8 ms·
Redwoods not only survive the fires, they tend to proliferate afterwards. After lesser trees have been cleared out by the fires, redwood seedlings take root. R
by DoreenMichele 6y ago
Redwoods not only survive the fires, they tend to proliferate afterwards. After lesser trees have been cleared out by the fires, redwood seedlings take root.
Redwoods also thrive in low rain areas that are prone to fog because they benefit from the fog in a way that other trees do not.
I once suggested redwoods as an alternate or additional metaphor for giftedness re Stephanie Tolan's "Is it a cheetah?"
https://www.stephanietolan.com/is_it_a_cheetah.htm https://www.stephanietolan.com/is_it_a_cheetah.htm
My idea didn't get any traction, but I think we need more mental models than the "cheetah" one because that not only implicitly suggests that gifted kids are always fast, it also implicitly suggests that they are dangerous predators. While it is true that intelligence can make you a danger, I would like to see myriad metaphors proliferate and redwoods are at the top of my list as a metaphor I would like to see proliferate.
- mdonahoe 6y agoI was thinking redwoods are like rich people. Their scale gives them unfair advantages compared to other plants. Also metaphors make weak arguments.
- jupp0r 6y agoThey also get thousands of years old, which rich people might achieve in the future.
- phkahler 6y agoMaybe they already do.
- deleted 6y ago[deleted]
- DoreenMichele 6y agoAt the time, I may have been Director of Community Life for The TAG Project, which I believe is the the oldest set of email lists for the gifted community on the internet and they were trying to make the transition to a formal charity and never completed the process. So the audience would have been parents of gifted kids in need of support for how to effectively raise their kids and my opinion was somewhat respected for a fairly brief period of time in gifted circles online. It wasn't an argument. It was an attempt to share my thoughts with people who liked my thoughts on certain subjects well enough that it got me started blogging because there was demand for my point of view on some subjects.
- bitwize 6y agoNow there's no more redwood oppression, For they passed a noble law; And the trees are all kept equal By hatchet, axe, and saw.
- hardmath123 6y agoI believe the heat of a wildfire is literally the trigger for the cone to open up and release the redwood's seeds! (I don't know the exact mechanism for this, though.)
- khuey 6y agoYou're thinking of the coast redwood's relative, the giant sequoia. Fire dries out the cones causing the seeds to release.
- tingletech 6y agoseems to be the same tree? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sequoia_sempervirens https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sequoia_sempervirens edit: ah, Giant Sequoia is genus Sequoiadendron -- but both seem to have cones open by fire
- hangun 6y agoI think I saw this in a zombie movie once
- DoreenMichele 6y agoI don't know. I know there is a pine that does that, but I'm in rough shape and trying to stay out of trouble, which is challenging for me under the best of circumstances. I remember the pine cone of I think a yellow pine species opens up at 170 degrees, so it typically opens in response to fire. A quick google suggests it is called a Jack Pine. Hurricanes are also thought to be responsible for bringing fly species to islands and new islands end up having bird poo on them with seeds the birds ingested. Plants do this intentionally to let birds spread their seeds because birds lack teeth, so the seeds don't get chewed up in the process. Hot peppers are intended to be eaten by birds but not other species. They are hot as a form of chemical warfare against things they don't want eating them. Chocolate and maybe also coffee is bitter like it is to kill ants and if you have sufficiently dark chocolate (in, say, a tent), it doesn't attract ants. Milk chocolate attracts ants because of the sugar, but the cocoa itself is ant poison. Anyway, little islands form from volcanos and they start sticking up out of the ocean a little and they become resting places for birds and the bird poo is the first soil and fertilizer on these barren volcanic rocks and then coconut trees are typically the first trees because the coconut will float across the ocean without being killed by the salt water and land on some newly formed little island with a bit of bird poo and a few plants and it will take root. I think no other tree does that. If you get rid of all "disasters" entirely, you kill off a lot of stuff. Mother Nature or "mother earth" has fascinating and complex ways of letting life find a way and fire laying waste to some portion of the forest and leaving in its wake fertile soil and opening the cones of some pine species is just one of the fascinating ways she does that. Anyway, I have big plans to shut up on HN and attempt to go behave now by being elsewhere. Ciao.
- m3kw9 6y agoSo fires multiplies them
- crawsome 6y agoSo this whole thread is "Fires good because seeds on some Trees", right?
- DoreenMichele 6y agoNo. All my comments on the internet can be explained as "I have a serious medical condition and spend most of my time trying to distract myself from misery," a la: http://writepay.blogspot.com/2020/07/my-occupation.html http://writepay.blogspot.com/2020/07/my-occupation.html I know a little something about redwoods. I talked about redwoods. The End. I bear zero responsibility for how other people choose to interact with anything I have said.
- gdubs 6y agoNot all fires are created equal. While fires are a natural part of many ecosystems, many of today’s fires are more powerful and become “ladder fires” where a build-up of fuel on the ground causes the fire to reach the crowns and cause severe damage to even fire-resistant species.
- biophysboy 6y agoAm I being overly optimistic if I think "hey maybe the buildup of fuel on the ground goes away in a fire"?
- komali2 6y agoNo, but the point is if the buildup goes for too long, what the controlled fires were trying to prevent becomes reality: a firestorm strong enough to burn to the tops of the trees.
- njarboe 6y agoWhat is cool about coastal redwoods is that they can survive all of their branches being burned off (i.e., a tree topping fire). The redwood trees in the Oakland fire were just logs in the sky after the fire and now the ones that were not cut down look quite nice. You can see the sprouts coming out of the redwoods left in place after the Santa Rosa fire. And those were just young redwoods (<100yr old). The ancient redwoods have much thicker insulating bark layers and even some insulating bark on some of the larger branches. It takes a lot of heat for a long time to heat up a 12ft diameter insulated redwood tree enough to kill it.
- ummonk 6y agoOld redwoods have high canopies and prevent smaller trees / shrubbery from growing so they’re naturally unlikely to succumb to ladder fires. Also, they can regrow the canopy if it does burn.
- d33lio 6y agoOne of the coolest communities of people I met in the Bay Area / old school Silicon Valley (think Los Altos / Palo Alto) were the long-time residents who grew redwood sapplings in their garages / back-yards and planned regular excursions to maintain forests and to plant these saplings. For those who don't know, redwood / sequoia saplings take years to grow in captivity and are actually quite complex to collect and sow. To be frank, the Bay Area wasn't a great fit for me - but communities like this keep itching at me to move back from the east coast.
- leafboi 6y agoWhat you're saying is true, but this fire was not a good thing. Trees don't do well when you set forest fires year after year after year.
- nitrogen 6y agoIs it the same exact area burning every time?
- DLA 6y agoOne of my favorite investing books (wait for it, it ties in!) is The Dao of Capital [0] which is all about contrarian investing. Great read on investing and for the philosophical perspective as well. In the book Mark Spitznagel (investment manager for Nassib Taleb's black swan inspired hedge fund, Universa Investments) has an entire chapter on how conifer trees take advantage of fire-cleared forrest floors to propagate at a higher rate. Fire clears faster growing endosperm trees which tend to dominate slower growing conifers (cone droppers) in the early stages of growth. The fire cleaning allows conifers to productively seed the forest floor and get growing with less competition in their early years. In fact some cones actually use fire as a signal to drop and open to release their seeds. Fascinating. Very eloquent writing, IMO. [0] https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/16599562-the-dao-of-capital https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/16599562-the-dao-of-capi...