3 ms·
I hate hate hate this advice. I am a complete idiot at coding. And one of the biggest barriers to getting good at it is I don't even know how to ask good quest
by legitster 6y ago
I hate hate hate this advice.
I am a complete idiot at coding. And one of the biggest barriers to getting good at it is I don't even know how to ask good questions.
Online communities are already toxic places for newcomers. Ask a dumb question on StackOverflow and you get downvoted and griped at. I know I am an idiot! I know I don't understand what I am asking for! This is a cry for help!
>..which is just lazy. If you're not willing to do the work to solve your problem, why should we?
When I ask a vague, dumb plea, I am intentionally trying to weed out the pedantic people who would rather write a blog post about how dumb I am than stop to help me. If they have the time to follow up, they will have the patience to help me. Everyone else should move along.
If everyone has to stop and think of a logical and formalized way to ask a question, no one will bother asking for help. Think of every time you have reached outside of your domain - you would be so much worse off if you spent the entire time researching the right way to ask something than just asking for help.
In fact, I will turn it around. If you are not actually stopping to thoughtfully answer dumb questions, you are not actually teaching anyone anything.
- xboxnolifes 6y agoI disagree with the topic you think the piece is even about. The piece isn't about having a well thought out question at all. It's about not asking for permission to ask the question. People don't want to say "sure, I'm around" and then 5-10 minutes later say "sorry, I don't have experience with that". They want people to ask a question to the best of their ability and if they think they can help they will. The domain I'm thinking about in my example is tournament organizing. So many questions start off with. > Can someone help me? Or > I have a question. And want nothing else than a 'sure' or 'yes?' before asking their questions. But why not just ask the question / state the issue that is almost always already thought out as: > I'm having an issue with registering my team. Or > Am I eligible to participate if X? There was no long and thought out process of "logical and formalized" question forming here. It was just avoiding the waste of time between the asker having a question and getting an answer.
- jancsika 6y ago> People don't want to say "sure, I'm around" and then 5-10 minutes later say "sorry, I don't have experience with that". Yes, if only humans could outsource such desiderata to some kind of specialized "engine" that could produce human language sentence given a set of explicit data and instructions. Would this be the right forum to ask about how to design such an engine? Seriously asking because it doesn't look like anyone here has experience with solving such a novel problem.
- aaronchall 6y agoStack Overflow is a Q&A repository. We want you to be careful and think when you ask. We want you to distill the problem you have down to a minimal, reproducible example, so we can easily plug your code into an interpreter or compiler, make it work, and then answer your question. We also want you to demonstrate that you've made an effort yourself, not by saying "I've really tried," but by demonstrating your efforts with your post. We're still not guaranteed to recognize your efforts and good faith, but that's because we have the freedom to up- and down-vote posts for just about any reason whatsoever (excluding the posters themselves). What you seem to want is to do minimal work, and maximize the work required of the person you're seeking help from. If you want to ask for a customized lesson and tutorial, you can ask for that on Reddit, Quora, Yahoo Answers, or many other Q&A sites - but not on Stack Overflow.
- pwdisswordfish0 6y agoThe advice is not about not asking dumb questions. > When I ask a vague, dumb plea, I am intentionally trying to weed out the pedantic people who would rather write a blog post about how dumb I am than stop to help me. What you're really doing is whittling down your audience to only those who have a lot of time on their hands. (There's a lot of overlap between that group and the one you're trying to avoid.)
- jagger27 6y agoI don't get this argument at all. Here's an example hierarchy of shitty to good questions to drop in IRC: > I have a question > I have a programming question > I have a Go question > I have a question about interfaces in Go > How do you implement an interface of a 3rd party package in Go? Or perhaps if you don't know what you're asking for, maybe something like: > I'm not quite sure how to ask this, but how can I make my code work with library code? I think I heard something about interfaces? That's all the article is arguing: get to the point and try to be as specific as possible. As a beginner you're doing a disservice to yourself by throwing your hands up and declaring you have no idea what's wrong. It may well be the case that you have no clue what's going on, but it's such an important skill as a programmer to learn how to approach the unknown. Collect what information you can, try to build a mental model, and only then try asking a question.
- legitster 6y agoI am not an IRC user, so I don't really have a comparison. But I don't live in a world where people drop in and ask me enough questions that I feel the need to criticize the quality of question.
- hammock 6y ago"hey, can you do me a favor?" "Hey, are you free on Saturday?" These kinds of questions are what TFA is getting at. These questions are socially awkward and unaware.
- Hackbraten 6y agoWhat you wrote comes across to me as a false dichotomy. There’s not just _perfectly crafted_ and _zero-effort,_ there are infinitely many nuances between those extremes. No one expects perfection, or formally rigorous problem descriptions. People do expect a _reasonable_ amount of effort, no less but also not much more. Reducing effort to near zero out of spite (or whatever your motivation is) doesn’t feel constructive. Why not make an honest, good-faith attempt insteas to help others help you? Something like: “I’m trying to do X. Here’s my attempt but it doesn’t work. I’d expect my code to run successfully but it prints ERROR instead. What does the message mean and how do I fix it?” goes a long way already. Bonus points if you minimize your example and make it self-contained. (Note that I didn’t say “spend an afternoon polishing your example.” Just spend a couple of minutes deleting lines of code until you feel it’s small enough to be useful.)
- MaxBarraclough 6y ago> I am a complete idiot at coding. And one of the biggest barriers to getting good at it is I don't even know how to ask good questions. This is a skill that can be learned. Admittedly it's harder to ask good questions when you're very new to something (there's a higher ratio of unknown unknowns to known unknowns), but the point still stands. As a programmer, you have the good fortune of belonging to a very helpful community. Programmers, some of them highly paid, help each other out online, for free, all the time. If you're going to ask someone with highly valued skills to help you out free of charge, you have a duty to make an effort with the question you ask. Equally, if you fail to express your question well, you're not likely to get a good answer. Someone answering questions for free, in their own time, gets to pick which questions to answer, and your poorly-expressed question isn't going to make the cut. > Ask a dumb question on StackOverflow and you get downvoted and griped at. You're expected to follow the rules and make an effort. Lazy, vague questions, or questions that break the rules, or 'questions' that aren't questions at all, are meant to get downvoted. That's what the downvote feature is for. This shouldn't be a surprise, StackOverflow has rules and guidelines. That's not to say StackOverflow is perfect. There's some amount of silly pedantry and hostility. > I know I am an idiot! Probably not, and anyone saying you are should end up getting downvoted for flagged for being abusive. > I know I don't understand what I am asking for! This is a cry for help! But that's not the same thing as asking good questions. There are good and bad ways to ask basic programming questions, just as there are good and bad ways to ask advanced programming questions. > When I ask a vague, dumb plea, I am intentionally trying to weed out the pedantic people who would rather write a blog post about how dumb I am than stop to help me. This is counterproductive and, frankly, comes across as rather entitled. You aren't hiring a salaried employee, you're asking strangers to help you out free of charge. You're in no position to 'weed out' anybody. You'll get more and better answers if you ask your question well. > If everyone has to stop and think of a logical and formalized way to ask a question, no one will bother asking for help. This is absolutely the wrong mindset for StackOverflow. People submitting StackOverflow questions are expected to make an effort, just like the people who submit answers. The StackOverflow format isn't intended to be conversational and fast-paced. Care and consideration should go into both questions and answers. Asking questions skillfully works out better for the questioner, who is more likely to get a high quality answer. It's better for the answerers, who can see at a glance if your question is something they can help you with. Lastly, it benefits future users of StackOverflow who are searching for answers to similar problems. With sloppy questions, you won't get good answers, and you won't help build the site as a searchable repository of knowledge. > Think of every time you have reached outside of your domain - you would be so much worse off if you spent the entire time researching the right way to ask something than just asking for help. Outside StackOverflow, sometimes that may be true, such as if you're starting out at a new job and are assigned to another employee to teach you the ropes. On StackOverflow though, it isn't the right mindset at all. On a site like StackOverflow, it's vital to have high quality questions. You aren't having a conversation, you're contributing to a question-and-answer site, so do your part and put the effort in. Answerers enjoy answering good technical questions, but they don't enjoy the process of improving an unclear question. > In fact, I will turn it around. If you are not actually stopping to thoughtfully answer dumb questions, you are not actually teaching anyone anything. This confuses questions about basic programming, and poorly expressed questions that frustrate potential answerers. They aren't the same thing at all. With all that said, good news: asking good questions is a skill, so you just have to learn how, and then make the effort when asking questions. (People who say Just ask good questions! are doing a disservice, there's more to it than just telling people to ask good questions.) There are various articles on asking good questions, the best I know of is the classic by Eric S. Raymond, How To Ask Questions The Smart Way. I'm not the first in this thread to mention it. http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html http://www.catb.org/~esr/faqs/smart-questions.html
- njharman 6y agoYour attitude comes off as selfish and entitled. You're the one lacking knowledge, the one needing help, the one who can't figure it out themselves. The experts don't need to be teaching anyone anything. No one owes you anything. And if you demonstrate unwillingness or inability to formulate a proper question then they have every right to ignore you.