4 ms·
We're already very much in a theoretical territory, but: Given small size, how do you detect a swarm? Hovering cubes would be ignorable noise to radars. At f22
by viraptor 6y ago
We're already very much in a theoretical territory, but: Given small size, how do you detect a swarm? Hovering cubes would be ignorable noise to radars. At f22 flight speeds, you can't exactly manoeuver around them.
If you knew where the plane is headed, the question could become: can you create a wide enough curtain ahead of time that can home in on the incoming plane? Chasing is not needed that way.
- baddox 6y agoIf you knew exactly where the plane is headed then, yeah, the drones might work.
- sliken 6y agoSure, and if you know exactly where a plane is headed than a anti-air missle, anti-air gun, or plane with radically less speed/agility would be fine as well. So that's a big if.
- nradov 6y agoThere's no way to put up that many drones at 40K feet. It's just impossible regardless of cost per unit. The sky is a big place.
- dodobirdlord 6y agoThe sky is too big, the distances are too large, and a fighter jet is moving too fast. What are these drones supposed to do, hope the jet flies close enough that the drone can act as a proximity mine? Plus, the kind of small drone you’re describing can’t operate at the altitude of a fighter jet. As the air thins out you need a lot of speed to keep sufficient oxygen flowing into the jets, and non-jet aircraft can’t operate. So unless the drones are going to be blimps, a drone that can climb to fighter jet altitude is going to be pretty big and look a lot like a fighter jet.
- onepointsixC 6y agoConsidering that a F-22's RCS is roughly the size of a marble, and it is expected to fight similarly stealthy aircraft I'd imagine that you're very much under estimating the ability of a modern jet to detect your swarm of tiny cubes. Next, how exactly do your cubes stay up in the air for long periods of time? You'd need a great deal of energy in order to fly at the altitudes which an F-22 would be flying at. And presumably to loiter up there for long periods of time. Suddenly your cheap tiny swarm is expensive, large, and unweildly.
- snowwrestler 6y agoAny large set of hovering things grouped tightly enough to ensure damage to a passing F-22 would definitely show up on radar. Flocks of birds show up; a flock of drones would too.