9 ms·
It is amazing that two disparate OS communities can take a shared codebase and integrate it deeply into their structure. There are many places where it would b
by ggm 6y ago
It is amazing that two disparate OS communities can take a shared codebase and integrate it deeply into their structure.
There are many places where it would be almost impossible to achieve this kind of share. Witness the 'compatability library' work which exists to avoid ABI blackholes running one platforms code on another platform.
BTW I have been able to carry FreeBSD ZFS LUN on a NetAPP and mount them on Debian ZFS, and vice-versa, since I started using ZFS. What we got here is better code alignment but with qualifications, ZFS has always been a common platform (with fringing differences)
I never had illumos or Solaris, I cannot comment on how well it would have worked.
- cryptonector 6y agoTwo?? Three. More!
- kev009 6y agoBrian Behlendorf and Matt Macy are both fantastic engineers, other people contributed but this is ultimately the kind of thing that must be led by a small number of (in this case two) extremely senior engineers working together for a common outcome with raw technical ability to get everything off the ground and prove it works; and refined leadership skills to stick around til it's actually done!
- nosequel 6y agoMatt (Kip) Macy also showed "refined" leadership when he > told workers in September 2006 to cut the beams that supported (his tenant's) apartment's floor... They also shut off Morrow's electricity, cut his phone line and had workers saw a hole in his living room floor from below, prosecutors said. So yes, he has really refined leadership qualities! https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/S-F-landlords-charged-with-tenant-terror-3217848.php https://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/S-F-landlords-charged...
- bjl 6y agoDamn what a shitstain. He should be in prison.
- tal8d 6y agoLooks like the CoC mob has failed to run off a capable developer... for all we know that tenant might have one day contributed code - this is a gross violation of "applicable spaces" clause!
- gjm11 6y agoWhatever does this have to do with codes of conduct? I mean, maybe software projects should have CoCs that say "do not do things likely to kill your tenants", but normally they're concerned with conduct within a project, and in any case "the CoC mob" seems to indicate you're somehow arguing against having and enforcing CoCs. Is there some background here that makes your comment make more sense than I'm currently able to get out of it?
- tal8d 6y ago> Whatever does this have to do with codes of conduct? Whatever does a rental property issue have to do with OpenZFS? What about political contributions? Are you genuinely unaware of all the crazy witchhunts, totally unrelated to the code base, that have occurred as a result of this CoC push? Have you ever heard of ESR? http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=8609 http://esr.ibiblio.org/?p=8609
- nosequel 6y agoTo be fair, I was originally replying to the complements about how amazing Kip Macy is, not OpenZFS. If the parent comment was about OpenZFS, I wouldn't have replied. I thought posting about Macy's multiple felony counts is a solid response about how amazing he is at leading folks. Also gtfo with your anti-CoC outrage with this. He didn't get caught using the wrong pronoun in a code comment. > Kip Macy is accused of three felony conspiracy charges, three burglary charges, two stalking charges, two grand theft charges and one felony count of shutting off service
- athms 6y agoThat is why Kip goes by his middle name now. He also moved from California to Washington. This was big news in SF Bay Area when it happened. It was FreeBSD's Hans Reiser moment. Another gem, Kip kicked one tenant in the chest while he was sitting on the couch and threatened him with a gun. I am curious if he ever reimbursed his parents after they drained their retirement savings and offered their house as collateral to pay for his $500k bail, which was forfeited after Kip and his wife Nicole decided to skedaddle to Europe instead of appearing in court. Kip continued to work on FreeBSD while on the lam in Italy with full knowledge of the core team, with many members actually defending his behavior. Kip and Nicole also never showed for the civil trial and lost by default. The original plea deal offered by the DA, before they absconded, was 6 months in county jail with charges reduced to misdemeanors. Instead, both were sentenced for 4 felonies and got 4.5 years (reduced for good behavior), with Kip ending up in San Quentin -- a maximum security prison housing California's death row. I remember ABC News did an interview with Kip while he was incarcerated and he blamed his tenants for all his troubles. At least he can no longer (legally) possess a gun since he is a convicted felon.
- kev009 6y agoillumos concern trolling, this has nothing to do with engineering leadership and is just lashing out a bad faith personal attack because you are friends with joyent people. Being unable to acknowledge that he served his sentence and is reformed indicates you are just hung up on a failed project that is as useful as spilled milk.
- scruffyherder 6y agoSo you follow every post everywhere to stalk, dox and bully. Stay classy.
- athms 6y agoSo that is what Kip was doing in Italy while being on the lam from the law. He is really dedicated. I wonder if San Quentin allowed him to code while he was incarcerated.
- znpy 6y agoWell you're citing netapp, zfs, freeebsd and debian. Those are all top notch. In all honesty I can't understand why would anyone use anything other than zfs nowadays for important data.
- vaylian 6y agoMaybe my understanding of ZFS is wrong, but what about storage requirements? As far as I understand ZFS, you take snapshots of all versions of all files and that can quickly lead to a lot of space usage. But maybe there is also an automatic cleanup tool that deletes old snapshots after some time?
- magicalhippo 6y agoYou take snapshots when you want to take snapshots, and a snapshot allows you to view the data as it was at the time the snapshot was taken. Not entirely unlike a git commit. The snapshot refers to the storage blocks/records on disk, not files as such, an important distinction since ZFS can expose block storage (zvol) as well as a "regular" file system. Since ZFS is copy-on-write, the only storage you pay for with a snapshot are the blocks that have changed since the snapshot was taken (plus a little overhead). Thus for data that does not change much, a snapshot is almost "free". The blocks are reference counted. Once a snapshot is deleted, ZFS decreases the reference count of the blocks referenced by the snapshot. Any block with a refcount of zero is considered free and thus that space is reclaimed. This happens when the block has changed since the snapshot was taken and there were no other snapshots referencing that block. ZFS itself has no automatic deletion of old snapshots AFAIK, but there are tools built around ZFS that allow for periodic snapshotting and cleanup.
- rakoo 6y agoSide-topic: the way you described how blocks and snapshots work is _exactly_ how git works, with references and blobs: as long as a blob can be reached by a reference (branch or tag), it will not be garbage-collected. Turns out a DAG, as is used in both ZFS and git, is a good data structure in many use cases.
- whereistimbo 6y agoHats off to anyone who involved there. Amazing achievement indeed. Edit: change heads up to hats off
- nucleardog 6y agoYou probably mean “hats off to anyone involved” — generally meaning to give praise. “Heads up” would give the sentence more a meaning of “warning to anyone involved”. Apologies if I’m being presumptuous or if this is just a late night typo. My wife speaks English as a second language so I know how confusing some of these idioms can be.
- whereistimbo 6y agoThank you for the correction. I'm not really sure about that but I type it anyway, hoping for correction from someone.
- eitland 6y agoI had to look up the "heads up" phrase a few years ago and IIRC it is a warning from baseball.
- y04nn 6y agoFreeBSD was staring to lack features compared to ZFS on Linux (ZOL), for example I'm not able to read encrypted datasets on FreeBSD but I'm able to do it on MacOS and Linux. More interoperability is very welcome.
- Crontab 6y agoI would like to see NetBSD follow suite but I don't know if they have the manpower to do so.
- hestefisk 6y agoFreeBSD used to need a kernel module called opensolaris.ko in order to load ZFS (not sure if that’s still the case). So whilst ZFS has been ported to many OSes, it still relies / relied on a paravirtualized Solaris kernel. Note: it’s not a critique; I love ZFS and use it to secure all my data.
- markjdb 6y ago"paravirtualized Solaris kernel" isn't really accurate - it's a collection of kernel interface shims. The whole thing is quite small, about 4KLOC on FreeBSD.
- temptemptemp111 6y agoThey're saying ZFS won't get the new SSD wear-leveling work that Ext4 et al are already getting. I'll have to Google to lookup the name of this next level TRIM technique.