5 ms·
I don't think mines quality as "AI", unless you stretch the definition to just mean anything under the sun.
by ekianjo 6y ago
I don't think mines quality as "AI", unless you stretch the definition to just mean anything under the sun.
- conception 6y agoI think they just meant that the military long left the “kill/don’t kill” decision along the wayside despite the propaganda of saying we have someone in control of the kill vector.
- ekianjo 6y agoThe whole discussion was about AI as far as I can recall.
- Dylan16807 6y agoMines are being compared as something that makes worse decisions but gets put in charge anyway.
- krustyburger 6y agoI think you’re right and I wish they would have just said that. It’s a good point.
- leafboi 6y agoBut AI's can qualify as mines. Sending out AI drones is like deploying mines that kill anything within a certain radius.
- ekianjo 6y agoAI supposes a certain level of complexity - if not we just use it a buzzword with virtually no signification.
- mlyle 6y agoYou're missing the point. The point is, we have very stupid systems making kill/no-kill decisions today if you step on top of them or drive by them. Slightly smarter systems making kill/no-kill decisions within a designated envelope should not be surprising.
- leafboi 6y agoI'm just saying the ethics of deploying AIs to kill is logically equivalent to deploying mines.
- supportlocal4h 6y agoAI _is_ a buzzword with questionable signification. The level of complexity is arbitrary. Maybe the AI won't blow something up unless it has a heat signature. Maybe it has to detect a pulse. Maybe it won't blow up something that emits a certain beacon. Maybe the kill has to be within a certain timeframe. Maybe the target had to have a certain mass. Which of these considerations qualifies as AI?
- klodolph 6y agoThat may be a valid technical complaint, but the problem remains—we create devices that are designed to kill humans, autonomously, without human decision inputs. From a different perspective you might think of guns and bombs as having similar problems—a human might decide to pull the trigger, but the human involved has limited control over who is killed and what is destroyed.
- chrisco255 6y agoWell let me know when the mines are walking around and deploying themselves. In the meantime they're not AI.
- klodolph 6y agoLet me know if I understand your priorities correctly—you care about whether the word “AI” is being used correctly, but you are not interested in discussing whether machines are autonomously killing humans? I think this has to be a pretty classic example of the way discourse can get derailed on HN, Stack Overflow, or the like—Alice has an interesting point to make, but Bob takes the floor to point out that Alice used a word incorrectly, even though he knows what Alice meant. The discussion about landmines is actually a good point—the legal language around landmines has evolved somewhat over the years and you might hear them referred to as “LAWs” these days, which stands for “Lethal Autonomous Weapons”. So many of the the same treaties will regulate both autonomous drones and landmines, with the same language.
- chrisco255 6y agoIt's not. Landmines aren't placed randomly. They also do not discriminate in what they kill. They are a simple explosive with a step trigger or proximity sensor. That does not an AI make. It completely deludes the definition of AI to call any switch based mechanism an AI. Words and meanings matter and it cannot mean whatever you want it to mean or it loses all capacity to communicate an idea.
- deleted 6y ago
- ip26 6y agoThere exists an even simpler AI program, wherein an edge is pressed against an object. If done so with sufficient force, the object is cut. This AI is called a knife.
- kranner 6y agoNot a good analogy. The human soldier driving the knife is the agent here, unlike the trigger or tripwire on a landmine.
- etaioinshrdlu 6y agoI know of someone who worked on face-recognition AI landmines for the US. They only explode if they recognize you. I don't think anything like that has actually been used though.
- JackFr 6y ago> They only explode if they recognize you. I’d go back and check with product on the requirements for that one. Sounds like the opposite of what I’d want.
- smabie 6y agoYeah but presumably your own troops know where your land minds are, so having them not explode if they recognized your face would be kind of stupid. I think maybe those landmines are supposed to kill specific targets, and avoid collateral damage.