things have gotten better since Hurricane Andrew in 1993. That was the first, modern major wake up call for Florida. Massive changes to building standards, general infrastructure and environmental management. It's been constantly refined since. I also feel the Florida gov (state and local) takes hurricanes far more seriously compared to other states. Part 2. I recommend you try watching videos of "local Florida resident decides to ride out hurricane". Floridians are less afraid of death, generally. Every year mother nature threatens to kill us. It takes a lot more to scare us. Also, wildfires aren't a big deal here. Hard to believe, we have some of the best wildfire responses in the country. Our fire crews train throughout the west coast (most wildfires you hear about only happen in about 3 states on the west coast) on a regular basis so when they do spring up in Florida, theres a swift and hardcore response. Politics... eh, Orlando has seen the brunt of it. Most of FL is actually pretty racially diverse other than some really small pockets (where no one cares). I'm constantly told theres racial tension on the news, but in real life, no one here cares. At least in most parts of Florida. If you go to a Florida beach on any day of the week, you'll see every race sun tanning or swimming with or next to each other, having fun.
- kube-system 6y agoI didn't realize wildfires were possible under 4000% humidity.
- aphextron 6y agoFlorida has the highest number of lightning strikes in the US
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- gamblor956 6y agoHard to believe, we have some of the best wildfire responses in the country. Our fire crews train throughout the west coast (most wildfires you hear about only happen in about 3 states on the west coast) on a regular basis so when they do spring up in Florida, theres a swift and hardcore response. I had to laugh at that. The scale of wildfires between CA and FL is like the difference between a nuclear bomb and a sparkler. The reason that wildfires aren't a big deal in FL is because (a) the air is humid, damping fire growth and generally creating fire-adverse weather conditions like rain, and (b) the fauna is wet, so it doesn't burn as easily, quickly, or as hot. In CA in the summer, the air is dry and hot. Fauna can get so dry that it can be used as kindling, resulting in fires that spread to thousands of acres in under an hour, that burn so hot they can create their own self-reinforcing weather systems and even ignite fauna from a distance. You're also going to need to support your claim that FL fire crews train in the West, since based on all reporting from the last 4 years of CA fires, all of the crews were from Western states, as far east as Utah. (The last time FL news sources report a crew being sent to assist CA was in 2015.) At least in most parts of Florida. If you go to a Florida beach on any day of the week, you'll see every race sun tanning or swimming with or next to each other, having fun. That described my experiences in FL in Orlando and in beach cities. The interior and northern half of the state...was just as racist as I was led to believe it would be.
- adventured 6y ago> Katrina used to be a once-in-a-lifetime event, now hurricanes of similar size occur every few years Factually that's simply not accurate at all. The post 2005 era of hurricanes was docile by historical standards until 2017-2018. From 2005 to 2017 zero category 3 (or worse) hurricanes made landfall in the US. Most of those that did, were weak category 1 hurricanes. There was no increase in frequency either. Texas got hit by four category 3 hurricanes and one category 4 hurricane, in the span of just 22 years, from 1961 to 1983. Nothing like that stretch has been seen by Texas since. Texas also got hit by five category 4 hurricanes in just the span of six years from 1944 to 1950. Florida went 11 years between hurricanes, from 2005 to 2016, something that is exceptionally rare. They were hit / impacted by four in 2004 and 2005 by comparison. Katrina also wasn't a once-in-a-lifetime hurricane. It was a category 3, those have never been that rare. The disaster in New Orleans was overwhelmingly caused by people and their neglect of infrastructure.
- 9nGQluzmnq3M 6y agoI have no dog in the fight, but if this comment is actually wrong (as implied by the downvotes), it'd be nice to hear why.
- NoOneNew 6y agoIt's pretty much on the money. Infrastructure and preparedness are the real factors of surviving a hurricane. A majority of new houses and buildings in FL are now cement or steel construction in response to Andrew and then the 2004 hurricanes. Wood construction is not popular anymore. This doesn't include the massive waterworks projects all across Florida to mitigate flooding.
- JoshuaJB 6y agoPer [1], the comment appears to be partially correct. The data prior to 1950 does not agree with [1], but hurricanes were not tracked in the same way prior to 1950. The author may just using a different source for those estimates. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_hurricanes https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_hurric...
- topkai22 6y agoHurricane season is getting worse with rising average temperaturs, in the sense that storm frequency is increasing, but its also getting "worse" because so many more people and more infrastructure has moved to the gulf of Mexico area in the last 30 years. For example, Greater Houston has more than doubled in size in that time period, while the US has only grown by a third. Also, as others have noted, COVID is the only really abnormal thing going on- wildfires and hurricanes are annual occurrences. This year is worse than normal it looks like, but largely just part of life for the areas affected. The protests, associated riots and violence are more out of norm.
- jupp0r 6y agoI don’t think storm frequency is increasing, but the intensity of storms.
- badrabbit 6y agoThe water being hotter and lower air pressure contributes to bigger and slower storms. The land is also moee urbanized - nowherr for the water to go.
- blaser-waffle 6y agoHouston is the 4th largest city in the US, and is poised to overtake Chicago as the 3rd before too long. So yeah, a big ole hurricane smashing the 3rd largest city in the US would be big.
- vikramkr 6y agoIt depends where the hurricanes hit as well. Here in New York we just got hit with a little tropical storm (Isaias) and that caused a lot of damage and pain because the electric infrastructure is barely equipped to dea with a stiff breeze, much less a storm. Its like how Atlanta descends into anarchy when there's a little bit of snow. On the other hand if a cat 2 hit anywhere in the gulf I get the impression they'd know how to deal with it. Also helps that a lot of the trees down there are nice aerodynamic palms, while the trees here are just begging to be blown over
- cobbzilla 6y ago> Katrina used to be a once-in-a-lifetime event, now hurricanes of similar size occur every few years I think this is patently false, although you're correct that judging by news reports one might think otherwise. For some perspective on the relative damage of hurricanes over many years, this diagram [1] is pretty good. Katrina looks like a big statistical outlier to me. [1] https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-hurricane-names-are-retired/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/why-hurricane-nam...
- dontreact 6y agoThis graph is great. It does make it seem like there is starting to be a trend of increased damage in terms of dollars. If we have another one causing 30+ billion dollars of damage this year, it looks to me like there will be a clear trend.
- hcrisp 6y agoMore infrastructure being built by the coast would cause damages to go up, even if storm severity remained constant. Edit: Found an article which says just that. https://www.cnn.com/2018/09/12/us/hurricane-damage-cost-coast-development/index.html https://www.cnn.com/2018/09/12/us/hurricane-damage-cost-coas...
- dontreact 6y agoThat's a true statement. In the wider context of this conversation, I think it is important to emphasize that a big factor for continued development along the coasts despite an increasing trend in damage appears to be climate change denial From the article you posted: "But rather than adjust the state's plans for coastal development, the Republican-controlled legislature passed a law in 2012 that banned state and local agencies from using sea-level estimates that "include scenarios of accelerated rates of sea-level rise." The law required predictions to stick to historical trends, despite scientific evidence that sea levels are rising at an accelerated rate due to climate change."
- JimboOmega 6y ago
- riffic 6y ago> Katrina used to be a once-in-a-lifetime event uh, hurricanes have been hitting the southeast for hundreds of recorded years: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_hurricanes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_United_States_hurrican...
- serverholic 6y agoHe isn't saying that the southeast doesn't get hurricanes... He's talking about the severity of Katrina.
- riffic 6y agoand high intensity hurricanes have been devastating the region for decades. here's just one example for the Houston/Galveston area: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1900_Galveston_hurricane https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/1900_Galveston_hurricane Here's a list of previous storms that have hit the New Orleans area: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hurricane_preparedness_in_New_Orleans#Early_20th_century_hurricanes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hurricane_preparedness_in_New_... Once-in-a-lifetime is both incorrect and hyperbolic.
- ghaff 6y agoOr Camille in 1969 which flattened a significant chunk of the Gulf coast. https://www.weather.gov/mob/camille https://www.weather.gov/mob/camille https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hurricane_Camille https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hurricane_Camille
- jonwachob91 6y agoAnother long time florida man here Katrina was 15 years ago. Prior to that crazy sequence of hurricanes, the previous major hurricane was Andrew in 92. Very few cat5 hurricanes make landfall in the US as cat5s (unfortunately that isn't true for the Caribbean islands). These major storms have been par for the course for as long as records have been kept. One of the major reasons the British lost the Revolutionary War was a fleet with reinforcements was wiped out from a major hurricane while en route. The other large-scale events you mention aren't related to each other at all... COVID, politics, and California wild fires have nothing to do with hurricane formation... So I'm unsure how the presence of COVID and other stuff would increase the likelihood of a major hurricane this year...
- dragonwriter 6y ago> COVID, politics These two are intimately related, though none of them are related to hurricanes (well, wildfires and unusual hurricane behavior might have a common contributing cause in climate change, but that's pretty weak as a connection between specific individual events.)
- rch 6y agoCOVID is a complicating factor in hurricane and wildfire response, affecting e.g. senior care, shelters, and healthcare capacity. It follows that a hurricane could be considered "worse" this year given the preexisting load on the systems necessary to handle major weather events effectively. I believe that's the sort of influence the parent comment was alluding to.
- xg15 6y agoThanks for the info and context. > The other large-scale events you mention aren't related to each other at all They are not directly related by cause, however they are all happening at the same time - so the effects of those events could influence each other. COVID cannot cause a hurricane, but it could e.g. make evacuation plans more difficult. Effects of modern industrial society on the planet could be a common cause in an abstract sense: It causes climate change, which could influence the strength and frequency of both hurricanes and wildfires and it seems to be responsible for increased likelihood of zoonotic diseases due to loss if habitat. It's also one (of many) points of contention in the political situation.
- pdonis 6y ago> International news make it appear as if the situation has worsened in the last years (Katrina used to be a once-in-a-lifetime event, now hurricanes of similar size occur every few years) Is this impression correct or overblown? Overblown.
- adamsea 6y agoNice :). Pun intended, I hope :).