3 ms·
education is not a scarce goods - why not accept _all_ candidates that are good enough? The cost of educating one more student is marginal, and if there's a lar
by chii 6y ago
education is not a scarce goods - why not accept _all_ candidates that are good enough? The cost of educating one more student is marginal, and if there's a large enough number, economies of scale can kick in as well.
- blackbear_ 6y agoWorks for a bachelor but fails for a PhD, where students need to have a much closer relationship with their professors.
- Broken_Hippo 6y agoIf we simply cannot accept the PhD students that qualify and are willing, then maybe we are doing it wrong.
- avani 6y ago"qualify" is nebulous. When professors accept PhDs, they are looking for people who they want working in their specific labs. It is much more like applying to a job than applying to undergrad. I have pulled candidates from the pile who had sub-par test scores but excellent writing skills, for instance, because teaching good writing to adults is much harder for me than teaching computer science. Similarly, I've taken students who reached out to me with ideas for followup on my papers over students with great test scores who didn't seem to care what they worked on. Random sampling is a terrible strategy for PhD admissions.
- Aerroon 6y ago>education is not a scarce goods Education itself is not, but going to a top college is not the same as getting an education. If Bryan Caplan's idea of college being mostly about signaling[0] is true, then top colleges can't scale. They are an exclusive club and a lot of the benefits of top colleges come from being exclusive. Opening it up to more people reduces these benefits for the students. [0] https://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-caplan-education-credentials-20180211-story.html https://www.latimes.com/opinion/op-ed/la-oe-caplan-education...
- chii 6y ago> a lot of the benefits of top colleges come from being exclusive which is something i feel is a bad outcome for society in general, even if this is good for those individuals.
- frobozz 6y agoThe cost of filling one more seat in a massive lecture theatre is marginal. At university, I audited a number of courses with no impact on staff or students. The cost of marking one more essay and giving comprehensive feedback is more significant, even if there is a comprehensive rubric to hand it off to an assistant. The cost of running one more seminar/tutorial group for every 10 extra students is significant. A degree based on lectures alone, without giving all students the opportunity to ask questions, is less valuable. The cost of courses that involve more consumables (chemistry, biology) or more face-to-face interaction (languages) is significant per student. Economies of scale might work in the first term, where the the purpose is to get everyone up to a certain common (and quite low) level. Someone with only a first degree in the subject might be capable of teaching that. In later years, you can't all be taught by a world-class expert in the field. The cost of physically expanding a university is significant. It can also be very difficult. I once had a term when I had a 15-20 minute walk between adjacent classes, because the nearest place the university could expand into was an old school about a mile away.