3 ms·
This is getting tiring... No, nobody is insane enough to only use batteries. They are primarily used to load-shift by a few hours within a 24 hour window. This
by imtringued 6y ago
This is getting tiring... No, nobody is insane enough to only use batteries. They are primarily used to load-shift by a few hours within a 24 hour window. This is mostly useful for PV because it has a very low window during which it generates energy. Longer term storage would simply involve power to gas infrastructure. Alternatively you can use natural gas as your storage mechanism until power to gas has been implemented.
A lot of complaints against renewables are rooted in the myth of "baseload". For renewables to be effective they have to be available 24/7 except this is completely wrong. The atmosphere doesn't care if you pollute at 3 am or at 3 pm. A kilogram of CO2 is a kilogram of CO2. All you have to look at is how much renewable energy has been produced per year and divide it by total energy produced per year to calculate the renewable share. As long as that number goes up you're reducing CO2 emissions. Of course at some point you hit a roadblock where that share ceases to go up because you need to store energy but no country on earth has reached that point.
Here is an in-depth article that explains how 100% renewables could be implemented: https://cleantechnica.com/2020/02/09/correcting-anti-renewable-energy-propaganda/ https://cleantechnica.com/2020/02/09/correcting-anti-renewab...
- manfredo 6y agoExisting energy storage options other than batteries are either geographically limited, or not feasible. I explain the issues with natural gas storage in another comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24253317 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24253317 You can't just produce natural gas out of hydrogen and air, you need a source of carbon (and the fraction of a percent of the carbon in the atmosphere cannot feasibly be used). Yes, solar and wind can mitigate fossil fuel use in the short term. But there is no feasible way to use them for the primary source of energy without massive amounts of storage. It provides an option to produce some carbon-free energy, but does not provide an option to go from "some" to "all". If we actually want to stop climate change, we need to go for "all". The link you posted does not refute this. The solution proposed in the article is to just use fossil fuel backup plants until a storage solution is found. Germany and California are both already approaching the saturation point for daytime generation. And once you hit that point there's no way to keep going without massive amounts of storage to transfer the excess generation during peak hours to non-producing hours. Intermittent sources cheaply reduce carbon emissions in the short term, but offer no path to fully renewable energy without a miraculous advancement in energy storage. The paper you linked to doesn't refute this. The plan laid out amounts to, "keep burning fossil fuels and hope we eventually figure out energy storage". When the fate of the world is at stake do you want to bet on an unknown and unproven solution, or a solution that has successfully delivered the lion's share of a nation's power since the 1980s?